Biology · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 61 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows a young locust eating the leaves of a plant. (Source: © Nigel Cattlin / Alamy Stock Photo) Locusts can breed in large numbers and destroy crops, such as sorghum, in East Africa. A scientist observed that some varieties of sorghum were more likely to be eaten by young locusts. The scientist collected the seeds of two varieties of sorghum (A and B) and grew them in trays. Locust eggs were collected and hatched into young locusts. Twenty young locusts were placed in a cage containing 100 g of fresh sorghum leaves of variety A. The cage was kept at 30 °C. After 24 hours, the leaves were removed and the mass of leaves eaten was calculated. This method was repeated with fresh sorghum leaves of variety B. The method was repeated six times for these two varieties of sorghum leaves.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)[1]
There is no (significant)
Candidates can express this
difference between the
in different ways
(mean) mass of leaves eaten
of variety A and variety B
3(b)[3]
Mass of leaves eaten (in 24 hours) / g
suitable table format
with correct column
(variety) A
(variety) B
headings and units (1)
17.3
17.8
17.2
17.9
all data correctly
17.5
17.7
17.0
17.6
entered (1)
16.7
17.8
16.9
17.4
means correctly
Mean 17.1
Mean 17.7
calculated (1)
3(c)[3]
bar graph with linear
Mean mass of leaves (eaten) /g
scale and axes labelled,
A B
with units (1)
means plotted correctly
ALLOW ECF from 3bi for
plotting incorrect means
range bars plotted
16.7 to 17.5
correctly (1)
17.4 to 17.9
3di
correct substitution of
given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
0.084 and 0.032
correct answer (1)
t = 4.3 / 4.32 / 4.315 / 4.3152
Correct answer gains 2 marks
Ignore minus signs
Allow ECF using incorrect means
Denominator is 0.139
3d ii
the calculated value of t
Do not allow ve values
(4.3152) is more than the
/ t < critical value if t
critical value 2.23 (1)
value not given
Ignore p = 0.01
therefore reject the null
Allow ECF for MP2
hypothesis, so there is a
difference in the mass (of
leaves) eaten between variety A
and variety B (1)
3(d)(i)[2]
There is no (significant)
Candidates can express this
difference between the
in different ways
(mean) mass of leaves eaten
of variety A and variety B
Mass of leaves eaten (in 24 hours) / g
suitable table format
with correct column
(variety) A
(variety) B
headings and units (1)
17.3
17.8
17.2
17.9
all data correctly
17.5
17.7
17.0
17.6
entered (1)
16.7
17.8
16.9
17.4
means correctly
Mean 17.1
Mean 17.7
calculated (1)
bar graph with linear
Mean mass of leaves (eaten) /g
scale and axes labelled,
A B
with units (1)
means plotted correctly
ALLOW ECF from 3bi for
plotting incorrect means
range bars plotted
16.7 to 17.5
correctly (1)
17.4 to 17.9
3di
correct substitution of
given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
0.084 and 0.032
correct answer (1)
t = 4.3 / 4.32 / 4.315 / 4.3152
Correct answer gains 2 marks
Ignore minus signs
Allow ECF using incorrect means
Denominator is 0.139
3d ii
the calculated value of t
Do not allow ve values
(4.3152) is more than the
/ t < critical value if t
critical value 2.23 (1)
value not given
Ignore p = 0.01
therefore reject the null
Allow ECF for MP2
hypothesis, so there is a
difference in the mass (of
leaves) eaten between variety A
and variety B (1)
An answer that includes two of the
Ignore repeat the expt /
following points:
use more locusts
Allow different humidities
use different temperatures (1)
use different {species / ages /
Ignore types
stages of locust} (1)
leave for longer than 24 hrs (1)
use both varieties at once so
locust can select diet (1)
An answer that includes one of the
following points:
Allow environmental
locusts {eat more at higher
temperatures / have a faster
e.g. increase in drought /
metabolism / respire faster so
temperature too hot for
they grow faster} (1)
plant growth / more
extreme weather such as
{locusts complete their life
severe storms
cycle faster / more locusts
produced} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(d)(ii)[2]
There is no (significant)
Candidates can express this
difference between the
in different ways
(mean) mass of leaves eaten
of variety A and variety B
Mass of leaves eaten (in 24 hours) / g
suitable table format
with correct column
(variety) A
(variety) B
headings and units (1)
17.3
17.8
17.2
17.9
all data correctly
17.5
17.7
17.0
17.6
entered (1)
16.7
17.8
16.9
17.4
means correctly
Mean 17.1
Mean 17.7
calculated (1)
bar graph with linear
Mean mass of leaves (eaten) /g
scale and axes labelled,
A B
with units (1)
means plotted correctly
ALLOW ECF from 3bi for
plotting incorrect means
range bars plotted
16.7 to 17.5
correctly (1)
17.4 to 17.9
3di
correct substitution of
given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)
0.084 and 0.032
correct answer (1)
t = 4.3 / 4.32 / 4.315 / 4.3152
Correct answer gains 2 marks
Ignore minus signs
Allow ECF using incorrect means
Denominator is 0.139
3d ii
the calculated value of t
Do not allow ve values
(4.3152) is more than the
/ t < critical value if t
critical value 2.23 (1)
value not given
Ignore p = 0.01
therefore reject the null
Allow ECF for MP2
hypothesis, so there is a
difference in the mass (of
leaves) eaten between variety A
and variety B (1)
An answer that includes two of the
Ignore repeat the expt /
following points:
use more locusts
Allow different humidities
use different temperatures (1)
use different {species / ages /
Ignore types
stages of locust} (1)
leave for longer than 24 hrs (1)
use both varieties at once so
locust can select diet (1)
An answer that includes one of the
following points:
Allow environmental
locusts {eat more at higher
temperatures / have a faster
e.g. increase in drought /
metabolism / respire faster so
temperature too hot for
they grow faster} (1)
plant growth / more
extreme weather such as
{locusts complete their life
severe storms
cycle faster / more locusts
produced} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(e)[2]
An answer that includes two of the
Ignore repeat the expt /
following points:
use more locusts
Allow different humidities
use different temperatures (1)
use different {species / ages /
Ignore types
stages of locust} (1)
leave for longer than 24 hrs (1)
use both varieties at once so
locust can select diet (1)
3(f)[1]
An answer that includes one of the
following points:
Allow environmental
locusts {eat more at higher
temperatures / have a faster
e.g. increase in drought /
metabolism / respire faster so
temperature too hot for
they grow faster} (1)
plant growth / more
extreme weather such as
{locusts complete their life
severe storms
cycle faster / more locusts
produced} (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

