Note AcademyNote Academy

Sociology · May / June 2026 · Paper 22 · Question 3

0495

As printed in the paper

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 3(a)(i)[2]

    Define the term relative deprivation. Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. being disadvantaged. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. feeling disadvantaged in comparison to others in your society. 2 Key annotations used: When a correct definitional element or example is used. A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect definition or example is given. An answer scoring two marks will be full definition. It will be clear and contain two creditable elements. One of these elements may be a relevant example. An answer scoring one mark will be a partial definition. This may be:

    an answer with one creditable definitional element
    a relevant example with no creditable definitional element
    an answer that shows some understanding but has some vagueness or confusion.
  • 3(a)(ii)[2]

    Define the term corporal punishment Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. physical pain. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. physical harm inflicted on an offender as punishment, for example by whipping them.

  • 3(b)[2]

    Give two examples of green crime Award one mark for each correct example (up to a maximum of two). Possible responses:

    Crimes against the environment
    Illegal poaching of animals
    Dumping of toxic waste
    Illegal logging
    Trading protected animals
    Pollution
    Failure to recycle
    Littering
    Deforestation
    Any other reasonable response. NB: green crime may be defined as an illegal act that harms the environment OR as an act that harms the environment. Please credit both. (Transgressive criminology redefines crime around the concept of "social harm" rather than strictly illegal acts) Key annotations used: for each correct point given. for each incorrect point given.
  • 3(c)[6]

    Describe three features of a moral panic Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three). Possible responses:

    Exaggeration – the behaviour of the labelled group is reported as being worse than it is, using exaggerated language and shocking images e.g. a small fight is reported as a ‘riot’;
    Prediction – the media claim that the deviance will happen again and will be much worse unless strong action is taken by the formal agents;
    Folk devils – Cohen argued the media label certain groups or individuals, turning them into folk devils i.e. people to be feared;
    Symbolisation – the media show how folk devils can be recognised in society, for example by their clothing or appearance. The ‘Rockers’, for example, were symbolised through their leather jackets;
    Creation of stereotypes – the exaggerated reporting and the creation of folk devils means that stereotypes are created of certain social groups whereby all members of that group are thought to have the same characteristics and are thus thought of badly e.g. Islamophobia;
    Binary opposition – the folk devils in the moral panic are reported as being completely different to the rest of society;
    Feelings of outrage in the public – lead to a cry for tough action to be taken against the folk devil;

    6 This question is not asking for examples of moral panics. It requires candidates to focus on what makes something a moral panic. Examples should only therefore be credited if they are supporting these features through their description. Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark, candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give further details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point. Each correct point described or explained can only be credited with two marks, so answers are likely to be quite concise. However, a relevant description/ explanation does need to be clearly present in order for the second mark to be awarded. Guidance

    Media – moral panics are created through media coverage and involvement, ensuring the message reaches a large audience quickly;
    Any other reasonable response.
  • 3(d)[6]

    Explain three reasons why old people have low rates of criminality. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three). Possible responses:

    Police targeting – old people do not fit the stereotype of the ‘typical criminal’ (Cicourel) and so are not subject to police targeting. This may mean they commit more crime than the crime statistics show;
    Lack of opportunity – as old people are unlikely to be at work, they have little or no opportunity of committing work-based crimes, e.g. corporate/white-collar;
    Status – old people have typically achieved what they wanted through life and are not in search of status or thrills, unlike some of the younger generation (postmodernism). Thus, the committing of expressive crime is unlikely;
    Cybercrimes – old people are sometimes referred to as ‘digital dinosaurs’ therefore they are not proficient with digital technology and so will not have the skills necessary for committing cybercrime;
    Physical health – old people may be incapacitated through poor health which restricts their opportunities for committing crime, e.g. burglaries and robberies would prove difficult;
    Pensions/support – old people should not need to commit crime for economic reasons as they have an income from their pension that supports them or they are financially supported by their families in certain cultures, e.g. Chinese culture;

    6 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark, candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give further details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point. Each correct point described or explained can only be credited with two marks, so answers are likely to be quite concise. However, a relevant description/ explanation does need to be clearly present in order for the second mark to be awarded. Guidance

    Social control – many old people now reside in care homes or family homes. Both of these options means that their freedoms and movements are monitored and supervised and thus they do not have the chance or opportunity to commit crime;
    Any other reasonable response.
  • 3(e)[8]

    Discuss how formal agencies of social control can prevent crime. Use Table A to mark answers to this question. Possible responses:

    Police – visible police presence plus the powers of arrest and stop and search ensure that crime is prevented, e.g. military policing;
    Courts – the courts will weigh up the evidence against a person and decide if they are guilty of the charges brought against them. A suitable punishment to prevent crime, often acting as a deterrent, will then be imposed;
    Government – they have to ensure law and order and have power over all the other formal agents to do this. As well as making the laws they pay and instruct the other agents, e.g. in times of public rioting the government may instruct the police to arrest more individuals and instruct the courts to sentence hard – all to try and prevent crime. They act as a ‘warning function’ and help in achieving social conformity (functionalism);
    Prison – this acts as deterrent to crime for many people (loss of liberty etc.) but also prevents crime through incapacitation – if a person is locked up then they cannot commit crime;
    Prison – the rehabilitation programmes found in the prison service are direct measures intended to prevent future re-offending, e.g. treating addiction issues will prevent further crime;

    8 Only formal agents of social control can be credited here. In order to secure credit for a fully developed response (DEV) candidates must link an aspect of a formal agent of social control to the key idea in the question of preventing crime. Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. Use Table A guidance plus metrics below: To score into level 3 (7–8 marks) the candidate must make at least three good quality well developed points (DEVx3). Expect to see sociological concepts and/or theory in the answer. Consistency across all these features is essential to achieve full marks. For example, an answer with three well developed points, one of which is not explicitly conceptual/theoretical, cannot achieve more than 7 marks. Guidance

    Range of punishments courts/police/government – societies now have a vast range of punishments to choose from in order to best prevent crime for the individual and the situation. This can be within an institution but can also be rehabilitative, financial penalties or community based;
    Surveillance (police/government/prison) – Cohen said surveillance has increased dramatically in society and is now everywhere. This means crimes are easier to detect and thus prevent as well as people regulating their own behaviours because of the fear of being caught on camera;
    Armed forces – the government may use the armed forces to prevent crime in situations where the police are unable to cope, e.g. riots, or in repressive state-run regimes. The armed forces may be able to use physical force, weaponry, tear gas and water cannons, for example;
    Social services – social services can intervene in situations in an attempt to prevent crime, e.g. they can remove children from families in order to prevent abuse, neglect or deprivation;
    Marxism – formal social control ensures that individuals conform to social expectations most of the time. Rebellion is quickly supressed and so crime is prevented, e.g. during riots, protests etc. (Althusser – repressive state apparatus);
    Any other reasonable response. To score in level 2 (4–6 marks) the candidate must make a minimum of two accurate sociological points. Use of sociological concepts/theory and/or the quality and development of the points made will be the differentiator for marks within the level. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) expect to see either two accurate points that are at least partially developed (^^) or one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with at least one other undeveloped point. Higher in the level (5–6 marks) expect better development and range. For example, two developed points (DEVx2) and a partially developed point (^) would be likely to score 6 marks. In level 1 (1–3 marks) points are likely to be simple, perhaps common-sense description with little sociological focus. Answers may also be short, perhaps just making one point. Candidates’ answers will typically identify points but do nothing/little with them i.e. undeveloped points or list-like answers. Sociological evidence and concepts are likely to be lacking or to be inaccurate. For example, one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with a concept/theory will score at the top of the level (3 marks) whereas one undeveloped point will score 1 mark. Do remember, candidates may address the question in different ways;

    there is no one required answer or approach. Also, don’t just think about the number of concepts used in an answer to determine your mark – their quality and relevance to the specific question is essential here.

  • 3(f)[14]

    Evaluate the view that subculturalism is the best explanation for crime. Use Table B to mark answers to this question. Possible responses for:

    Collective deviance – these theories offered valid explanations for the amount of deviance committed in groups and considered and explained the idea that a lot of crime is not for economic gain but is expressive;
    Young people – these theories really focused on the crimes committed by young people and so helped to explain this clear trend in the official crime statistics, e.g. the age-crime curve;
    Gang crime – this theory considers how alternative sets of norms and values may become established for a group of people, gangs being one such example. Gang members are thus socialised into the new gang culture – particularly true for deprived and marginalised youth;
    Cohen – status frustration – all young males want status but working-class boys, failing at school are unable to achieve this through the legitimate route of gaining qualifications. So, they look for alternative sources of status e.g. by adopting deviant behaviours and values they may gain respect from some of their peers;
    Cloward and Ohlin – illegitimate opportunity structure – this theory aimed to explain why in some areas (inner- city, deprived communities) crime occurred so frequently and the cycle wasn’t broken. Successful criminal role models were found here along with a career structure for aspiring criminals (e.g. Vankatesh’s study of Chicago gangs);

    14 Note: Strain theory (Merton) can be credited for either side of the debate depending on how candidates use it. Note: In evaluation, candidates may directly criticise subcultural explanations for crime or provide other explanations for crime that are seen to be better. Either way is fine to credit. Note: Age, social class, gender, ethnicity may all be used as points of evaluation, e.g. they are better explanations for crime than subculturalism, as well as alternative theoretical approaches, e.g. Marxism. Key annotations used: for each correct ‘for’ point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. for each correct evaluation point identified. for when an answer comes to a conclusion or judgement. Guidance

    Cloward and Ohlin – different reactions – said there were three sub-cultural responses to a lack of legitimate success in society and thus recognised that situations were different e.g. criminal, conflict and retreatist sub- cultures;
    Miller – focal concerns – young working-class boys had their own sub-culture that was markedly different to middle class youths. The values of this working-class sub-culture could lead young people into deviance e.g. excitement, smartness, toughness etc.;
    Neo-Marxism – CCCS – resistance – this subcultural explanation for crime focuses on youth sub-cultures and how youths may form a collective identity of resistance, expressed through criminal behaviour, to resist wider societal norms and values, e.g. skinheads and racist violence;
    Any other reasonable response. Possible responses against:
    Outdated and irrelevant – subculturalist theories are from the 1950’s and 1960’s in the USA and thus may not be relevant today or apply to other countries e.g. the types of sub-cultures identified by Cloward and Ohlin were not seen in other cultures and do not take account of the digital world so not relevant for youths today;
    Miller and the working-class sub-culture – this explanation fails to take account of the fact that one holistic working-class sub-culture just does not exist. There are many variations and they don’t all share the same ‘focal concerns’ that he suggested;
    Feminism – invisible girls – subculturalism tended to focus on male criminality so is criticised by feminists for ignoring girls and their reasons for criminality (a malestream theory);

    Refer to Table B for guidance plus below: To score in level 4 (12–14 marks) expect to see a minimum of six sociological points. This must be three points for and three points against (or more). If this is not the case the answer cannot score in level 4. Both sides of the debate should be well developed and engage conceptually/theoretically with the question. To be awarded full marks (14 marks) an answer must have 3 good quality, well developed points for and against, a well- developed conclusion (J+DEV) and consistent use of sociological concepts/theory (typically 10+ KU’s). Lower in the level (12–13 marks) an answer may have: DEVx5 and one ^ but is consistently conceptual through all points and has a conclusion or whilst having DEVx6 an answer may have less than 10 KU’s. Alternatively, you may see a strong answer with a less developed conclusion (J rather than J+DEV). A level 4 answer with no conclusion can score a maximum of 12 marks. To score in level 3 (8–11 marks) there must be a two-sided debate with a minimum of 4 sociological points, all with some development. Some accurate sociological concepts/theory will be seen in this level. Answers will contain both developed (DEV) and partially developed points (^). An answer that contains no developed points (DEV) cannot score in level 3. At the bottom of the level (8 marks) there is likely to be 1 conceptual/theoretical developed point (DEV) plus at least 3 partially developed points (^x3). It is likely that there will be more points than this higher in the level (9-10 marks), including more developed points (DEVs) and more concepts/theory (KU). Guidance

    Marxism – invisible crime – subculturalism says that crimes are committed by young people, largely for status. This does not explain corporate and white-collar crimes committed by higher class adults;
    Marxism – their fundamental belief is that instrumental crime is caused by social inequalities, poverty and relative deprivation. This would explain the OCS patterns and trends of working-class criminality;
    Ordinary youth – subculturalism fails to explain social conformity in young people and the fact that most of them do not engage in criminal behaviour. The majority of young working-class males are law abiding;
    Labelling theory – Interactionists such as Becker would say that police stereotypes of the ‘typical criminal’ (Cicourel) lead to police targeting and high stop and search rates of certain individuals. The deviancy amplification caused by this is the key reason for crime;
    Postmodernism – age – the work of Lyng and Katz demonstrates how much youth crime is not committed because of a set of deviant norms and values but because of the ‘buzz’ and ‘thrill seeking’ nature of crime. Postmodernists therefore discuss how youth crime and deviance is largely for fun and is therefore classless;
    Any other reasonable response. At the top of the level (11 marks) an answer would typically have 5 conceptual/theoretical developed points (DEVx5) covering both sides of the debate or perhaps four developed points (DEVx4) and one or more partially developed points (^ minimum). A very unbalanced debate (e.g. 1 point for and 3 against) will not score at the top of the level, however strong development and conceptuality may be. A one-sided answer, however good, can score a maximum of 6 marks (level 2). A level 2 answer (4–7 marks) is either a one-sided response (remember these can also fall into level 1) or a response with partially developed points (^^s) on both sides of the debate. They may be characterised by less, or even no sociological concepts/theory. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) there needs to be a minimum of 2 points with some development (^^ minimum). At the top of the level (6-7 marks) there may be 1 developed point (DEV) and 2 partially developed points (^x2) or there may be 4 partially developed points (^x4) covering both sides of the debate. A level 1 answer (1–3 marks) is likely to be short and/or largely common sense. It is unlikely to be a two-sided response and may be undeveloped and list-like. Alternatively, it might be a simple undeveloped point for and a simple undeveloped point against (this would typically score 2 marks). An answer that contains only one partially developed point (^), however many undeveloped points, can only score in this level.

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.