Biology · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 41 · Question 5
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
5 Antimicrobial substances can be tested using a Minimum Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) assay. This assay determines the lowest concentration of an antimicrobial substance that prevents visible growth of bacteria. A microdilution plate is used in these assays. It is made of plastic and contains small wells that the antimicrobial substance and the bacteria can be added to. The diagram shows a microdilution plate. wells An investigation tested eight antimicrobial substances on one type of bacteria, E. coli. Appropriate controls were included in this investigation. The diagram shows the steps involved. Step 1: Each antibacterial substance was added to the wells in one row of the microdilution plate using a 1 in 2 dilution plating method. Step 2: The same concentration and volume of a suspension of E. coli was added to each well. Step 3: The microdilution plate was incubated at an appropriate temperature for E. coli for 72 hours. Step 4: The microdilution plate was looked at under a microscope to determine which of the wells had E. coli growing in them and which ones did not.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
5(a)(i)[1]
methods used to prevent contamination (of person /
ACCEPT techniques / procedures /
culture) (with other microorganisms) (1)
routines
ACCEPT prevent {entry / exit /
infection}
IGNORE growth
5(a)(ii)[2]
A description that includes two of the following points:
carry out work beside {a bunsen burner / in a hood} (1)
ACCEPT description of how
use sterilised {equipment / media} / sterilise equipment after use
equipment could be sterilised e.g.
media autoclaved, wash area with
disinfectant
e.g. wearing gloves, washing hands
credit named personal procedure (1)
e.g. transfer bacteria quickly
minimise the time that cultures are exposed to the air / do not
open cultures at the end (1)
5(a)(iii)[2]
An explanation that includes two of the following points:
to prevent entry of bacteria that may compete with the E. coli
ACCEPT will not know if E.coli or the
to prevent entry of bacteria that may grow in different {types /
other bacteria is growing
concentrations} of microbial substances (than E. coli) (1)
to prevent infection (of person) with bacteria in the culture that
{is / maybe} pathogenic (1)
5(b)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
explanation for temperature given (1)
e.g. appropriate temperature needed
for the enzymes to function
temperature not too high so the
enzymes do not denature
ACCEPT proteins for enzymes
temp won’t be rate limiting
for growth
explanation for time given (1)
e.g. antimicrobial effect can be seen
when bacteria are growing
enough time has to be allowed
for the bacterial growth to become
visible
enough time for antimicrobials to
have an effect
5(c)(i)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
ACCEPT a description e.g. to see if
to show if the cultures were contaminated (1)
other bacteria are growing
because the antimicrobial agent would not {kill / inhibit the
growth of} other types of bacteria (1)
OR
to check that the E. coli has not changed its {susceptibility /
resistance} (1)
so that the results will apply to known E. coli (1)
5(c)(ii)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
to show that the E.coli were viable (1)
ACCEPT alive / can replicate / can
grow
ACCEPT to show that the
because if there was not any growth of bacteria you would not
know if the bacteria were dead or the antimicrobial agents were
antimicrobials were inhibiting growth
IGNORE antimicrobials affecting
(very) effective (1)
growth
5(c)(iii)[2]
A description that includes the following points:
ACCEPT the idea of doing this
process in the wells directly or
separately
ACCEPT stated volumes / 50%
description of adding equal volumes of {antimicrobial substance /
antimicrobials / substance / solution} and {water / media / broth
volumes / volumes in ratio 1 : 1
/ buffer} together (1)
IGNORE amount
description of this being repeated (a few times) using previous
ACCEPT a reference to serial
solution (1)
dilutions
5(c)(iv)[2]
MIC of E and G calculated (1)
MIC of E = 1 in 8 and MIC of G = 1 in 256
Or
MIC of E = 1 in 16 and MIC of G = 1 in 512
{32 / 25} (1)
ACCEPT E is {32 / 25} times less effective
NB correct answer gains 2 marks
ACCEPT 2.25 for 1 mark
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

