Note AcademyNote Academy

Physics YPH11 · Chapter 24

Practical skills

Planning an experiment, taking and recording measurements, processing results with graphs and uncertainties, and drawing conclusions, as tested in Units 3 and 6.

7 min read

Download this chapter (PDF)

Planning an experiment

Units 3 and 6 are written practical papers. You are asked to plan, describe or analyse an experiment, often one of the core practicals or one that uses the same ideas in a new setting.

What a good plan contains

  1. The aim and the variables: the independent variable (what you change), the dependent variable (what you measure), and the control variables (what you keep the same).
  2. Apparatus, with the right measuring instrument and its resolution (a metre rule to 1 mm, vernier callipers to 0.1 mm, a micrometer screw gauge to 0.01 mm).
  3. A method a student could follow: how to set up, what to change and by how much, what to measure, and how many readings to take.
  4. How to control the other variables so the test is fair.
  5. Repeat readings, to spot anomalies and find a mean, where random error is likely.
  6. Safety: the hazard, the risk, and the precaution (a clamp for a heavy mass, goggles for a spring that may break, a resistor to limit current).
  7. How the data will be used: what graph to plot and what its gradient or intercept will give.

Choosing and using instruments

  • Time a large number of oscillations or events and divide, to reduce the effect of reaction time. Use a fiducial marker at the centre of an oscillation.
  • Measure a long length where possible: the percentage uncertainty is smaller.
  • Use a zero check on meters and micrometers, and correct for a zero error.
  • Take a measurement across several positions for a diameter (a wire) and take the mean.

Choosing the range

Take at least 6 sets of readings across as wide a range as is safe, evenly spread. Show the values you would use, such as lengths of 0.20 m to 1.00 m in steps of 0.20 m.

Implementation and measurements

Recording

Record raw data in a table with headings and units (for example TT / s, ll / m). Give every reading in a column to the same number of decimal places, matching the instrument's resolution. A mean may have one more significant figure than the readings.

Errors and uncertainty

  • Random errors cause scatter in repeat readings. Repeats and averaging reduce them.
  • Systematic errors shift every reading the same way (a zero error, a wrongly calibrated meter). Repeating does not remove them; a different method or a correction does.
  • The uncertainty in a reading is at least half the smallest division, or the range of repeat readings divided by two.
CaseUncertainty
Sum or differenceAdd the absolute uncertainties
Product or quotientAdd the percentage uncertainties
Power xnx^nMultiply the percentage uncertainty by nn

0.125.0=0.4%\dfrac{0.1}{25.0} = 0.4\% and 0.031.50=2%\dfrac{0.03}{1.50} = 2\%. The percentage uncertainty in the product is 0.4%+2%=2.4%0.4\% + 2\% = 2.4\%.

Processing results

Graphs

Rearrange the equation into the straight-line form y=mx+cy = mx + c so that the gradient and intercept give the quantity you want.

Square it: T2=4π2g lT^2 = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{g}\,l. A graph of T2T^2 against ll is a straight line through the origin with gradient 4π2g\dfrac{4\pi^2}{g}, so g=4π2gradientg = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{\text{gradient}}.

When the relationship is a power law, y=axny = ax^n, plot lg⁡y\lg y against lg⁡x\lg x: the gradient is nn and the intercept is lg⁡a\lg a. When it is exponential, y=aekxy = ae^{kx}, plot ln⁡y\ln y against xx.

Gradient and its uncertainty

Take the gradient using a large triangle that uses more than half the line. For the uncertainty, draw the steepest and shallowest acceptable lines through the error bars and find the difference between their gradients, then halve it.

Anomalous results and conclusions

Identify an anomalous point and say what to do: repeat it, or exclude it with a reason. A conclusion states the relationship found (direct proportion, or yy against xx gives a straight line) and compares a result with an accepted value using percentage difference, relating it to the uncertainty.

Evaluating an experiment

Say what limits the accuracy and give a specific improvement:

  • Reaction time in timing: use light gates, or time more oscillations.
  • Parallax when reading a scale: view at eye level, use a set square.
  • Heat loss: insulate the apparatus.
  • Too few readings: take more over a wider range.
  • A zero error: check the zero and correct readings.

The core practicals

Be ready to describe, in outline, the method, the graph and the sources of error for the core practicals: acceleration of a freely-falling object; viscosity by the falling-ball method; the Young modulus; speed of sound with an oscilloscope; stretched-string resonance; wavelength by a diffraction grating; resistivity; e.m.f. and internal resistance; force and change of momentum; collisions; discharging a capacitor; a thermistor thermostat; specific latent heat; pressure and volume of a gas; absorption of gamma radiation; and resonance of an oscillating system.

Test yourself12 flashcards on this chapter.Flashcards →

These notes are AI generated and may contain mistakes. Check them against your syllabus.