Biology · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 The photograph shows an aquatic plant, Cabomba aquatica. (Source: © Dorling Kindersley Ltd / Alamy Stock Photo) This plant grows in water in Asia. A student observed that the shortest plants were always seen in water shaded by overhanging trees. The student thought that reduced photosynthesis may be limiting the growth of these plants. The student formed the following hypothesis: Low light intensity reduces the rate of photosynthesis in Cabomba aquatica. Plan an investigation to find evidence to support or reject this hypothesis. Your answer should give details under the following headings.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[2]
A description that includes two of
A method to provide
the following points:
quantitative results
Collection of gas / O2 needs
only be mentioned only
once
find a suitable {mass / length}
of plant to use (1)
find a suitable method to
Allow suitable rage of light
change light intensity (1)
intensities
Ignore wavelength
find a suitable {temperature /
Allow optimum
time} to collect {gas / O2} (1)
temperature
find suitable {method /
apparatus} to measure
Ignore number of bubbles
volume of {gas / O2} (1)
rate of photosyn
4(b)[9]
An answer that includes nine of the
ALLOW different valid methods.
following points:
clear statement of the
Do not allow carbon dioxide
dependent variable e.g. the
Ignore reference to time
volume of {gas / O2} released
Allow (labelled) diagram /
description of method of
photosynthometer
measuring volume of gas (1)
Allow length / mass /
method of standardising
preconditioning
plants (1)
Ignore age / species / size
eg moving lamp / wattage of bulb /
method of producing two
darkened room and light room
different light intensities (1)
use of (sodium)
hydrogencarbonate (1)
allow plant time to acclimatise
{standardised / stated} time
Allow 5 mins to 24 hrs
for gas collection (1)
one variable that need to be
eg temperature – TC waterbath /
controlled and its method of
heatshield / LED bulb
control (1)
Ignore AC room
wavelength of light – filter / bulb
pH – buffer
{repeats / repeat the whole
experiment} to give mean and
SD (1)
eg volume / πr2d/ gradient of graph
method of calculation of rate
time t
4(c)[3]
An answer that includes the following
points:
table for raw data with headings
Allow a description of
and units, with means calculated
how to calculate mean
from repeats (1)
in text or as part of an
axis label
AND
bar graph format with labelled
axes (1)
Allow other valid tests
use of a t test for difference (with
a bar graph showing only two
different light intensities)
OR
{line / scatter} graph format with
labelled axes (1)
use of a correlation test
Allow named test e.g.
difference (with a line graph
Spearmans Rank
showing more than two different
light intensities)
4(d)[2]
An answer that includes two of the
following points:
difficult to measure (small)
Allow {some O2 dissolved /
{volumes / distances} of
some O2 used in respiration
{gas / O2} (with precision)
/ some gas may be CO2}
Ignore bubbles / escape of
gas / errors in measuring
difficult to control
temperature (1)
difficult to control surface
area of leaves (1)
Allow example of change
idea that actual growing
conditions in the river
change during the day so
the results may not be a fair
representation (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

