Biology · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 41 · Question 6
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
6 Seaweeds are a group of organisms that carry out photosynthesis. Identifying the types and proportions of chlorophyll pigments is important in the classification of seaweeds and biodiversity studies.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
6(a)[2]
An answer that includes the following points:
number of (different) species (1)
ACCEPT species richness
amount
genetic diversity within a species (1)
ACCEPT variation in {genotypes / alleles}
6(b)[2]
An explanation that includes two of the following points:
absorb light energy so that electrons are {excited / released} (1)
ACCEPT NADPH
to synthesise ATP and reduced NADP (1)
IGNORE + signs
ALLOW to absorb light energy so that
it can be converted into ATP energy =
1 mark
*6(c)(i)
Indicative content:
Comparisons:
propanone extracts more chlorophyll a from species P
propanone extracts more chlorophyll a from species R
Level 1 :
DMSO extracts more chlorophyll a from species Q than propanone
propanone and DMSO extract similar concentrations of chlorophyll b from species S
1 mark = 2 comparisons listed
propanone extracts more chlorophyll b from species P
2 marks = 4 comparisons listed
propanone extracts more chlorophyll b from species Q
propanone extracts more total chlorophyll from species P
Level 2 :
Generalisations:
3 marks = 6 comparisons
propanone is the most effective solvent at extracting chlorophyll
OR
species P appears to contain the most chlorophyll when using propanone
1 generalisation + 3 comparisons
DMSO is generally less effective than propanone except when extracting chlorophyll a
OR
from species Q
2 generalisations
Implications in identifying species:
4 marks = one implication discussed
some chlorophyll lost when extracted together as total is less than the sum of the components
other pigments extracted in some cases as total is more than individual components added
Level 3 :
together
the choice of solvent depends on the chlorophyll / species being extracted
5 marks = two implications discussed
because of difference in solubility (of pigments / membranes) / permeability of membranes
6 marks = three implications discussed
more than one solvent needs to be used if this method is to be used for identifying species
as different solvents extract different concentrations of different chlorophylls from different
species
possibility of looking at extraction of other pigments
some sort of comparison table / calibration curve needed to match profile to extraction profiles
propanone better if only using one solvent as results the most varied
avoids need for DNA analysis
comparisons can be made in the field / with simple equipment
no indication of validity of data
6(c)(ii)
An answer that includes two of the following points:
ACCEPT more / less will dissolve
chlorophylls have different solubility in different solvents (1)
IGNORE Rf values
reacted with solvent
because the chlorophylls have different structures (1)
different solvents can {permeate / dissolve / disrupt} (cell /
chloroplast) membranes differently (1)
6(c)[8]
An answer that includes the following points:
number of (different) species (1)
ACCEPT species richness
amount
genetic diversity within a species (1)
ACCEPT variation in {genotypes / alleles}
An explanation that includes two of the following points:
absorb light energy so that electrons are {excited / released} (1)
ACCEPT NADPH
to synthesise ATP and reduced NADP (1)
IGNORE + signs
ALLOW to absorb light energy so that
it can be converted into ATP energy =
1 mark
*6(c)(i)
Indicative content:
Comparisons:
propanone extracts more chlorophyll a from species P
propanone extracts more chlorophyll a from species R
Level 1 :
DMSO extracts more chlorophyll a from species Q than propanone
propanone and DMSO extract similar concentrations of chlorophyll b from species S
1 mark = 2 comparisons listed
propanone extracts more chlorophyll b from species P
2 marks = 4 comparisons listed
propanone extracts more chlorophyll b from species Q
propanone extracts more total chlorophyll from species P
Level 2 :
Generalisations:
3 marks = 6 comparisons
propanone is the most effective solvent at extracting chlorophyll
OR
species P appears to contain the most chlorophyll when using propanone
1 generalisation + 3 comparisons
DMSO is generally less effective than propanone except when extracting chlorophyll a
OR
from species Q
2 generalisations
Implications in identifying species:
4 marks = one implication discussed
some chlorophyll lost when extracted together as total is less than the sum of the components
other pigments extracted in some cases as total is more than individual components added
Level 3 :
together
the choice of solvent depends on the chlorophyll / species being extracted
5 marks = two implications discussed
because of difference in solubility (of pigments / membranes) / permeability of membranes
6 marks = three implications discussed
more than one solvent needs to be used if this method is to be used for identifying species
as different solvents extract different concentrations of different chlorophylls from different
species
possibility of looking at extraction of other pigments
some sort of comparison table / calibration curve needed to match profile to extraction profiles
propanone better if only using one solvent as results the most varied
avoids need for DNA analysis
comparisons can be made in the field / with simple equipment
no indication of validity of data
6(c)(ii)
An answer that includes two of the following points:
ACCEPT more / less will dissolve
chlorophylls have different solubility in different solvents (1)
IGNORE Rf values
reacted with solvent
because the chlorophylls have different structures (1)
different solvents can {permeate / dissolve / disrupt} (cell /
chloroplast) membranes differently (1)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

