Physics · May / June 2021 · Paper 31 · Question 2
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 A student determined the speed of sound in air using a standing wave. The student used a tuning fork to create a sound wave in the column of air inside a plastic tube. He placed the plastic tube into a measuring cylinder of water so he could adjust the length l of the column of air. tuning fork plastic tube l measuring cylinder of water Diagram not to scale The student adjusted l until the loudest sound was heard, indicating that a standing wave had formed. He marked the water level on the plastic tube and measured l. He repeated this process several times and recorded the results. l / cm 18.4 18.0 19.2 19.4 19.2
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)[2]
Difficult to identifying when sound was loudest
Or Difficulty hearing tuning fork due to background noise
Tube moved when marking the water level
Or Tube not vertical when water level was marked
2(b)(i)[2]
Calculation of the mean using 5 values
Mean l = 18.8 cm to 3 s.f.
Example of calculation
Mean l = (18.4 + 18.0 + 19.2 + 19.4 + 19.2) / 5
Mean l = 18.8 cm
2(b)(ii)[2]
Use of half the range
Percentage uncertainty = 4 (%)
OR
Use of value furthest from the mean (18.0)
Percentage uncertainty = 4 (%)
Allow ecf from 2(b)(i) for use of 4 values (e.g. ignoring 18.0) for both mark points.
Example of calculation
Range = 19.4 – 18.0 = 1.4 cm
Percentage uncertainty = (0.7 cm / 18.8 cm) × 100 % = 3.7 %
Difference from mean = 18.8 – 18.0 = 0.8 cm
Percentage uncertainty = (0.8 cm / 18.8 cm) × 100 % = 4.3 %
2(c)[2]
Use of v = fλ
Speed of sound = 331 m s–1
Allow e.c.f from 2(b)(i)
Example of calculation
λ = 4 × 0.188 m = 0.752 m
v = 440 Hz × 0.752 m = 331 m s–1
2(d)[2]
Use of percentage uncertainty from (b)(ii) to calculate relevant
maximum/minimum value for speed of sound from (c)
Statement comparing this with 343 m s–1
MP1 – only needs to calculate one boundary – e.g. maximum if their value in (c) is
below 343 m s–1, minimum if (c) is above 343 m s–1.
OR
Calculates the percentage difference between 343 m s–1 and their speed of sound
from (c)
Statement comparing this with their percentage uncertainty from (b)(ii)
Example of calculation
Percentage uncertainty = 4 %
v = 331 m s–1
Max v = 331 × = m s–1
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

