Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 17
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
17 This question is about four isomers with the molecular formula C4H8O2. Name Skeletal formula O butanoic acid OH H OH 4‑hydroxybutanal O O ethyl ethanoate O O 3‑hydroxybutanone OH
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
17(a)[6]
This question assesses the student’s ability to show a coherent and
Guidance on how the mark scheme should be applied.
logically structured answer with linkages and fully sustained reasoning.
The mark for indicative content should be added to the
Marks are awarded for indicative content and for how the answer is
mark for lines of reasoning. For example, a response
structured and shows lines of reasoning.
with five indicative marking points that is partially
structured with some linkages and lines of reasoning
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for
scores 4 marks (3 marks for indicative content and 1
indicative content.
mark for partial structure and some linkages and lines of
Number of indicative marking
Number of marks awarded for
reasoning).
points seen in answer
indicative marking points
If there were no linkages between the points, then the
6
4
same indicative marking points would yield an overall
54
3
32
2
score of 3 marks (3 marks for indicative content and no
marks for linkages).
1
1
0
0
In general it would be expected that
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for
5 or 6 indicative points would get 2 reasoning marks
structure and lines of reasoning
3 or 4 indicative points would get 1 reasoning mark
Number of marks awarded for
0, 1 or 2 indicative points would get 0 reasoning marks.
structure of answer and
sustained lines of reasoning
If there is any incorrect chemistry, deduct mark(s) from
Answer shows a coherent logical
2
the reasoning. If no reasoning mark(s) awarded do not
structure with linkages and fully
deduct mark(s).
sustained lines of reasoning
demonstrated throughout
Comment: Look for the indicative marking points first,
Answer is partially structured with
1
then consider the mark for the structure of the answer
some linkages and lines of
and sustained line of reasoning
reasoning
Answer has no linkages between
0
points and is unstructured
Indicative content
1 IP for each test and positive result,
1 IP for the compound and the functional group.
Compound IP dependent on correct test or very near miss
IP1 sodium carbonate solution
Allow react with alcohol and (conc) H2SO4 and fruity
/ sodium hydrogencarbonate solution gives fizzing
smell for IP1 BUT deduct one reasoning mark (as ethyl
(due to the formation of carbon dioxide)
ethanoate also has a fruity smell)
Allow reactive metal such as magnesium giving fizzing
but do not award sodium / potassium
Allow produces gas
Ignore produces CO2 / bubbling through limewater
IP2 identifies butanoic acid is the only (carboxylic) acid /
Allow butanoic acid is a carboxylic acid
compound with an acidic proton / only compound with
–COOH
IP3 Tollens’ reagent / ammoniacal silver nitrate gives a silver
Accept Fehling’s / Benedict’s test gives a red precipitate
mirror
IP4 identifies 4hydroxybutanal, which is the only aldehyde /
Allow has a carbonyl group which can be oxidised
only compound containing –CHO
Allow 4hydroxybutanal is an aldehyde
IP5 iodine and sodium hydroxide (solution) gives a yellow
Allow ‘use of the triiodomethane / iodoform test /
precipitate / antiseptic smell
iodoform reaction’ / alkaline iodine
IP6 identifies 3hydroxybutanone, which is the only compound
Accept is the only compound with a secondary OH group
with a CH3CO‒ group / only compound with a methyl ketone
attached to a methyl group
group
If IP3 (and IP4) OR IP5 (and IP6) have been scored,
Allow 2,4 DNP and red/orange ppt as an alternative to the
other pair of IPs (IP3 & IP4 or IP5 & IP6) BUT deduct 1
reasoning mark
Ignore Brady’s reagent / 2,4 DNP other than as above
Ignore indicator / PCl5 / hydrolysis of ethyl ethanoate /
acidified potassium dichromate(VI) / ethyl ethanoate has a
fruity / gluey smell
17(b)(i)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
they / all (four isomers) have four carbon
Allow they have the same number of peaks
environment / produce four peaks
Allow they all have four carbons in different
environments
Allow they / all (four) have the same number of carbon
environments / peaks
Ignore just they all have four carbons
Ignore they have the same molecular formula
Ignore they have the same proton environments
Ignore they all have five different proton environments
Do not award they have the same peaks
Do not award the wrong number of carbon atoms
Do not award all have four different proton
environments
17(b)(ii)[3]
Name
Skeletal structure
Number of peaks
Two correct numbers of peaks
butanoic acid
4
Third correct number of peaks
4hydroxybutanal
5
Fourth correct number of peaks
ethyl ethanoate
3
3hydroxybutanone
4
17(b)(iii)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
If both are given, both must be correct
butanoic acid / CH3CH2CH2COOH
May be shown on a labelled diagram
Allow any formula showing structure including skeletal
formula to identify the acid
and
the hydrogen / proton in COOH
Allow COOH to indicate the proton
If name and formula are given both must be correct
Do not award positive ions such as [COOH]+
17(b)(iv)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
the quintet results from a hydrogen with four
This marking point is to justify the quintet.
hydrogens on adjacent carbons / the hydrogen is split
This may be scored within M2
by four other hydrogens
Ignore next to a carbon with 4 hydrogens attached?
because 4hydroxybutanal has (a carbon with) a
This marking point justifies 4hydroxybutanal as the
hydrogen / two hydrogens with four hydrogens on
isomer.
adjacent carbons
May be shown by a diagram indicating the either the
hydrogens giving the signal or the hydrogens causing the
quintet in some way for example
Do not award 4hydroxybutanal and arguments related
to having 5 hydrogen environments
(Total for Question 17 = 13 marks)
(Total for Section B = 52 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

