Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 31 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 Scientists study the possibilities of antimicrobial properties in plants. The effects of extracts of roselle plants and clove plants on the inhibition of the growth of the bacterium E. coli were studied. Extracts were made in water and in ethanol. The results are shown in the graph. 25 20 15 Inhibition of growth / a.u. 10 5 0 Ethanol Water Ethanol Water Roselle Clove
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[2]
A table with the
Must all be quoted to one decimal place.
following features:
Inhibition of growth / au
suitable table drawn (1)Roselle
Clove
Ethanol
Water
Ethanol
Water
all headings correct13.0/ 13.1 /
with units (1)
21.1 / 21.0
15.6 / 15.5
17.4 / 17.5
13.2
Units in cells loses mp 2
all data correctlyentered (1)
Additional Guidance Mark
3ci
1.2:1 / 1.23:1 / 0.83:1
ACCEPT the other
way round in any
case
3cii
An answer that includes the following points:
Ethanol extract {is more effective / better than /ACCEPT reverse argument
gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
antimicrobial properties} (extract made with
water) (1)
Roselle (extract) {is more effective / better /gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
An answer that includes two of the following points:
{enzymes / protein} needed for growth / relevantprocesses described (1)
pH is no longer optimal (for growth) (1)because {enzymes / proteins} are denatured (by pHchange) (1)
lower pH affects (hydrogen / ionic) bonding / Rgroups (in proteins / enzymes) (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
3(a)(ii)[4]
A table with the
Must all be quoted to one decimal place.
following features:
Inhibition of growth / au
suitable table drawn (1)Roselle
Clove
Ethanol
Water
Ethanol
Water
all headings correct13.0/ 13.1 /
with units (1)
21.1 / 21.0
15.6 / 15.5
17.4 / 17.5
13.2
Units in cells loses mp 2
all data correctlyentered (1)
Additional Guidance Mark
3ci
1.2:1 / 1.23:1 / 0.83:1
ACCEPT the other
way round in any
case
3cii
An answer that includes the following points:
Ethanol extract {is more effective / better than /ACCEPT reverse argument
gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
antimicrobial properties} (extract made with
water) (1)
Roselle (extract) {is more effective / better /gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
An answer that includes two of the following points:
{enzymes / protein} needed for growth / relevantprocesses described (1)
pH is no longer optimal (for growth) (1)because {enzymes / proteins} are denatured (by pHchange) (1)
lower pH affects (hydrogen / ionic) bonding / Rgroups (in proteins / enzymes) (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
3(b)[3]
A table with the
Must all be quoted to one decimal place.
following features:
Inhibition of growth / au
suitable table drawn (1)Roselle
Clove
Ethanol
Water
Ethanol
Water
all headings correct13.0/ 13.1 /
with units (1)
21.1 / 21.0
15.6 / 15.5
17.4 / 17.5
13.2
Units in cells loses mp 2
all data correctlyentered (1)
Additional Guidance Mark
3ci
1.2:1 / 1.23:1 / 0.83:1
ACCEPT the other
way round in any
case
3cii
An answer that includes the following points:
Ethanol extract {is more effective / better than /ACCEPT reverse argument
gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
antimicrobial properties} (extract made with
water) (1)
Roselle (extract) {is more effective / better /gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
3(c)(i)[1]
A table with the
Must all be quoted to one decimal place.
following features:
Inhibition of growth / au
suitable table drawn (1)Roselle
Clove
Ethanol
Water
Ethanol
Water
all headings correct13.0/ 13.1 /
with units (1)
21.1 / 21.0
15.6 / 15.5
17.4 / 17.5
13.2
Units in cells loses mp 2
all data correctlyentered (1)
Additional Guidance Mark
3ci
1.2:1 / 1.23:1 / 0.83:1
ACCEPT the other
way round in any
case
3cii
An answer that includes the following points:
Ethanol extract {is more effective / better than /ACCEPT reverse argument
gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
antimicrobial properties} (extract made with
water) (1)
Roselle (extract) {is more effective / better /gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
An answer that includes two of the following points:
{enzymes / protein} needed for growth / relevantprocesses described (1)
pH is no longer optimal (for growth) (1)because {enzymes / proteins} are denatured (by pHchange) (1)
lower pH affects (hydrogen / ionic) bonding / Rgroups (in proteins / enzymes) (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
3(c)(ii)[2]
A table with the
Must all be quoted to one decimal place.
following features:
Inhibition of growth / au
suitable table drawn (1)Roselle
Clove
Ethanol
Water
Ethanol
Water
all headings correct13.0/ 13.1 /
with units (1)
21.1 / 21.0
15.6 / 15.5
17.4 / 17.5
13.2
Units in cells loses mp 2
all data correctlyentered (1)
Additional Guidance Mark
3ci
1.2:1 / 1.23:1 / 0.83:1
ACCEPT the other
way round in any
case
3cii
An answer that includes the following points:
Ethanol extract {is more effective / better than /ACCEPT reverse argument
gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
antimicrobial properties} (extract made with
water) (1)
Roselle (extract) {is more effective / better /gives higher inhibition of growth than / has higher
An answer that includes two of the following points:
{enzymes / protein} needed for growth / relevantprocesses described (1)
pH is no longer optimal (for growth) (1)because {enzymes / proteins} are denatured (by pHchange) (1)
lower pH affects (hydrogen / ionic) bonding / Rgroups (in proteins / enzymes) (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
3(d)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following points:
{enzymes / protein} needed for growth / relevantprocesses described (1)
pH is no longer optimal (for growth) (1)because {enzymes / proteins} are denatured (by pHchange) (1)
lower pH affects (hydrogen / ionic) bonding / Rgroups (in proteins / enzymes) (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

