Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2023 · Paper 31 · Question 2

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

2 Scientists use pollen grains to artificially pollinate certain crop plants. Collecting pollen by hand is very time consuming. However, bees collect large amounts of pollen in their daily activity. Pollen traps can be used to remove pollen when the bees return to their hive. The viability of the pollen collected by these two methods was investigated.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 2(a)[2]

    An answer that includes the following:

    A divide to form the male (gamete / nuclei) (1)
    B produces (digestive) enzymes / digests the style /

    ACCEPT ovary, ovule,

    female gamete, egg

    makes pathway (for male gamete / to ovum) /grows

    towards ovum (1)

  • 2(b)[5]

    An answer that includes the following points:

    e.g. hanging drop, agar

    credit suitable methods used (to observe

    plates, filter paper,

    germination of pollen grains) (1)

    cavity slide

    ACCEPT boron / sugar.

    sucrose solution added (1)

    > or = 15 minutes < or =

    suitable time quoted before germination rate

    5 days

    assessed (1)

    temperature, pH, light,

    control of one relevant abiotic variable (1)

    sucrose concentration,

    fixed time

    species, a cultivar,

    control of one relevant biotic variable (1)

    variety of plant, type

    species of bee

    view through microscope / count germinated &

    nongerminated / count germinated & total (and

    work out percent) (1)

    e.g. pollen allergy, bee

    reference to relevant health and safety issue (1)

    stings

    2ci

    An answer that includes the following points:

    the optimum is at higher temperature for bee

    ACCEPT both

    temperatures at which

    than hand collected pollen / described / both

    optima quoted (30C and 36C) (1)

    % germinations starts to

    go down quoted

    the percentage germination is higher in hand

    (than bee collected pollen at all temperatures)

    ACCEPT reverse

    range in percentage germination in hand greater

    arguments

    than in bee collected / fall from optimum {higher

    / steeper} in hand than bee collected/

    ACCEPT ranges quoted

    (3 or 4 and 16) from

    temperature has greater effect on hand collected

    22 to 19/18

    56 to 40/41 etc. or

    peak to lowest

    enzymes denature (above the optimum / above

    30C and 36C in both) (1)

    ACCEPT there is no

    there are no {error bars / SDs / SEs} (1)

    measure of variability

    2cii

    An answer that includes the following points:

    IGNORE the number of

    repeat the experiment at 30C (1)

    repeats

    IGNORE temperature

    {all conditions / named condition} should be

    kept constant (1)

    (mean and) SD (calculated) / error bars (1)

    ACCEPT named relevant

    look for overlap in SDs / perform ttest (1)

    other test of difference

    2di

    A calculation with the following steps:

    Correct answer gets 3

    marks with no working

    Ecf at mp 2 and 3

    1000 and 750

    lengths correctly read from graph (1)

    1000 – 750 = 250

    subtraction followed by correct division using

    data above and multiplication by 100(1)

    then 250 ÷ 750 =

    0.3333

    OR

    1000 – 750 = 250

    250 ÷ 1000 = 0.25

    OR

    250 ÷ 875 = 0.2857

    quoted to correct sig figs. and as a percentage

    3.3 (%)

    25.0 (%)

    28.6 (%)

    Accept 25, 33 or 29

    for 2 marks

    2dii

    pollen damaged (in bee sample)/ description (1)

    ACCEPT reverse

    argument.

    Allow secrete

    something which

    affects pollen

    negatively/ collect

    less ripe pollen / bees

    selective / bee pollen

    from a different

    species

    3ai

    An explanation that includes the following:

    prevents escape / spreading of (bacteria / E .coli)
    prevents {contamination of the agar or cultures

    accept ref validity

    with (other types of) bacteria) / cross

    contamination /effect on the results} (1)

    If no other marks awarded

    ACCEPT

    prevents contamination

    3aii

    An answer that includes four of the following

    points:

    description of how a bacterial culture is made (1)

    description of addition of extract (1)

    e.g. paper disc / cut

    well

    e.g. disc size / wells

    control of feature of independent variable

    same size / {volume

    described (1)

    / age} / of extract

    temp. <30 but > 10,

    incubate {at suitable quoted temperature / for

    suitable quoted time / same length of time} (1)

    time 1 day to 7 days

    zone of inhibition

    statement of what is measured related to method

    clear area / turbidity

    above if awarded (1)

  • 2(c)(i)[4]

    An answer that includes the following:

    A divide to form the male (gamete / nuclei) (1)
    B produces (digestive) enzymes / digests the style /

    ACCEPT ovary, ovule,

    female gamete, egg

    makes pathway (for male gamete / to ovum) /grows

    towards ovum (1)

    An answer that includes the following points:

    e.g. hanging drop, agar

    credit suitable methods used (to observe

    plates, filter paper,

    germination of pollen grains) (1)

    cavity slide

    ACCEPT boron / sugar.

    sucrose solution added (1)

    > or = 15 minutes < or =

    suitable time quoted before germination rate

    5 days

    assessed (1)

    temperature, pH, light,

    control of one relevant abiotic variable (1)

    sucrose concentration,

    fixed time

    species, a cultivar,

    control of one relevant biotic variable (1)

    variety of plant, type

    species of bee

    view through microscope / count germinated &

    nongerminated / count germinated & total (and

    work out percent) (1)

    e.g. pollen allergy, bee

    reference to relevant health and safety issue (1)

    stings

    2ci

    An answer that includes the following points:

    the optimum is at higher temperature for bee

    ACCEPT both

    temperatures at which

    than hand collected pollen / described / both

    optima quoted (30C and 36C) (1)

    % germinations starts to

    go down quoted

    the percentage germination is higher in hand

    (than bee collected pollen at all temperatures)

    ACCEPT reverse

    range in percentage germination in hand greater

    arguments

    than in bee collected / fall from optimum {higher

    / steeper} in hand than bee collected/

    ACCEPT ranges quoted

    (3 or 4 and 16) from

    temperature has greater effect on hand collected

    22 to 19/18

    56 to 40/41 etc. or

    peak to lowest

    enzymes denature (above the optimum / above

    30C and 36C in both) (1)

    ACCEPT there is no

    there are no {error bars / SDs / SEs} (1)

    measure of variability

    2cii

    An answer that includes the following points:

    IGNORE the number of

    repeat the experiment at 30C (1)

    repeats

    IGNORE temperature

    {all conditions / named condition} should be

    kept constant (1)

    (mean and) SD (calculated) / error bars (1)

    ACCEPT named relevant

    look for overlap in SDs / perform ttest (1)

    other test of difference

    2di

    A calculation with the following steps:

    Correct answer gets 3

    marks with no working

    Ecf at mp 2 and 3

    1000 and 750

    lengths correctly read from graph (1)

    1000 – 750 = 250

    subtraction followed by correct division using

    data above and multiplication by 100(1)

    then 250 ÷ 750 =

    0.3333

    OR

    1000 – 750 = 250

    250 ÷ 1000 = 0.25

    OR

    250 ÷ 875 = 0.2857

    quoted to correct sig figs. and as a percentage

    3.3 (%)

    25.0 (%)

    28.6 (%)

    Accept 25, 33 or 29

    for 2 marks

    2dii

    pollen damaged (in bee sample)/ description (1)

    ACCEPT reverse

    argument.

    Allow secrete

    something which

    affects pollen

    negatively/ collect

    less ripe pollen / bees

    selective / bee pollen

    from a different

    species

    3ai

    An explanation that includes the following:

    prevents escape / spreading of (bacteria / E .coli)
    prevents {contamination of the agar or cultures

    accept ref validity

    with (other types of) bacteria) / cross

    contamination /effect on the results} (1)

    If no other marks awarded

    ACCEPT

    prevents contamination

    3aii

    An answer that includes four of the following

    points:

    description of how a bacterial culture is made (1)

    description of addition of extract (1)

    e.g. paper disc / cut

    well

    e.g. disc size / wells

    control of feature of independent variable

    same size / {volume

    described (1)

    / age} / of extract

    temp. <30 but > 10,

    incubate {at suitable quoted temperature / for

    suitable quoted time / same length of time} (1)

    time 1 day to 7 days

    zone of inhibition

    statement of what is measured related to method

    clear area / turbidity

    above if awarded (1)

  • 2(c)(ii)[4]

    An answer that includes the following:

    A divide to form the male (gamete / nuclei) (1)
    B produces (digestive) enzymes / digests the style /

    ACCEPT ovary, ovule,

    female gamete, egg

    makes pathway (for male gamete / to ovum) /grows

    towards ovum (1)

    An answer that includes the following points:

    e.g. hanging drop, agar

    credit suitable methods used (to observe

    plates, filter paper,

    germination of pollen grains) (1)

    cavity slide

    ACCEPT boron / sugar.

    sucrose solution added (1)

    > or = 15 minutes < or =

    suitable time quoted before germination rate

    5 days

    assessed (1)

    temperature, pH, light,

    control of one relevant abiotic variable (1)

    sucrose concentration,

    fixed time

    species, a cultivar,

    control of one relevant biotic variable (1)

    variety of plant, type

    species of bee

    view through microscope / count germinated &

    nongerminated / count germinated & total (and

    work out percent) (1)

    e.g. pollen allergy, bee

    reference to relevant health and safety issue (1)

    stings

    2ci

    An answer that includes the following points:

    the optimum is at higher temperature for bee

    ACCEPT both

    temperatures at which

    than hand collected pollen / described / both

    optima quoted (30C and 36C) (1)

    % germinations starts to

    go down quoted

    the percentage germination is higher in hand

    (than bee collected pollen at all temperatures)

    ACCEPT reverse

    range in percentage germination in hand greater

    arguments

    than in bee collected / fall from optimum {higher

    / steeper} in hand than bee collected/

    ACCEPT ranges quoted

    (3 or 4 and 16) from

    temperature has greater effect on hand collected

    22 to 19/18

    56 to 40/41 etc. or

    peak to lowest

    enzymes denature (above the optimum / above

    30C and 36C in both) (1)

    ACCEPT there is no

    there are no {error bars / SDs / SEs} (1)

    measure of variability

    2cii

    An answer that includes the following points:

    IGNORE the number of

    repeat the experiment at 30C (1)

    repeats

    IGNORE temperature

    {all conditions / named condition} should be

    kept constant (1)

    (mean and) SD (calculated) / error bars (1)

    ACCEPT named relevant

    look for overlap in SDs / perform ttest (1)

    other test of difference

    2di

    A calculation with the following steps:

    Correct answer gets 3

    marks with no working

    Ecf at mp 2 and 3

    1000 and 750

    lengths correctly read from graph (1)

    1000 – 750 = 250

    subtraction followed by correct division using

    data above and multiplication by 100(1)

    then 250 ÷ 750 =

    0.3333

    OR

    1000 – 750 = 250

    250 ÷ 1000 = 0.25

    OR

    250 ÷ 875 = 0.2857

    quoted to correct sig figs. and as a percentage

    3.3 (%)

    25.0 (%)

    28.6 (%)

    Accept 25, 33 or 29

    for 2 marks

    2dii

    pollen damaged (in bee sample)/ description (1)

    ACCEPT reverse

    argument.

    Allow secrete

    something which

    affects pollen

    negatively/ collect

    less ripe pollen / bees

    selective / bee pollen

    from a different

    species

    3ai

    An explanation that includes the following:

    prevents escape / spreading of (bacteria / E .coli)
    prevents {contamination of the agar or cultures

    accept ref validity

    with (other types of) bacteria) / cross

    contamination /effect on the results} (1)

    If no other marks awarded

    ACCEPT

    prevents contamination

    3aii

    An answer that includes four of the following

    points:

    description of how a bacterial culture is made (1)

    description of addition of extract (1)

    e.g. paper disc / cut

    well

    e.g. disc size / wells

    control of feature of independent variable

    same size / {volume

    described (1)

    / age} / of extract

    temp. <30 but > 10,

    incubate {at suitable quoted temperature / for

    suitable quoted time / same length of time} (1)

    time 1 day to 7 days

    zone of inhibition

    statement of what is measured related to method

    clear area / turbidity

    above if awarded (1)

  • 2(d)(i)[3]

    An answer that includes the following:

    A divide to form the male (gamete / nuclei) (1)
    B produces (digestive) enzymes / digests the style /

    ACCEPT ovary, ovule,

    female gamete, egg

    makes pathway (for male gamete / to ovum) /grows

    towards ovum (1)

    An answer that includes the following points:

    e.g. hanging drop, agar

    credit suitable methods used (to observe

    plates, filter paper,

    germination of pollen grains) (1)

    cavity slide

    ACCEPT boron / sugar.

    sucrose solution added (1)

    > or = 15 minutes < or =

    suitable time quoted before germination rate

    5 days

    assessed (1)

    temperature, pH, light,

    control of one relevant abiotic variable (1)

    sucrose concentration,

    fixed time

    species, a cultivar,

    control of one relevant biotic variable (1)

    variety of plant, type

    species of bee

    view through microscope / count germinated &

    nongerminated / count germinated & total (and

    work out percent) (1)

    e.g. pollen allergy, bee

    reference to relevant health and safety issue (1)

    stings

    2ci

    An answer that includes the following points:

    the optimum is at higher temperature for bee

    ACCEPT both

    temperatures at which

    than hand collected pollen / described / both

    optima quoted (30C and 36C) (1)

    % germinations starts to

    go down quoted

    the percentage germination is higher in hand

    (than bee collected pollen at all temperatures)

    ACCEPT reverse

    range in percentage germination in hand greater

    arguments

    than in bee collected / fall from optimum {higher

    / steeper} in hand than bee collected/

    ACCEPT ranges quoted

    (3 or 4 and 16) from

    temperature has greater effect on hand collected

    22 to 19/18

    56 to 40/41 etc. or

    peak to lowest

    enzymes denature (above the optimum / above

    30C and 36C in both) (1)

    ACCEPT there is no

    there are no {error bars / SDs / SEs} (1)

    measure of variability

    2cii

    An answer that includes the following points:

    IGNORE the number of

    repeat the experiment at 30C (1)

    repeats

    IGNORE temperature

    {all conditions / named condition} should be

    kept constant (1)

    (mean and) SD (calculated) / error bars (1)

    ACCEPT named relevant

    look for overlap in SDs / perform ttest (1)

    other test of difference

    2di

    A calculation with the following steps:

    Correct answer gets 3

    marks with no working

    Ecf at mp 2 and 3

    1000 and 750

    lengths correctly read from graph (1)

    1000 – 750 = 250

    subtraction followed by correct division using

    data above and multiplication by 100(1)

    then 250 ÷ 750 =

    0.3333

    OR

    1000 – 750 = 250

    250 ÷ 1000 = 0.25

    OR

    250 ÷ 875 = 0.2857

    quoted to correct sig figs. and as a percentage

    3.3 (%)

    25.0 (%)

    28.6 (%)

    Accept 25, 33 or 29

    for 2 marks

    2dii

    pollen damaged (in bee sample)/ description (1)

    ACCEPT reverse

    argument.

    Allow secrete

    something which

    affects pollen

    negatively/ collect

    less ripe pollen / bees

    selective / bee pollen

    from a different

    species

    3ai

    An explanation that includes the following:

    prevents escape / spreading of (bacteria / E .coli)
    prevents {contamination of the agar or cultures

    accept ref validity

    with (other types of) bacteria) / cross

    contamination /effect on the results} (1)

    If no other marks awarded

    ACCEPT

    prevents contamination

    3aii

    An answer that includes four of the following

    points:

    description of how a bacterial culture is made (1)

    description of addition of extract (1)

    e.g. paper disc / cut

    well

    e.g. disc size / wells

    control of feature of independent variable

    same size / {volume

    described (1)

    / age} / of extract

    temp. <30 but > 10,

    incubate {at suitable quoted temperature / for

    suitable quoted time / same length of time} (1)

    time 1 day to 7 days

    zone of inhibition

    statement of what is measured related to method

    clear area / turbidity

    above if awarded (1)

  • 2(d)(ii)[1]

    An answer that includes the following:

    A divide to form the male (gamete / nuclei) (1)
    B produces (digestive) enzymes / digests the style /

    ACCEPT ovary, ovule,

    female gamete, egg

    makes pathway (for male gamete / to ovum) /grows

    towards ovum (1)

    An answer that includes the following points:

    e.g. hanging drop, agar

    credit suitable methods used (to observe

    plates, filter paper,

    germination of pollen grains) (1)

    cavity slide

    ACCEPT boron / sugar.

    sucrose solution added (1)

    > or = 15 minutes < or =

    suitable time quoted before germination rate

    5 days

    assessed (1)

    temperature, pH, light,

    control of one relevant abiotic variable (1)

    sucrose concentration,

    fixed time

    species, a cultivar,

    control of one relevant biotic variable (1)

    variety of plant, type

    species of bee

    view through microscope / count germinated &

    nongerminated / count germinated & total (and

    work out percent) (1)

    e.g. pollen allergy, bee

    reference to relevant health and safety issue (1)

    stings

    2ci

    An answer that includes the following points:

    the optimum is at higher temperature for bee

    ACCEPT both

    temperatures at which

    than hand collected pollen / described / both

    optima quoted (30C and 36C) (1)

    % germinations starts to

    go down quoted

    the percentage germination is higher in hand

    (than bee collected pollen at all temperatures)

    ACCEPT reverse

    range in percentage germination in hand greater

    arguments

    than in bee collected / fall from optimum {higher

    / steeper} in hand than bee collected/

    ACCEPT ranges quoted

    (3 or 4 and 16) from

    temperature has greater effect on hand collected

    22 to 19/18

    56 to 40/41 etc. or

    peak to lowest

    enzymes denature (above the optimum / above

    30C and 36C in both) (1)

    ACCEPT there is no

    there are no {error bars / SDs / SEs} (1)

    measure of variability

    2cii

    An answer that includes the following points:

    IGNORE the number of

    repeat the experiment at 30C (1)

    repeats

    IGNORE temperature

    {all conditions / named condition} should be

    kept constant (1)

    (mean and) SD (calculated) / error bars (1)

    ACCEPT named relevant

    look for overlap in SDs / perform ttest (1)

    other test of difference

    2di

    A calculation with the following steps:

    Correct answer gets 3

    marks with no working

    Ecf at mp 2 and 3

    1000 and 750

    lengths correctly read from graph (1)

    1000 – 750 = 250

    subtraction followed by correct division using

    data above and multiplication by 100(1)

    then 250 ÷ 750 =

    0.3333

    OR

    1000 – 750 = 250

    250 ÷ 1000 = 0.25

    OR

    250 ÷ 875 = 0.2857

    quoted to correct sig figs. and as a percentage

    3.3 (%)

    25.0 (%)

    28.6 (%)

    Accept 25, 33 or 29

    for 2 marks

    2dii

    pollen damaged (in bee sample)/ description (1)

    ACCEPT reverse

    argument.

    Allow secrete

    something which

    affects pollen

    negatively/ collect

    less ripe pollen / bees

    selective / bee pollen

    from a different

    species

    3ai

    An explanation that includes the following:

    prevents escape / spreading of (bacteria / E .coli)
    prevents {contamination of the agar or cultures

    accept ref validity

    with (other types of) bacteria) / cross

    contamination /effect on the results} (1)

    If no other marks awarded

    ACCEPT

    prevents contamination

    3aii

    An answer that includes four of the following

    points:

    description of how a bacterial culture is made (1)

    description of addition of extract (1)

    e.g. paper disc / cut

    well

    e.g. disc size / wells

    control of feature of independent variable

    same size / {volume

    described (1)

    / age} / of extract

    temp. <30 but > 10,

    incubate {at suitable quoted temperature / for

    suitable quoted time / same length of time} (1)

    time 1 day to 7 days

    zone of inhibition

    statement of what is measured related to method

    clear area / turbidity

    above if awarded (1)

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.