Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 16
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
16 Iron, lead and zinc can be extracted using a blast furnace but aluminium cannot. In a blast furnace, iron is extracted from iron(III) oxide, Fe2O3, at high temperature. Some standard enthalpy changes of formation, ΔfH d, and standard molar entropies, Sd, are shown. Substance Al(s) Al2O3(s) CO(g) CO2(g) Fe(s) Fe2O3(s) ΔfH d / kJ mol–1 0 –1676 –111 –394 0 –824 Sd / J K–1 mol–1 28.3 50.9 197.6 213.6 27.3 87.4
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
16(a)(i)[3]
Example of calculation
Penalise units once only
= 87.4 + (3 × 197.6) = (680.2) (J K‒1 mol‒1)
calculation of the standard entropy of the reactants
calculation of the standard entropy of the products
= (2 × 27.3) + (3 × 213.6) = (695.4) (J K‒1 mol‒1)
= (695.4 ‒ 680.2) = (+)15.2 (J K‒1 mol‒1)
calculation of the entropy change (products –
reactants)
Ignore SF in final answer except 1 SF
Correct answer with no working scores (3)
Allow TE
16(a)(ii)[3]
Example of calculation
calculation of the standard enthalpy of formation of the
= ‒824 + (3 × ‒111) = (‒1157 (kJ mol‒1))
reactants
= 3 × ‒394 = (‒1182) (kJ mol‒1)
calculation of the standard enthalpy of formation of the
products
= (‒1182) ‒ (‒1157) = ‒25 (kJ mol‒1)
calculation of the enthalpy change (products –
reactants)
‒2339 (kJ mol‒1) scores M1 and M2
+25 (kJ mol‒1) scores M1 and M2
Ignore calculates the enthalpy change and then goes on to
calculate ΔSsurroundings BUT allow the equations in (a)(iii)
Ignore SF except 1 SF
Correct answer with no working scores (3)
16(a)(iii)[3]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Candidates may use their values instead of symbols
Penalise omission of Δ once only
Either (using entropy arguments)
ΔStotal = ΔSsystem + ΔSsurroundingsΔStotal = ΔSsystem ‒ ΔH scores M1
and
T
ΔSsurroundings = ‒ΔH ÷ T
Allow either equation described in words
(ΔH is negative so) ΔSsurroundings or ‒ΔH ÷ T is(always) positive
and
ΔSsystem is positive
ΔStotal is positive (at all temperatures)and
so the reaction is feasible (at all temperatures)
Allow spontaneous
OR (using Gibbs free energy arguments)
ΔG = Δ ‒ TΔS
(ΔS is positive so) TΔS or ΔS is (always) positive
and
ΔH is negative
ΔG is (always) negative
and
so the reaction is (always) feasible
Allow spontaneous
Allow TE on values in (a)(i) and (a)(ii)
16(b)(i)[4]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
calculation of ΔSsystem
= ((2 × 28.3) + (3 × 213.6)) ‒ (50.9 + (3 × 197.6))
= 697.4 ‒ 643.7
= 53.7 (J K‒1 mol)
calculation of ΔH
= (3 × ‒394) ‒ (‒1676 + (3 × ‒111)
= ‒1182 + 2009
= 827 (kJ mol‒1)
conversion of ΔSsystem or ΔH so units match
ΔS = 0.0537 (kJ K‒1 mol)
or
ΔH = 827000 (J mol‒1)
rearrange ΔStotal = ΔSsystem + ΔSsurroundings when
T = ΔH ÷ ΔSsystem
ΔStotal = 0
and
= 827000 = 15400 / 1.5400 x 104 (K)
calculation of T
53.7
Correct answer scores (4)
15.4 (no M3) scores (3)
Ignore incorrect units throughout except in final answer
Allow TE thoughout except for M4 for a negative temperature
16(b)(ii)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
because this temperature cannot be achieved in a Blast
Allow the temperature in the Blast Furnace is too low
Furnace
Allow the temperature required is too high
Ignore temperature required is very high
Ignore the energy needed is too high
Ignore activation energy is too high
Ignore cost
(Total for Question 16 = 14 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

