Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 9
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
9 The time of death of a mammal can be estimated in a number of ways.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
9(a)(i)[3]
A description that includes the following points:
use the (liver / rectal / core) temperature (immediately) (1)
NB be careful not to award time
use the graph and this temperature to get the {number of hours
of death
after death / time (after death)} (1)
ACCEPT work backwards using the
subtract this value from the time of finding the corpse (1)
graph
9(a)(ii)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
{other factors / named factor} affects {heat loss / rate of heat loss
e.g. several hours since death
/ body temperature (after death)} (1)
body may have been moved to
a cooler area
credit an explanation for how a named factor affects {heat loss /
e.g. {clothing / fat} {acts as an
insulator / limits heat loss}
temperature} (1)
cooler ambient temperature
cools body faster
9(b)(i)[10]
not ethical / dead person cannot give their permission / relatives
IGNORE more available
may not agree / humans are genetically diverse
similar tissues
*9(b)(ii)
Chemical
Discussion of usefulness
tests
pH
Pigs
Useful because decrease with time
Useful as there is an increase with time with {small error bars / very little overlap in error bars} so timings are quite
accurate
Rats
Useful because decrease with time
Useful as there is an increase with time but error bars overlap so would not give accurate timings
Ammonia
Pigs
Useful as there is an increase with time
Useful as there is an increase with time with no overlap in error bars so timings will be accurate
Rats
Not very useful as {no clear patterns / no trend / data goes up and down}
Not very useful because data goes up and down so one value will give two times
Not useful as no ammonia after 48 hours
Useful for determining that there was more than 48 hours since time of death as no ammonia present
Hypoxanthine
Pigs
Useful as there is an increase with time
Useful as there is an increase with time with no overlap in error bars so timings will be accurate
Very low levels between 0 and 6 hours with overlapping error bars so may not be useful {then / until after 6 hours}
There is an anomaly (at 24 hours) so this would need further investigation to see if this affects accuracy
Rats
Not very useful as {no clear patterns / no trend / data goes up and down}
Only useful up to {9 hours /32 hours}
Only useful up 6 hours otherwise one level could give two different timings
Lactate
Pigs
Not very useful as {no clear patterns / no trend / data goes up and down}
Could be useful up to 9 / 24 hours as there is an increase in levels / not useful after 9 /24 hours as levels fluctuate
Rats
Not very useful as {no clear patterns / no trend / data goes up and down}
Could be useful up to 9 hours as there is an increase in levels / not useful after 9 hours as levels fluctuate
General
small sample size so questionable significance
use more than one marker and combine results
results indicate that the test are species specific
overall pigs are more useful than rats
Level 1: Limited comments
1 mark = description of data for one chemical
2 marks = description of data for two chemicals
Level 2: Limited comments on usefulness
3 marks = usefulness of one chemical commented on OR one general comment
4 marks = usefulness of two chemicals commented on OR one chemical and one general comment
Level 3: Extended comments on usefulness
5 marks = usefulness of three chemicals commented on OR two chemicals and one general comment, that includes at least one extended comment
6 marks = usefulness four chemicals commented on OR three chemicals and one general comment, that includes at least one extended comment
9(b)(iii)
An answer that includes three of the following points:
{pH / some chemicals} seem to have similar patterns so could be useful (in
ACCEPT pH decreases in both species so could
humans) (1)
be useful (in humans)
some patterns seem to be speciesspecific so may not be useful (1)
ACCEPT are different in pigs and rats
humans may be similar to {pigs / rats}
therefore testing will need to be done (on humans) / but will the testing be
{allowed / possible} (1)
credit suitable comment about {sample size / error bars} (1)
chemical tests will need to be used in conjunction with other methods (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

