Sociology · May / June 2026 · Paper 21 · Question 3
0495
As printed in the paper
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[2]
Define the term relativity of crime. Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. Crime definitions change. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. Definitions of crime differ depending on culture, era, role and situation/context. 2 Key annotations used: When a correct definitional element or example is used. A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect definition or example is given. An answer scoring two marks will be full definition. It will be clear and contain two creditable elements. One of these elements may be a relevant example. An answer scoring one mark will be a partial definition. This may be:
an answer with one creditable definitional elementa relevant example with no creditable definitional elementan answer that shows some understanding but has some vagueness or confusion.3(a)(ii)[2]
Define the term prejudice. Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. Being racist/discriminating against someone. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. An unfair and unjustified opinion about a group of people that is often based on stereotypes.
3(b)[2]
State two ways the family can prevent an individual from committing crime. Award one mark for each correct way (up to a maximum of two). Possible responses:
Socialisation;Social control;Enforcing rules;Negative sanctions e.g. grounding;Positive sanctions e.g. praise;Role models;Imitation;Any other reasonable response. 2 Key annotations used: for each correct point given. for each incorrect point given.3(c)[6]
Describe three ways surveillance prevents crime. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three). Possible responses:
Targeting suspects – surveillance can be used to focus on individuals or groups who are suspected of being involved in crime and so limit and prevent their offending;Widespread nature – in today’s media saturated world surveillance is widespread meaning individuals and groups are almost continuously being watched. This ‘big brother’ process prevents crime as CCTV acts as a deterrence;Security guards/firms – hiring staff to patrol and keep watch on a business/home prevents crime as the security staff can apprehend criminals ‘in the act’, deter them from targeting that property and/or use weapons or force to incapacitate the criminal;Computer surveillance – monitoring websites visited and emails sent and received allows the authorities to investigate criminal behaviour. Suspects can be arrested and crime thus prevented;Telephone surveillance – phone calls can be monitored to track down and prevent crimes e.g. phone tapping by governments, the military, the police etc.;Aerial surveillance – helicopters, satellites and drones are all used both for deterring criminal behaviour as well as tracking down suspected criminals, finding victims etc.;6 Note: To achieve the second mark in each point the candidate must be focusing on the prevention of crime, e.g. deterrence. Note: Surveillance is likely to be very different in different local contexts. Please be mindful of this when marking and duly credit relevant localised examples. Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark, candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give further details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point. Each correct point described or explained can only be credited with two marks, so answers are likely to be quite concise. However, a relevant description/ explanation does need to be clearly present in order for the second mark to be awarded. Guidance
Social media/the internet – usage can be tracked/monitored and the knowledge of this will a) prevent people from committing crime and b) allow authorities to catch and deal with criminals;Electronic tagging – people/animals/goods can all be tagged in order to prevent crime. This allows authorities to monitor movement, location and restrict certain freedoms in an attempt to prevent crime (e.g. further offending);Undercover surveillance – police officers will often go undercover in order to infiltrate protest groups and criminal gangs. They will use false identities and become involved in the activities of the monitored group in order to try and prevent crime;Any other reasonable response.3(d)[6]
Explain three strengths of using self-report studies to measure crime. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three). Possible responses:
Hidden crimes – self-report studies can show crimes that have not been revealed in the official crime statistics, i.e. have not been recorded. This is particularly true for petty crime/deviant acts;Victimless crimes – these rarely feature in the official crime statistics and therefore sociologists and the government know little about them. Self-report studies can provide information about such crimes, e.g. drug- taking, prostitution;Data from offenders themselves – this is the only method of finding out about crime that gives the offenders a voice. They can talk honestly about the crimes they commit and their motivations for doing so;Improved validity – they are thought to be a better source of information on crime than the official crime statistics where there is a huge dark figure of unreported and unrecorded crime. With the promise of anonymity, self-report studies can shed light on this;Patterns and trends – official statistics show that the majority of crime is committed by men and working- class people. Self-report studies reveal the large amount of crime committed by the higher classes and by females. This allows theories of crime to be questioned;Any other reasonable response. 6 SELF-REPORT STUDIES – research that asks people what crimes they have committed. This is typically by questionnaire/structured interview but can sometimes use a semi-structured interview. Note: Some candidates are talking about victims in their responses. That is not creditable – self-report studies focus on offenders. Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark, candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give further details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point. Each correct point described or explained can only be credited with two marks so answers are likely to be quite concise. However, a relevant description/ explanation does need to be clearly present in order for the second mark to be awarded.3(e)[8]
Discuss reasons why domestic crimes are under- reported. Use Table A to mark answers to this question. Possible responses:
Victim blaming – many victims feel that they are to blame for the crimes committed against them as domestic abusers often manipulate their victims into believing this and so victims do not report the crime;Private matter – domestic crime has historically been seen (by the public and the criminal justice system) as a private matter to be dealt with by the families themselves. Victims do not want anyone else to know;Police – many victims do not report the crime because they do not trust the police/do not think the police will take them seriously/feel the police will not be able to help them/do not want to relive the crime under police investigation;Do not want offender to be punished – they may still love the offender or have no other means of economic support for themselves and their children. Victims may also be worried about breaking up a family;Further abuse – most domestic crimes are not one-offs and thus victims may be reluctant to report the crime as they think it will just make the situation worse and further abuse will ensue;Coercion – this can be both physical and/or emotional. Abusers will force their victims to say nothing about what has happened. They may use emotional manipulation or threats or physical force to ensure this happens. Whichever way, the abuse is unlikely to be reported;Any other reasonable response. 8 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. Use Table A guidance plus metrics below: To score into level 3 (7–8 marks) the candidate must make at least three good quality well developed points (DEVx3). Expect to see sociological concepts and/or theory in the answer. Consistency across all these features is essential to achieve full marks. For example, an answer with three well developed points, one of which is not explicitly conceptual/theoretical, cannot achieve more than 7 marks. To score in level 2 (4–6 marks) the candidate must make a minimum of two accurate sociological points. Use of sociological concepts/theory and/or the quality and development of the points made will be the differentiator for marks within the level. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) expect to see either two accurate points that are at least partially developed (^^) or one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with at least one other undeveloped point. Guidance Higher in the level (5–6 marks) expect better development and range. For example, two developed points (DEVx2) and a partially developed point (^) would be likely to score 6 marks. In level 1 (1–3 marks) points are likely to be simple, perhaps common-sense description with little sociological focus. Answers may also be short, perhaps just making one point. Candidates’ answers will typically identify points but do nothing/little with them i.e. undeveloped points or list-like answers. Sociological evidence and concepts are likely to be lacking or to be inaccurate. For example, one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with a concept/theory will score at the top of the level (3 marks) whereas one undeveloped point will score 1 mark. Do remember, candidates may address the question in different ways;there is no one required answer or approach. Also, don’t just think about the number of concepts used in an answer to determine your mark – their quality and relevance to the specific question is essential here.
3(f)[14]
Evaluate the view that labelling theory is the best explanation for crime and deviance. Use Table B to mark answers to this question. Possible responses for:
Identity – labelling theory recognises the links between being negatively labelled and given a particular status and that person’s self-concept. People see themselves in terms of the views of others which can lead to a self- fulfilling prophecy and deviance;Public labelling – the theory examines the consequences of this process for the labelled individual as it can lead to a loss of family and friends, so encouraging further deviance. For example, they may adopt a deviant identity and join a deviant sub-culture so leading to deviancy amplification;Police – targeting, stereotyping and stop and search are examples of police labelling in action and these can all lead to certain social groups being more likely to be arrested and prosecuted;Resistance – anti-authority sentiments can result in deviance through protests/riots because of prior labelling of some social groups;Males – being labelled as hegemonically masculine and with the associated negative stereotypes can lead to deviance as males have to live up to the label and prove themselves;Individual choice – the theory recognises that human beings are all different and that people can choose whether they accept society’s labels or reject them. Therefore the ‘one size fits all’ explanations of the other theories is not seen in labelling theory, thus making it a better explanation for crime;14 In evaluation, candidates may criticise aspects of the labelling theory’s explanation for crime or provide other explanations for crime that are seen to be better, e.g. Marxism. Either way is fine to credit. In evaluation, candidates may use social factors such as age, gender, ethnicity, social class as better explanations for crime and deviance than labelling theory. This is also an acceptable style for evaluation. Key annotations used: for each correct ‘for’ point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. for each correct evaluation point identified. for when an answer comes to a conclusion or judgement. Guidance
Explaining why a label is given to a person – this is the theory’s focus, not an attempt to explain the criminal act. This is a big difference to other explanations. They are interested in how individuals come to be labelled as deviant and the consequences of this for the labelled person – an entirely different focus;Changes in the criminal justice system – labelling theory has led to changes being implemented in the criminal justice system, e.g. young offenders are often not named in media reports so they have a chance to avoid being labelled and so avoid future offending;Any other reasonable response. Possible responses against:Some behaviour is always deviant – in some cases context and reaction is irrelevant as some behaviour is always seen as deviant. For example, acts of murder are always deviant;Deviance is not created by the label – most people know they are breaking norms and laws when they commit an act of deviance, even if their actions are not detected. Therefore, deviance is not created by the label as labelling theory implies;Passive victims – labelling theory portrays the offenders as passive victims of the labels that have been assigned to them by those with more power. However, human beings make active choices and so make the decision themselves to be deviant, whether or not they have been labelled;Why are some people labelled and others not? – labelling theory does not explain this other than referring to power differentials (Becker). Marxists would say that class structure and who benefits from labelling should be explored more fully;Refer to Table B for guidance plus below: To score in level 4 (12–14 marks) expect to see a minimum of six sociological points. This must be three points for and three points against (or more). If this is not the case the answer cannot score in level 4. Both sides of the debate should be well developed and engage conceptually/theoretically with the question. To be awarded full marks (14 marks) an answer must have 3 good quality, well developed points for and against, a well- developed conclusion (J+DEV) and consistent use of sociological concepts/theory (typically 10+ KU’s). Lower in the level (12–13 marks) an answer may have: DEVx5 and one ^ but is consistently conceptual through all points and has a conclusion or whilst having DEVx6 an answer may have less than 10 KU’s. Alternatively, you may see a strong answer with a less developed conclusion (J rather than J+DEV). A level 4 answer with no conclusion can score a maximum of 12 marks. To score in level 3 (8–11 marks) there must be a two-sided debate with a minimum of 4 sociological points, all with some development. Some accurate sociological concepts/theory will be seen in this level. Answers will contain both developed (DEV) and partially developed points (^). An answer that contains no developed points (DEV) cannot score in level 3. At the bottom of the level (8 marks) there is likely to be 1 conceptual/theoretical developed point (DEV) plus at least 3 partially developed points (^x3). It is likely that there will be more points than this higher in the level (9–10 marks), including more developed points (DEVs) and more concepts/theory (KU). At the top of the level (11 marks) an answer would typically have 5 conceptual/theoretical developed points (DEVx5) covering both sides of the debate or perhaps four developed points (DEV×4) and one or more partially developed points (^ minimum). Guidance
Functionalism – this may be a better explanation for crime as it recognises the importance of socialisation and value consensus and how this can reduce crime and deviance e.g. Parsons;Strain theory – Merton – this may be a better explanation as it explains crimes committed for material gain as well as crimes such as drug-taking where society’s goals have been given up entirely;Subcultural theory – Cohen, Cloward and Ohlin, Miller – this may be a better explanation as it considers collective deviance and why so much is not done for material gain. Focusing on the search for status may better explain the crimes of the young/the marginalised;Marxism – may be a better explanation for crime as it draws attention to those crimes that are ignored by labelling theory e.g. corporate and white-collar crime – such criminals have not been labelled and so are ignored in labelling theory;Feminism – this may be a better explanation for crime as it recognises that most crime is committed by males and the links this has with patriarchy and the stereotypical expectations of masculinity;Any other reasonable response. A very unbalanced debate (e.g. 1 point for and 3 against) will not score at the top of the level, however strong development and conceptuality may be. A one-sided answer, however good, can score a maximum of 6 marks (level 2). A level 2 answer (4–7 marks) is either a one-sided response (remember these can also fall into level 1) or a response with partially developed points (^^s) on both sides of the debate. They may be characterised by less, or even no sociological concepts/theory. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) there needs to be a minimum of 2 points with some development (^^ minimum). At the top of the level (6–7 marks) there may be 1 developed point (DEV) and 2 partially developed points (^x2) or there may be 4 partially developed points (^x4) covering both sides of the debate. A level 1 answer (1–3 marks) is likely to be short and/or largely common sense. It is unlikely to be a two-sided response and may be undeveloped and list-like. Alternatively, it might be a simple undeveloped point for and a simple undeveloped point against (this would typically score 2 marks). An answer that contains only one partially developed point (^), however many undeveloped points, can only score in this level.
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

