Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 8
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
8 Reforestation is an example of effective management of conflicts between human needs and conservation. Organisations have put together a list of rules for responsible reforestation. These rules aim to improve absorbing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide, biodiversity and human livelihoods. Four of the rules are: 1. Protect existing forests first 2. Work together with local people 3. Select appropriate areas for reforestation 4. Select species to maximise biodiversity.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
8(a)[2]
An explanation that includes two of the following points:
because if existing trees are destroyed {carbon dioxide / carbon}
ACCEPT existing forests are carbon
will be released (back into the atmosphere) (1)
sinks
established trees are
already removing (high levels of)
carbon dioxide (from the
atmosphere)
new trees would remove
less carbon dioxide (from the
atmosphere)
because they are {established / native} and therefore more
resistant to {fires / storms / drought / disease / protect from soil
erosion} (1)
because they are {homes / source of food} to other species
ACCEPT human dependent on them
for {food / medicines}
(animals) (1)
8(b)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following points:
because the local people rely on the land (that is planned for
ACCEPT named land use
reforestation) (1)
organisations need to be
aware of the needs of the local
people
local people need to {understand the issues / be onside / feel that
IGNORE avoid conflicts
there livelihoods are safe / protect the trees} (1)
local people will understand {the area / climate / their land use /
animals} better (1)
8(c)[4]
An explanation that includes the following points:
NB max 3 for reasons without
explanations (reasons = mp 1, 3, 5 and
to avoid {destroying / disturbing / competition with} other
7)
ecosystems when planting trees (1)
as this would result in the {loss / decrease} of {other species /
biodiversity}
to avoid destroying the {homes / farmland} of the local people by
planting trees (1)
as this would cause {resentment / hunger / loss of income} (1)
to join together fragments of remaining forests / reduce isolation
(of a particular) species by planting trees (1)
increase genetic diversity / prevent loss of genetic diversity (1)
e.g. soil type, rainfall, temperature,
{conditions / named condition} at the site of original forest must be
nutrient levels
appropriate (for those trees) (1)
therefore reforestation will be {faster / more effective / more
DO NOT ACCEPT when clearly written
likely to be successful} (1)
in the direct context of succession
8(d)[4]
An explanation that includes four of the following points:
(overall) to increase biodiversity (1)
native species because they are adapted for the conditions (1)
native species as they will support the indigenous wild life of the
area
OR
native species to avoid the risk of nonnative species outcompeting
the native species (1)
ACCEPT increase gene flow
endangered species to avoid {extinction / inbreeding / drop in
increase biodiversity within
genetic diversity} (1)
that species
ACCEPT increase biodiversity within
geneticallydiverse species to expand the gene pool (1)
that species
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

