Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 61 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows a fruit fly, Drosophila suzukii, on the skin of a fruit. (Source: © dpa picture alliance/Alamy Stock Photo) This species of fruit fly is endemic to southeast Asia but recently it has become an invasive species in Europe. The female lays fertilised eggs under the skin of fruits. The eggs hatch into larvae that feed on the fruit. The larvae develop into pupae that become adult flies. A student investigated the effect of using an organic pesticide, pyrethrum, on the hatching of eggs and the development of pupae. Sixteen flasks containing a culture medium were prepared. Eight flasks had 0.5 g of pyrethrum added. Each flask had one female fly that layed eggs for 24 hours. The fly was then removed and the eggs were allowed to hatch and develop into pupae.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)[1]
There is no (significant)
Ignore eggs hatched
difference between the
number of pupae from the
untreated (A) and treated
culture (B) medium
3(b)[2]
Number of pupae
A/untreated B/treated
72
45
68
56
81
39
suitable table format with
56
40
data correct column headings
43
29
52
38
60
35
means correctly calculated (1)
64
46
Mean 62
Mean 41
3(c)[3]
bar graph with linear scale
mean number of
and labels (1)
pupae/culture or
treatment/ A B.
means plotted correctly (1)
y axis must start at zero
ALLOW ECF for incorrect
range bars plotted correctly
means from 3bi
Range bars 8143 5629
3di
correct substitution of given
ECF allow use of
(SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
incorrect means
Correct square root
correct answer (1)
reduces to 5.109
t = 4.11 (4.1)
Correct answer only
gains 2 marks
accept additional decimal
places
3d ii
the calculated value of t (4.11) is
Allow ECF from 3di
more than the critical value 2.14 (1)
if calculated value is
less than stated
critical value
Accept critical value
therefore reject the null hypothesis
of 2.98
there is a difference between the
treated and untreated groups (1)
3(d)(i)[2]
There is no (significant)
Ignore eggs hatched
difference between the
number of pupae from the
untreated (A) and treated
culture (B) medium
Number of pupae
A/untreated B/treated
72
45
68
56
81
39
suitable table format with
56
40
data correct column headings
43
29
52
38
60
35
means correctly calculated (1)
64
46
Mean 62
Mean 41
bar graph with linear scale
mean number of
and labels (1)
pupae/culture or
treatment/ A B.
means plotted correctly (1)
y axis must start at zero
ALLOW ECF for incorrect
range bars plotted correctly
means from 3bi
Range bars 8143 5629
3di
correct substitution of given
ECF allow use of
(SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
incorrect means
Correct square root
correct answer (1)
reduces to 5.109
t = 4.11 (4.1)
Correct answer only
gains 2 marks
accept additional decimal
places
3d ii
the calculated value of t (4.11) is
Allow ECF from 3di
more than the critical value 2.14 (1)
if calculated value is
less than stated
critical value
Accept critical value
therefore reject the null hypothesis
of 2.98
there is a difference between the
treated and untreated groups (1)
An answer that includes two of the
ignore repeat the
following points:
expt/amount
accept
use other masses of pyrethrum (1)
concentration/volume
leave adults to lay eggs for more
accept more time
than 24 hours (1)
Leave eggs for more than 5 days
accept more time
(to see if more hatch/pupate) (1)
An answer that includes two of the
following points:
Pyrethrum/concentration/ mass
accept flies become
may have no effect on the flies/flies
resistant
resistant (1)
Pyrethrum may be washed/blown
off fruits (1)
pyrethrum may not reach eggs (1)
Fruit skin might
prevent pyrethrum
fruit damaged by {being
entering fruit
eaten/pests/weather} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(d)(ii)[2]
There is no (significant)
Ignore eggs hatched
difference between the
number of pupae from the
untreated (A) and treated
culture (B) medium
Number of pupae
A/untreated B/treated
72
45
68
56
81
39
suitable table format with
56
40
data correct column headings
43
29
52
38
60
35
means correctly calculated (1)
64
46
Mean 62
Mean 41
bar graph with linear scale
mean number of
and labels (1)
pupae/culture or
treatment/ A B.
means plotted correctly (1)
y axis must start at zero
ALLOW ECF for incorrect
range bars plotted correctly
means from 3bi
Range bars 8143 5629
3di
correct substitution of given
ECF allow use of
(SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
incorrect means
Correct square root
correct answer (1)
reduces to 5.109
t = 4.11 (4.1)
Correct answer only
gains 2 marks
accept additional decimal
places
3d ii
the calculated value of t (4.11) is
Allow ECF from 3di
more than the critical value 2.14 (1)
if calculated value is
less than stated
critical value
Accept critical value
therefore reject the null hypothesis
of 2.98
there is a difference between the
treated and untreated groups (1)
An answer that includes two of the
ignore repeat the
following points:
expt/amount
accept
use other masses of pyrethrum (1)
concentration/volume
leave adults to lay eggs for more
accept more time
than 24 hours (1)
Leave eggs for more than 5 days
accept more time
(to see if more hatch/pupate) (1)
An answer that includes two of the
following points:
Pyrethrum/concentration/ mass
accept flies become
may have no effect on the flies/flies
resistant
resistant (1)
Pyrethrum may be washed/blown
off fruits (1)
pyrethrum may not reach eggs (1)
Fruit skin might
prevent pyrethrum
fruit damaged by {being
entering fruit
eaten/pests/weather} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(e)[2]
An answer that includes two of the
ignore repeat the
following points:
expt/amount
accept
use other masses of pyrethrum (1)
concentration/volume
leave adults to lay eggs for more
accept more time
than 24 hours (1)
Leave eggs for more than 5 days
accept more time
(to see if more hatch/pupate) (1)
3(f)[2]
An answer that includes two of the
following points:
Pyrethrum/concentration/ mass
accept flies become
may have no effect on the flies/flies
resistant
resistant (1)
Pyrethrum may be washed/blown
off fruits (1)
pyrethrum may not reach eggs (1)
Fruit skin might
prevent pyrethrum
fruit damaged by {being
entering fruit
eaten/pests/weather} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

