Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 31 · Question 2
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 The molar volume of carbon dioxide may be determined using the reaction between calcium carbonate and ethanoic acid. The equation for this reaction is shown. CaCO3(s) + 2CH3COOH(aq) → Ca(CH3COO)2(aq) + H2O(l) + CO2(g) Procedure Step 1 Place 30 cm3 of 1 mol dm−3 ethanoic acid in a boiling tube. Step 2 Set up an apparatus to collect the carbon dioxide produced over water in a measuring cylinder. Step 3 Place approximately 0.10 g of calcium carbonate powder in a clean dry weighing bottle. Step 4 Weigh the weighing bottle and its contents accurately. Step 5 Remove the bung from the boiling tube and tip the calcium carbonate into the boiling tube. Quickly replace the bung in the boiling tube. Step 6 When the reaction is finished, measure the volume of gas collected in the measuring cylinder. Step 7 Reweigh the weighing bottle. Step 8 Repeat the experiment five more times, increasing the mass of calcium carbonate by about 0.05 g each time. Do not exceed 0.40 g of calcium carbonate.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)[3]
Diagram showing the following points
boiling tubeAllow any reaction apparatus that can be fitted with a bung and
delivery tube
delivery tube above the level of theAllow any part of a delivery tube shown
liquid in the boiling tube if shown or
Allow bung not shown as crosssection
above half the height of the tube
Allow measuring cylinder shown not vertical
sealed connection between reaction vesselAllow other collecting vessels with graduations
and delivery tube
Ignore omission of graduations on measuring cylinder
inverted measuring cylinder containingIgnore omission of beehive shelf
some water (shown as a line or an
Ignore gas syringe
annotation indicating it is full)
Ignore the delivery tube passing through the wall of the trough
water level in trough over the bottom of themeasuring cylinder
Alternative allowed bungs
end of delivery tube below or in themeasuring cylinder
6 points scores 3 marks;
5 or 4 points scores 2 marks;
2 or 3 points scores 1 mark
Ignore apparatus labels
including ‘heat’
2(b)[2]
An explanation that makes reference to the following points:
ethanoic acid is a weak acid (and hydrochloric acid is a strong acid)Allow ‘hydrochloric acid is a stronger
acid’
Allow reaction would be slow
Allow reaction would be less vigorous
Allow reaction would not be violent
Allow reverse arguments
Ignore just ‘hydrochloric acid is a
strong acid’
(with hydrochloric acid)Allow just (with ethanoic acid ) ‘less
gas would escape before the boiling tube was sealed
gas would escape’
2(c)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
to take account of any calcium carbonate left in the weighing bottleIgnore just ‘gives the mass of CaCO3 that
reacts’
Ignore just ‘gives exact amount of CaCO3’
2(d)(i)[3]
correct axes with at least 50% of the grid used in both directionsmass on x axis; volume on y axis
Allow scale 0.10 g = 1 big square
axes labelled with correct unitsAllow grammatical errors e.g. use of
brackets rather than ‘/’ before units
Allow mass / g and vol / cm3 for labels
Allow plotting to within half a small square
all points plotted correctlyTE for M2 and M3 if axes wrong way round
2(d)(ii)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following
points:
Do not award BFL drawn to include value at 0.2 g
best fit line drawn through five pointsAllow TE on points plotted in (d)(i) even if it does not go
and
through origin
Accept line that stops at 0.11 g data point but would pass
passes through the origin
through the origin if extrapolated
Ignore extrapolation beyond 0.36 / 76
structure line from 0.25 g to graphAllow just the horizontal structure line if 0.25 g is on a major
grid line.
and
line to 52.5 cm3
Allow vol at 0.25 g clearly marked on BFL by a cross or circle.
Allow 51.553.5 cm3
TE only on any straight line covering all the points
Ignore calculation of volume
2(d)(iii)[3]
Example of calculation
molar mass = 40.1 + 12 + 16 × 3 = 100.1 (g mol−1)
calculation of molar mass of CaCO3calculation of amount of CaCO3mol (CaCO3) = 0.25 ÷ 100.1=2.4975 × 10−3 / 0.0024975
1 mol CO2 occupies 52.5 ÷ 2.4975 × 10−3 = 21021 (cm3) / 21.021 dm3
scale volume of CO2 to 1 molUnits must be correct if given but accept cm3 mol−1 / dm3 mol−1
TE at each stage and on volume in (d)(ii)
Ignore SF except 1 SF
Correct answer with some working scores (3)
Allow use of Mr (CaCO3) = 100 (Vm = 21)
Use of 51.5 gives 20621 cm3 (20600 for Mr = 100)
Use of 52 gives 20821 cm3 (20800 for Mr = 100)
Use of 53 gives 21221 cm3(21200 for Mr = 100)
Use of 53.5 gives 21421 cm3(21400 for Mr = 100)
Calculation of moles of acid (0.030) divided by 2 (0.015)
Vol of CO2 ÷ 0.015 e.g. 52.5 ÷ 0.015 = 3500 cm3 scores M3 only
2(e)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
some carbon dioxide / CO2 / gas will escape before theAllow Some CO2 / gas will escape in Step 5
boiling tube can be sealed
Allow Some CO2 / gas will escape when the solid is
added
Allow reaction starts before the boiling tube can be
sealed
Ignore just ‘Some carbon dioxide / gas will escape’
some carbon dioxide / gas will dissolve in the waterAccept carbon dioxide is soluble (in water)
Ignore reference to temperature or pressure not rtp
Ignore ‘some CO2 remains in apparatus’
Ignore ‘incomplete reaction’
Do not award
references to measurement errors
loss of reactant
apparatus damaged or not working properly
(Total for Question 2 = 16 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

