Physics · Oct / Nov 2022 · Paper 31 · Question 3
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 A student investigated the refractive index of a liquid. He placed the liquid into a curved glass container so that the liquid acted as a converging lens. Light from a filament bulb was transmitted through the lens, as shown. metre rule filament bulb filament u clamp liquid in curved glass container clamp stand v paper The student adjusted the position of the filament bulb until a clear image of the filament was formed on the paper. The student calculated the power P of the lens using the distance u between the container and the filament, and the distance v between the container and the paper.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[3]
Mark 3(a)(i) and (ii) holistically
EITHER
Measure the height from the paper to the top of the liquid (v)
Measure the height from the paper to the filament/middle of the bulb
(u + v)
Subtract v to give u
OR
Measure the height from the filament/middle of the bulb to the top of
the liquid (u)
Measure the height from the paper to the filament/middle of the bulb
(u + v)
Subtract u to give v
OR
Measure the height from the paper to the top of the liquid (v)
Move the ruler so that zero aligns with the lens
Measure the distance from the lens to the filament/middle of the
bulb (u)
3(a)(ii)[2]
Identifies relevant source of uncertainty
Suggest suitable approach to reduce/eliminate the uncertainty
Examples
Parallax error when measuring the height of the bulb/lens with the
ruler
Use a set square from rule to bulb/lens
Metre rule not vertical
Use a set square to ensure metre rule is perpendicular to the
base/paper
Zero error when measuring the height from the lens to the bulb
Check zero on the rule is aligned with top of the liquid
Filament sealed within glass, so cannot measure distance directly
Measure to the middle of the bulb
3(b)(i)[2]
1
1
Use of 𝑃=
𝑣
𝑢+
P = 4.30 (D) to 3 s.f.
Example of calculation
𝑃= 1
𝑢+ 1
𝑣
1
0.374 m = 4.2998 D
1
𝑃=
0.615 m +
𝑃= 4.30 D
nlens− nair
1
3(b)(ii)[3]
Use of P =
(
r)
nair
with nair = 1
nlens = 1.3
Allow e.c.f from 3(b)(i)
Example of calculation
mean P = (4.28 D + 4.31 D + 4.30 D)/3 = 4.297 D
𝑛lens = 𝑃𝑟+ 1
𝑛lens = (4.297 D × 0.070 m) + 1
𝑛lens = 1.3
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

