Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 61 · Question 2
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 The photograph shows part of a desert in Mexico. mimosa trees cactus plants (Source: © Alexander Semkin/Alamy Stock Photo) A scientist observed that one species of cactus, Neobuxbaumia tetetzo, was often found near a species of tree, Mimosa luisana. The scientist decided to test the hypothesis that the cactus plants often grow close to mimosa trees. One hundred locations were selected at random. A 10 × 10 m quadrat was placed at each location. The presence or absence of each species was recorded in each quadrat.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)[1]
E.g. shelter for wind/sun
Appropriate suggestion linked to benefit
(so) reduced water
loss/transpiration
Animals graze mimosa
before cactus
Shelter helps cactus
seedlings establish
Accept other valid
suggestions
2(b)[2]
identify a suitable risk such as being infected/
bitten/allergic
reaction/irritant/sunburn/spines/dehydration/
trip hazard (1)
Appropriate description of how to reduce the
risk (1)
2c i
correct selection of
Step 1 = 60 ÷ 16 OR 3.75
data/ration
Step 2 = 4 ÷ 20 OR 0.2
Odds ratio = 3.75 ÷ 0.2 OR
both ratios correct and
18.75
divided correctly
19 (not 19.0)
correct final odds ratio
Correct answer gains 3
ECF for MP2 and answer to
2sig fig if data/ratio
incorrect
2cii
The cactus plants are found growing in
Ignore text lifted from the
association with the mimosa/ tree
question without
qualification
2di
An answer that includes two of the
Only mark the first response on each
following points:
line
Abiotic
Temperature (1)
pH (1)
water content (1)
Accept soil moisture
Accept soil
mineral content/salinity (1)
stucture/compaction/depth/oxygen
/carbon dioxide content
2dii
results are not valid / description of
Description of effect must
expected effect on the dependent
be directional eg increase
variable (1)
temperature increases
enzyme activity
(Total for question 2 = 10 marks)
2(c)(i)[3]
E.g. shelter for wind/sun
Appropriate suggestion linked to benefit
(so) reduced water
loss/transpiration
Animals graze mimosa
before cactus
Shelter helps cactus
seedlings establish
Accept other valid
suggestions
identify a suitable risk such as being infected/
bitten/allergic
reaction/irritant/sunburn/spines/dehydration/
trip hazard (1)
Appropriate description of how to reduce the
risk (1)
2c i
correct selection of
Step 1 = 60 ÷ 16 OR 3.75
data/ration
Step 2 = 4 ÷ 20 OR 0.2
Odds ratio = 3.75 ÷ 0.2 OR
both ratios correct and
18.75
divided correctly
19 (not 19.0)
correct final odds ratio
Correct answer gains 3
ECF for MP2 and answer to
2sig fig if data/ratio
incorrect
2cii
The cactus plants are found growing in
Ignore text lifted from the
association with the mimosa/ tree
question without
qualification
2di
An answer that includes two of the
Only mark the first response on each
following points:
line
Abiotic
Temperature (1)
pH (1)
water content (1)
Accept soil moisture
Accept soil
mineral content/salinity (1)
stucture/compaction/depth/oxygen
/carbon dioxide content
2dii
results are not valid / description of
Description of effect must
expected effect on the dependent
be directional eg increase
variable (1)
temperature increases
enzyme activity
(Total for question 2 = 10 marks)
2(c)(ii)[1]
E.g. shelter for wind/sun
Appropriate suggestion linked to benefit
(so) reduced water
loss/transpiration
Animals graze mimosa
before cactus
Shelter helps cactus
seedlings establish
Accept other valid
suggestions
identify a suitable risk such as being infected/
bitten/allergic
reaction/irritant/sunburn/spines/dehydration/
trip hazard (1)
Appropriate description of how to reduce the
risk (1)
2c i
correct selection of
Step 1 = 60 ÷ 16 OR 3.75
data/ration
Step 2 = 4 ÷ 20 OR 0.2
Odds ratio = 3.75 ÷ 0.2 OR
both ratios correct and
18.75
divided correctly
19 (not 19.0)
correct final odds ratio
Correct answer gains 3
ECF for MP2 and answer to
2sig fig if data/ratio
incorrect
2cii
The cactus plants are found growing in
Ignore text lifted from the
association with the mimosa/ tree
question without
qualification
2di
An answer that includes two of the
Only mark the first response on each
following points:
line
Abiotic
Temperature (1)
pH (1)
water content (1)
Accept soil moisture
Accept soil
mineral content/salinity (1)
stucture/compaction/depth/oxygen
/carbon dioxide content
2dii
results are not valid / description of
Description of effect must
expected effect on the dependent
be directional eg increase
variable (1)
temperature increases
enzyme activity
(Total for question 2 = 10 marks)
2(d)(i)[2]
E.g. shelter for wind/sun
Appropriate suggestion linked to benefit
(so) reduced water
loss/transpiration
Animals graze mimosa
before cactus
Shelter helps cactus
seedlings establish
Accept other valid
suggestions
identify a suitable risk such as being infected/
bitten/allergic
reaction/irritant/sunburn/spines/dehydration/
trip hazard (1)
Appropriate description of how to reduce the
risk (1)
2c i
correct selection of
Step 1 = 60 ÷ 16 OR 3.75
data/ration
Step 2 = 4 ÷ 20 OR 0.2
Odds ratio = 3.75 ÷ 0.2 OR
both ratios correct and
18.75
divided correctly
19 (not 19.0)
correct final odds ratio
Correct answer gains 3
ECF for MP2 and answer to
2sig fig if data/ratio
incorrect
2cii
The cactus plants are found growing in
Ignore text lifted from the
association with the mimosa/ tree
question without
qualification
2di
An answer that includes two of the
Only mark the first response on each
following points:
line
Abiotic
Temperature (1)
pH (1)
water content (1)
Accept soil moisture
Accept soil
mineral content/salinity (1)
stucture/compaction/depth/oxygen
/carbon dioxide content
2dii
results are not valid / description of
Description of effect must
expected effect on the dependent
be directional eg increase
variable (1)
temperature increases
enzyme activity
(Total for question 2 = 10 marks)
2(d)(ii)[1]
E.g. shelter for wind/sun
Appropriate suggestion linked to benefit
(so) reduced water
loss/transpiration
Animals graze mimosa
before cactus
Shelter helps cactus
seedlings establish
Accept other valid
suggestions
identify a suitable risk such as being infected/
bitten/allergic
reaction/irritant/sunburn/spines/dehydration/
trip hazard (1)
Appropriate description of how to reduce the
risk (1)
2c i
correct selection of
Step 1 = 60 ÷ 16 OR 3.75
data/ration
Step 2 = 4 ÷ 20 OR 0.2
Odds ratio = 3.75 ÷ 0.2 OR
both ratios correct and
18.75
divided correctly
19 (not 19.0)
correct final odds ratio
Correct answer gains 3
ECF for MP2 and answer to
2sig fig if data/ratio
incorrect
2cii
The cactus plants are found growing in
Ignore text lifted from the
association with the mimosa/ tree
question without
qualification
2di
An answer that includes two of the
Only mark the first response on each
following points:
line
Abiotic
Temperature (1)
pH (1)
water content (1)
Accept soil moisture
Accept soil
mineral content/salinity (1)
stucture/compaction/depth/oxygen
/carbon dioxide content
2dii
results are not valid / description of
Description of effect must
expected effect on the dependent
be directional eg increase
variable (1)
temperature increases
enzyme activity
(Total for question 2 = 10 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

