Sociology · May / June 2026 · Paper 11 · Question 3
0495
As printed in the paper
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[2]
Define the term open society. Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. a meritocracy. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. a society where people can move through social roles and change statuses. 2 Key annotations used: When a correct definitional element or example is used. A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect definition or example is given. An answer scoring two marks will be full definition. It will be clear and contain two creditable elements. One of these elements may be a relevant example.
3(a)(ii)[2]
Define the term life chances. Award one mark for a partial definition, e.g. a better job. Award two marks for a clear definition, e.g. the opportunities people have to improve their lives. 2 Key annotations used: When a correct definitional element or example is used. A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect definition or example is given. An answer scoring two marks will be full definition. It will be clear and contain two creditable elements. One of these elements may be a relevant example.
3(b)[2]
Give two examples of pull factors in migration. Possible answers:
better education;better employment;better living standards;a western consumer culture;hope of better treatment/rights’;safety;any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of two). 2 Key annotations used: for each correct point given. for each incorrect point given.3(c)[6]
Describe three ways wealth can be redistributed. Possible answers:
unemployment benefits – taking money from taxes given by richer people and giving money to those left unemployed;providing jobs to unemployed people e.g. government schemes – this can give people a basic level of income and helps them to avoid absolute poverty;state pensions – a minimum amount of money designed to keep older people out of poverty, paid for out of taxation;free or subsidised housing for the disadvantaged – paid for from government money;progressive taxation – where wealthy people pay a higher rate of tax on their earnings than those on lower incomes, this money can then be used to help the poorer members of society;a national minimum wage – guarantees a basic level of income for low wage workers, set by the government but paid for by employers, preventing poverty and reducing social inequality;universal basic income – when the government pay everyone a set amount of money each month, ensuring that no one is living in poverty;land reform – in some places the government has taken back land from certain groups and given it to others e.g. in Zimbabwe during the 1980s White farmers lost land which was given to poor Black people in rural areas;grants to people to set up or support a small business – money gained from taxing richer people can be re- directed to small farmers or entrepreneurs from the working class;6 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point. Guidance
wealth or inheritance tax – when richer people die a proportion of the value of their estate goes to the state who can use it to fund welfare programmes;NGOs can redistribute wealth from prosperous donors (including some governments) and use the money to address economic inequalities, provide healthcare or support poor people with direct grants;wealth can be redistributed through services such as free and universal education or free healthcare;any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three).3(d)[6]
Explain three negative effects of urbanisation. Possible answers:
cities in developing countries take resources from the countryside such as food and water to service the increasing number of people in the cities;increased levels of crime – there is likely to be more violent crime, theft etc. in cities as opposed to rural areas;urbanisation can lead to social inequalities of all kinds e.g. in housing, income levels, access to services such as education and healthcare etc.;cities can function as ‘drains’ soaking up a country’s resources, particularly human resources, leaving fewer young people in rural areas to manage traditional economic activities such as farming;the number of people living in slums or shanty towns or favelas increases, giving them no legal rights and forcing them to live in overcrowded conditions often with contaminated water supplies and no/irregular energy supplies;shanty towns in new urban centres can often lack proper sanitation, giving rise to disease and lower life expectancy;any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for each point correctly identified (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three). 6 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding. This may include addressing how or why something is the case, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third point.3(e)[8]
Discuss Marxist criticisms of the welfare state. Your answer should include:
at least three developed points with evidence. Possible answers:the welfare state cushions the harshest effects of capitalism on the proletariat and thus gives a false impression – creating a false consciousness in working people of a caring system;the welfare state reduces any demands for radical change or revolution because it keeps the working class happy with their basic needs being met by benefits etc.;the welfare state can lead to a divided working class with those in employment criticising those who are unemployed or who exist on government benefits, sometimes labelling them as scroungers and lazy rather than as victims of the system;the welfare state can be used to control the proletariat or working class because it makes them dependent on the state rather than empowering them to join together to challenge capitalism;by providing healthcare and education the welfare state enables capitalism to continue by proving a steady stream of healthy, educated workers who continue the cycle of exploitation;providing temporary relief the welfare state does nothing to tackle the root causes of inequality which lie within capitalism itself and the division between those who own the means of production and the wage slave workers;any other reasonable answer. Use Table C to mark answers to this question. 8 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/ theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. To score into level 3 (7–8 marks) the candidate must make at least three good quality well developed points (DEVx3). Expect to see sociological concepts and/or theory in the answer. Consistency across all these features is essential to achieve full marks. For example, an answer with three well developed points, one of which is not explicitly conceptual/theoretical, cannot achieve more than 7 marks. To score in level 2 (4–6 marks) the candidate must make a minimum of two accurate sociological points. Use of sociological concepts/theory and/or the quality and development of the points made will be the differentiator for marks within the level. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) expect to see either two accurate points that are at least partially developed (^^) or one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with at least one other undeveloped point. Higher in the level (5–6 marks) expect better development and range. Guidance For example, two developed points (DEVx2) and a partially developed point (^) would be likely to score 6 marks. In level 1 (1–3 marks) points are likely to be simple, perhaps common-sense description with little sociological focus. Answers may also be short, perhaps just making one point. Candidates’ answers will typically identify points but do nothing/little with them i.e. undeveloped points or list-like answers. Sociological evidence and concepts are likely to be lacking or to be inaccurate. For example, one good quality, well developed point (DEV) with a concept/theory will score at the top of the level (3 marks) whereas one undeveloped point will score 1 mark.3(f)[14]
Evaluate the view that ethnicity has the most influence on whether an individual lives in poverty. Your answer should include:
at least three arguments for and three arguments againsta conclusion. Possible answers for:racial discrimination in the workplace prevents some people in ethnic minorities from gaining employment thus exposing them to welfare dependency and poverty;in closed societies some ethnic groups may hold a lower ascribed status and be prevented from integrating into society or given basic human rights e.g. Black people in apartheid South Africa;some ethnic groups experience racism in education e.g. via teacher labelling;language barriers may mean that some ethnic minorities struggle to access the school curriculum and therefore underachieve in exams leading to lower chances of a well-paid job;New Right thinkers such as Charles Murray argue that some ethnic groups are at greater risk of being in the underclass, they are thus more likely to become trapped in poverty;ethnic minorities/migrants can often become trapped in modern slavery and trafficked into illegal and/or low wage work in a new country;ethnic minorities/migrants are often negatively labelled and portrayed as criminals in the media leading to discrimination and poverty;many people living in extreme poverty globally live in sub-Saharan Africa or South Asia where economies are underdeveloped;any other reasonable answer. 14 Key annotations used: for each correct ‘for’ point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/ theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. for each correct evaluation point identified. for when an answer comes to a conclusion or judgement. To score in level 4 (12–14 marks) expect to see a minimum of six sociological points. This must be three points for and three points against (or more). If this is not the case the answer cannot score in level 4. Both sides of the debate should be well developed and engage conceptually/theoretically with the question. To be awarded full marks (14 marks) an answer must have 3 good quality, well developed points for and against, a well- developed conclusion (J+DEV) and consistent use of sociological concepts/theory (typically 10+ KU’s). Lower in the level (12–13 marks) an answer may have: DEVx5 and one ^ but is consistently conceptual through all points and has a conclusion or whilst having DEVx6 an answer may have less than 10 KU’s. Alternatively, you may see a strong answer with a less developed conclusion (J rather than J+DEV). A level 4 answer with no conclusion can score a maximum of 12 marks. Guidance Possible answers against:the feminisation of poverty – women of different ethnicities are over-represented in the numbers of poor people due to cultural prejudices and patriarchal stereotypes e.g. women being expected to be child carers and, in some countries, being denied access to education and jobs;functionalists argue that poverty is inevitable but that in a meritocracy individuals from any ethnicity can potentially achieve social mobility through talent and merit;intersectionality – it is not simply ethnicity but a combination of factors, such as gender, age and social class, which increases the likelihood of an individual being in poverty;ageism is more influential than ethnicity in causing poverty e.g. the elderly can be forced to leave their jobs and exist on inadequate pensions or rely on economic support from their familiespeople who are born into the underclass are likely to experience a cycle of poverty and remain in the same economic position as their parents e.g. because they may be forced to leave school early to work to support their family, thus leaving them without qualifications and stuck in low wage occupations;Marxists argue that inequalities caused by global capitalism cause widespread poverty due to the economic division between the bourgeoisie and proletariat and multinational corporations exploiting the resources of developing nations;any other reasonable answer. Use Table D to mark answers to this question. To score in level 3 (8–11 marks) there must be a two-sided debate with a minimum of 4 sociological points, all with some development. Some accurate sociological concepts/theory will be seen in this level. Answers will contain both developed (DEV) and partially developed points (^). An answer that contains no developed points (DEV) cannot score in level 3. At the bottom of the level (8 marks) there is likely to be 1 conceptual/theoretical developed point (DEV) plus at least 3 partially developed points (^x3). It is likely that there will be more points than this higher in the level (9–10 marks), including more developed points (DEVs) and more concepts/theory (KU). At the top of the level (11 marks) an answer would typically have 5 conceptual/theoretical developed points (DEVx5) covering both sides of the debate or perhaps four developed points (DEVx4) and one or more partially developed points (^ minimum). A very unbalanced debate (e.g. 1 point for and 3 against) will not score at the top of the level, however strong development and conceptuality may be. A one-sided answer, however good, can score a maximum of 6 marks (level 2). A level 2 answer (4–7 marks) is either a one-sided response (remember these can also fall into level 1) or a response with partially developed points (^^s) on both sides of the debate. They may be characterised by less, or even no sociological concepts/theory. At the bottom of the level (4 marks) there needs to be a minimum of 2 points with some development (^^ minimum). At the top of the level (6–7 marks) there may be 1 developed point (DEV) and 2 partially developed points (^x2) or there may be 4 partially developed points (^x4) covering both sides of the debate. Guidance A level 1 answer (1–3 marks) is likely to be short and/or largely common sense. It is unlikely to be a two-sided response and may be undeveloped and list-like. Alternatively, it might be a simple undeveloped point for and a simple undeveloped point against (this would typically score 2 marks). An answer that contains only one partially developed point (^), however many undeveloped points, can only score in this level.
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

