Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 The photograph shows some leaves of Piper betle, a plant that grows in the Philippines and other countries in southeast Asia. (Source: © Bowonpat Sakaew/Alamy Stock Photo) The leaves are eaten as a traditional cure for human digestive disorders. The leaves are thought to prevent the growth of some species of bacteria. A student formed the following hypothesis: The leaves of Piper betle contain antibacterial compounds that reduce bacterial growth. Plan an investigation to find evidence to support or reject this hypothesis. Your answer should give details under the following headings.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[2]
A description that includes two of the
following points:
A method to
provide
find a suitable mass/age of
quantitative results
leaves/concentration of
extract/method of extraction (1)
find a suitable
temperature/pH/medium/time/species
of bacteria (1)
find suitable method to measure
{inhibition/antibacterial effect} (1)
4(b)[9]
An answer that includes nine of the following
Ignore amount
points:
ALLOW different valid
methods.
clear statement of the dependent
variable e.g.zone of inhibition (1)
description of method of preparation
of extract (1)
method of preparing bacterial
lawn/broth/pour plate (1)
Wells/discs/drop in
broth/serial dilution/put on
method of applying extract (1)
agar
detail of measuring dependent
e.g. ruler/grid/different
variable (1)
orientations
description of aseptic technique (1)
ignore taping dishes
use of a control for comparison (1)
Incubate at stated temperature (1)
But not more than 30˚
two variables that need to be
e.g.
controlled (1)
temperature/pH/incubation
time/size of
method of control of one named
disc/medium/species of
variable (1)
bacteria/source/mass of
leaves
repeat the whole experiment to
accept to measure
calculate (mean) and SD/error bars (1)
variability of data
4(c)[3]
An answer that includes the
following points:
accept with several
concentrations
table for collecting raw
description of mean calculated
data with headings and
in text or mean on one graph
units with means
label
calculated from repeats
bar graph format with
accept line graph if several
labelled axes (1)
concentrations used
use of an appropriate
Accept a (named) correlation
statistical test (1)
test with line graph a test for
difference if bar graph
4(d)[2]
An answer that includes two of the
following points:
difficult to measure
Accept errors in use of
distances/diameters/ZOI with
colorimeter
precision (1)
Accept the bacteria used
only tested against one species
might be resistant
of bacteria (1)
contamination (1)
Accept conditions might
not be aseptic
Ignore ref to pathogens
bacteria cultured in aerobic
conditions and gut is anaerobic
or not cultures at human body
temperature (1)
(Total for question 4 = 16 marks)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

