Physics · Oct / Nov 2022 · Paper 31 · Question 4
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 A student investigated the bending of a plastic beam. The beam, of width w and height h, was supported at either end by two metal rods a distance l apart, as shown. plastic beam w h l metal rod metal rod She applied a force F to the middle of the plastic beam by hanging a mass from it. plastic beam mass
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[2]
No repeat measurements
Inconsistent d.p. for d
Or all values of d should be recorded to the same d.p.
Or measurements of d are not all recorded to the same resolution (of
the device)
4(b)[5]
Labels axes with quantities and unitsSensible scalesPlottingLine of best fitF/N
d/ m
4.9
0.0007
9.8
0.0013
14.7
0.002
19.6
0.0027
24.5
0.0033
29.4
0.004
4(c)(i)[2]
EITHER
Rearranges equation and compares to y = mx (+ c)
𝑙3
Shows that 𝑚=
4𝑤ℎ3𝐸
OR
𝑑
𝑙3
Rearranges equation to
4𝑤ℎ3𝐸
𝐹=
𝑑
States that
𝐹= gradient of the graph plotted
4(c)(ii)[2]
Calculates gradient using large triangleGradient in the range 1.30×10–4 to 1.40×10–4 (m N–1)Example of calculation:
Gradient = (0.0035 – 0.0010) / (26 – 7.5) = 1.35 × 10–4
4(c)(iii)[2]
𝑙3
Use of gradient =4𝑤ℎ3𝐸
𝑙3𝐹
Or use of substituted values of F and d into 𝐸=
4𝑤ℎ3𝑑
E value in the range 2.41 GPa to 2.60 GPaEcf for gradient value in (c)(ii) – but not power of 10 errors in substitution of
l, w, or h
Example of calculation:
𝑙3
4𝑤ℎ3𝑚
𝐸=
(0.30 m)3
4 × 0.020 m × (0.010 m)3 × 1.35×10−4 m N−1 = 2.5 × 109 Pa
𝐸=
4(d)[2]
A thinner beam would cause a larger d (for the same force)
Reducing percentage uncertainty (in d)
MP2 dependent on MP1
4(e)[2]
Identifies physics relating to health & safety
Suggests a relevant safety issue
Examples
Glass is brittle, so will snap/break
Sharp edges could cause injury by causing cuts
Glass is stiffer, so a larger force/mass would be needed
A large mass could cause injury if the mass falls on feet
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

