Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 18
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
18 Pentanoic acid, C4H9COOH, is a carboxylic acid with Ka = 1.38 × 10–5 mol dm–3. A student was asked to titrate 25.0 cm3 of 0.120 mol dm–3 pentanoic acid solution with 0.100 mol dm–3 potassium hydroxide solution. The equation for the reaction is shown. C4H9COOH + KOH → C4H9COO–K+ + H2O The teacher asked the student to sketch a graph showing the expected changes in pH as potassium hydroxide solution is added. The student first identified four key points for the sketch graph, using four calculations and one chemical equation. These points are shown. 14 13 12 Key point 4 11 10 9 Key point 3 8 pH 7 6 5 4 Key point 2 3 2 Key point 1 1 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Volume of KOH(aq) / cm3
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
18(a)(i)[3]
Allow any alternative methods
Ignore throughout ‒log100.00120 = 2.9
Route 1 – Solving the expression to find [H+]
Ka = [C4H9COO–][H+]
M1 expression for Ka
[C4H9COOH]
Allow use of [H+]2 [HA] and / or [A–]
Allow correct rearranged expression
= √1.38 × 10–5 × 0.12 This also scores M1
M2 uses expression to calculate [H+]
= 0.0012869 / 1.2869 × 10‒3 (mol dm–3)
Then
Either
= ‒log100.0012869
M3 calculates pH
= 2.8905 / 2.9
Or
= 0.0012589 / 1.2589 × 10‒3
M3 calculates [H+] from given pH
Or
= 0.00128692 = 0.12001
M3 calculates [C4H9COOH]
1.38 × 10‒5
Or
pH = pKa + log10([CH3COO‒] / [CH3COOH])
M3 uses HendersonHasselbalch equation to find pH
or
pH = ‒log10Ka + log10 [CH3COO‒] ‒ log10 [CH3COOH]
or
pH = ‒log10(0.0000138) + log100.0012869 ‒ log100.12
and
pH = 4.8601 + ‒2.8905 + 0.92082 = 2.8904
Route 2 – Equating expression for [H+] to expression for pH
Ka = [C4H9COO–][H+]
[C4H9COOH]
expression for Ka
pH = ‒log10[H+] or [H+] = 10‒pH
gives a mathematical expression relating pH and [H+]
10‒2.9 = √1.38 × 10–5 × 0.12
equates expression to calculate [H+] to 10‒pH
or
or
2.9 = ‒log10√1.38 × 10–5 × 0.12
equates expression to calculate [H+] to pH
Do not award a statement that ‒log100.00120 = 2.9
18(a)(ii)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Allow alternative methods
Allow TE throughout as long as the final pH is less than
13 and greater than 9
EITHER
Route 1
Kw = [H+][OH‒]
estimates concentration of H+
[H+] = 1.0 × 10‒14 ÷ 0.1 = 1.0 × 10‒13 (mol dm‒3)
pH = 13
calculates pH
and
so pH must be less than 13 as concentration diluted (by
Ignore incomplete dissociation of alkali
pentanoic acid solution / by reaction with pentanoic
acid)
OR
Route 2
= ‒log10[OH‒] = 1
estimates pOH
pH = 14 ‒ pOH = 13
calculates pH
and
so pH must be less than 13 as concentration diluted (by
Ignore incomplete dissociation of alkali
pentanoic acid solution / by reaction with pentanoic
acid)
OR
Route 3
calculates the concentration of OH‒ in 75 cm3 assuming
mol OH‒ = 0.1 × 50 × 10‒3 = 5 × 10‒3 (mol)
none has reacted
[OH‒] = 5 × 10‒3 ÷ 75 × 10‒3 = 0.066667 (mol dm‒3)
‒log10[OH‒] = 1.1761
calculates pH of this concentration
pH = 14 1.1761 = 12.824
(which is less than 13)
Or
[H+] = 1.0 × 10‒14 ÷ 0.066667 = 1.5 × 10‒13
pH = ‒log10[H+] = 12.824
OR
Route 4
[OH‒] = moles of OH‒ added ‒ moles of pentanoic acid
calculates concentration of OH‒ after addition of 50
Volume of water
cm3 to the pentanoic acid
[OH‒] = 0.00500 ‒ 0.00300 = 0.026667 (mol dm‒3)
75 ÷ 1000
pOH = ‒log10[OH‒] = 1.574
calculates pH
pH = 14 ‒ pOH = 14 ‒ 1.574 = 12.426
Or
[H+] = 1.0 × 10‒14 ÷ 0.026667 = 3.75 × 10‒13
pH = ‒log10[H+] = 12.426
(which is less than 13)
18(a)(iii)[2]
Example of calculation
(Neutralisation should occur at 30 cm3 because)
calculation of number of moles of pentanoic acid
= 0.12 × 25 = 0.003 / 3.0 × 10‒3 (mol)
1000
EITHER
= 0.003 × 1000 = 30 (cm3)
calculation of volume of potassium hydroxide
0.1
OR
calculation of moles of potassium hydroxide assuming
= 0.100 × 30 = 0.003 / 3.0 × 10‒3 (mol)
volume is 30 cm3
1000
18(a)(iv)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
Accept
the titration between a weak acid and a strong base
the product of the neutralisation / the potassium
(results in pH greater than 7 / alkaline pH
pentanoate / the pentanoate ion / the salt of weak
at the equivalence point)
acid forms an alkaline solution when dissolved in
water
Allow
C4H9COO‒ + H2O ⇌ C4H9COOH + OH‒
Allow some H+ (from water) will combine with
C4H9COO‒
18(a)(v)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
at 15.0 cm3 the concentration of pentanoic acid and
Accept this is the halfequivalence point
Allow numbers of moles of both = 0.0015 (mol)
pentanoate ion are equal / the pentanoic acid has been
Allow concentration of both = 0.0375 (mol dm‒3)
halfneutralised / this is the halfneutralisation point
This can be scored from a full buffer calculation
= –log10 1.38 × 10‒5 = 4.8601 / 4.9
(at the halfneutralisation point) pH = pKa
The value of 4.9 from a full buffer calculation scores M2
and
calculation of pH
Ignore pH = –log10 1.2589 × 10‒5 = 4.9
Ignore SF except 1SF
Accept use of HendersonHasselbalch. All of the
following would score M1 and the first half of M2
pH = pKa + log100.0375
0.0375
pH = pKa + log101
pH = pKa + 0
Common incorrect calculations give values of 2.82, 3.14
and 4.35. These will generally score (0) BUT look for
both moles or both concentrations calculated to score
M1
18(b)[3]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
because this region is a buffer / is the buffering region
Do not award the addition of buffer
Allow the concentration of pentanoic acid is high
because there is a large reservoir of undissociated
Ignore C4H9COOH and C4H9COO− are both present in
pentanoic acid (and pentanoate ions) in solution
solution
EITHER
Allow equations
added OH‒ reacts with H+ and pentanoic acid dissociates
H+ + OH− → H2O
and
C4H9COOH ⇌ C4H9COO− + H+
Allow descriptions using formulae
Allow ratio of [C4H9COO−] to [C4H9COOH] hardly
keeping the concentration of H+ (almost) constant
changes
OR
pentanoic acid reacts with the small quantity of
Allow balanced equation
hydroxide ions added
C4H9COOH + OH− ⇌ C4H9COO− + H2O
Allow descriptions using formulae
and
keeping the concentration of H+ (almost) constant
Allow ratio of [C4H9COO−] to [C4H9COOH] hardly
changes
Ignore just quoting the HendersonHasselbalch equation
without explanation
18(c)(i)[3]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Allow answers describing colour at the pH values OR
volumes of KOH(aq) added
at the start of the titration the solution will be red
Allow it will be red at key point 1
Allow it will be red between key points 1 and 2
Allow at / before pH 3.2
it will change to orange before key point 2 / in the buffering
Allow it changes to orange after adding a small volume / a
region / at pH 3.2 and remains orange in the buffering
few cm3 of KOH and remains orange until just before key
point 2 / until about 20cm3 are added
region / until about 25 cm3 of KOH is added / until the pH
Allow it gradually changes (from red) to orange around
reaches 4.4
key point 2 / between and key points 1 and 2 / 3
Allow any volume of KOH up to 5cm3 for the change to
orange and from 1525 cm3 for change to yellow
it will be yellow before the neutralisation point / before the
Allow it changes to yellow before key point 3 / at key
point 3 and stays yellow
vertical portion of the graph / before key point 3 / when pH
Allow it will be yellow at key point 3 and stays yellow
is (about) 4.4 and is still yellow at key point 4
18(c)(ii)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
M2 dependent on M1 OR the selection of bromocresol
green or bromocresol blue or bromophenol blue (which
will not score M1)
bromothymol blue
(at the neutralisation point) there is a mixture of yellow
and blue forms (of the indicator) so the solution appears
Allow indicator is yellow in acid and blue in alkali so
green
green (at the neutralisation point) is observed
Allow indicator is yellow below pH 6.0 and blue above
pH 7.6 and grren at the neutralisation point
Allow green is between yellow in acid and blue in alkali
(Total for Question 18 = 18 marks)
(Total for Section C = 18 marks)
Total for Paper = 90 marks
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

