Note AcademyNote Academy

Sociology · May / June 2026 · Paper 11 · Question 1

0495

As printed in the paper

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 1(a)(i)[2]

    From Source A, identify the two countries with the biggest increase in the number of males in prison between 1980 and 2020. Acceptable answers:

    Brazil
    Russia Award one mark for each point correctly identified from Source A (up to a maximum of two). 2 Key annotations used: When a correct point from the source is given. A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect point is given.
  • 1(a)(ii)[4]

    Using information in Source A, explain two reasons why the data is useful for researching crime. Possible answers:

    the data is quantitative – allowing researchers to compare patterns in the male prison population across different countries;
    the data is quantitative – allowing researchers to compare trends in the male prison population across time;
    it comes from official statistics – apart from this there is no other way for researchers to access the figures on the male prison population;
    it comes from official statistics – this type of data is often seen as trustworthy and reliable as it is done professionally by people working for the government;
    the data shows rising numbers of criminals that may suggest rising crime in these countries – so can alert governments to act to try and reduce offending;
    the data runs up to 2020 – so it gives a relatively up to date picture of male prison rates;
    It shows data from different continents – this may be helpful in giving a snapshot from around the world;
    any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for each point correctly identified from Source A (up to a maximum of two). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of two). 4 Key annotations used: When a correct reason from the source is given (see examples in italics). A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect reason is given. For appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark candidates need to identify an appropriate reason from within Source A. Having identified an appropriate reason, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. This will involve addressing how or why something is useful, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second point. Notes Reference to reliability, validity should only be credited if explained. Points that refer to the data showing an increase in crime (rather than male prisoners) should not be credited. Points that identify that the data comes from 5 countries – avoid crediting explanations that suggest such a sample is representative.
  • 1(a)(iii)[6]

    Using information in Source A, explain three problems with the data for understanding crime. Possible answers:

    the data only shows the prison population – understanding crime requires much more than this e.g. some commit crime but never actually end up in prison etc.;
    the last data is 2020/outdated – this means the data is now old and the prison numbers in each country could now be very different;
    the data is only about males in prison– this tells us nothing about females and hence only gives a partial picture of the prison population;
    the data is only about males who are 21 and over – there is no mention of prisoners who are younger than this and hence the data is not a full picture of male prisoners;
    the actual data is quantitative and this gives researchers no understanding of why males are committing crime – for this qualitative data is needed;
    the source has been adapted – this means it has been modified in some way and hence may not show an accurate picture of the male prison population numbers in the selected countries;
    the information comes from the government who may have a political agenda and manipulate the data to show what they want e.g. that crime is getting worse in order to justify a crackdown on law and order;
    the data only shows 1980 and 2020 – there is a 40 year gap in the data so we have no information about prison rates in the intervening years;

    6 Key annotations used: When a correct reason from the source is given (see examples in italics). A maximum of two TICKS per answer. When an incorrect reason is given. For appropriate development of a point. The question is marked in the same way as question 1 (a) (ii). To achieve the first mark candidates need to identify an appropriate point from within Source A. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. This will involve addressing how or why something is a problem, supporting with relevant evidence and/or building upon information given. The same process as above should be followed for the second and third points. Notes Reference to representativeness, reliability, validity should only be credited if explained. Guidance

    the information is only relevant to the selected countries – it tells us nothing about, for example, the situation in the vast majority of countries across the world, so it is unrepresentative of the world and cannot be generalised;
    the numbers have been rounded up to the nearest thousand – so none of the figures are absolutely accurate;
    any other reasonable response. Award one mark for each point correctly identified from Source A (up to a maximum of three). Award one mark for each point that is developed (up to a maximum of three).
  • 1(b)[2]

    State two practical issues that can affect sociological research. Possible answers:

    time;
    cost/funding;
    access to subjects or sample;
    finding/training researchers;
    response rates e.g. in a self-completion questionnaire;
    facilities e.g. room for a focus groups
    any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for each example correctly identified (up to maximum of two). 2 Key annotations used: for each correct example given. for each incorrect example given.
  • 1(c)[4]

    Explain one strength and one limitation of using covert observation in sociological research. Possible strengths:

    it is useful when researching deviant or criminal groups as going undercover will enable ‘secret’ behaviours to be uncovered and recorded, enhancing validity;
    the researcher does not have to gain permission to enter a group, saving time;
    ethics – in the study of dangerous groups going covert should protect the researcher from possible harm;
    the covert nature of the research means that the researcher is more likely to gain a true or valid picture of the group’s behaviour and views because the researcher is taking part secretly;
    it avoids the Hawthorne Effect so the behaviour of the group will not change due to the researcher’s presence;
    covert participant research usually takes place in a naturalistic setting, so the normal behaviour of the group can be studied often over time;
    any other reasonable answer. Possible limitations:
    the researcher may need to take a lot of time and trouble in maintaining their cover, rather than gaining information – this can negatively affect the data gathered;
    the participants have not given their consent to be observed and thus the research is unethical;
    to maintain cover a researcher may have to do things he/she may not want to do e.g. commit a crime;
    it is difficult to take regular, accurate notes – a researcher may have to wait until the end of the day when their memory may not be fully accurate;

    4 Key annotations used: for each correct point given. for each incorrect point given. for appropriate development of a point. To achieve the first mark candidates need to identify an appropriate point. Having identified an appropriate point, this then needs to be developed to achieve the second mark. Development should give further details that demonstrate knowledge and understanding of how or why something is a strength or limitation of the aspect of methodology in the question. Guidance

    it is difficult to combine with other research methods e.g. asking interview-style questions whilst observing may raise suspicion;
    a researcher may be prone to bias if he/she develops empathy for the group under study, this can lead to a biased view and invalid data;
    most observation is unique and difficult to repeat and hence low in reliability;
    observations tend to be small scale and are thus unlikely to be representative of a wider group;
    any other reasonable answer. Award one mark for a strength correctly identified. Award one mark for development of the strength. Award one mark for a limitation correctly identified. Award one mark for development of the limitation.
  • 1(d)[10]

    Evaluate the use of surveys in sociological research. Your answer should include:

    at least two arguments for and two arguments against
    a conclusion. Possible arguments for:
    due to the quantitative nature of the data sociologists can use survey data to make comparisons e.g. between the responses of different cohorts;
    the closed question format of surveys is useful for generating patterns and trends in data;
    surveys are generally high in reliability due to the structured nature of the format;

    hence they can be repeated and similar responses will be gained;

    they can be done on a large scale via questionnaire and so sample size may be more representative of target population;
    it is possible to access geographically distant populations via post, telephone or online surveys, enhancing representativeness;
    if the survey is done via self-completion questionnaire a researcher is not present so cannot influence answers given, raising validity;
    if done via questionnaire they are convenient for the respondent who can complete it in their own time;
    due to fact that surveys are often quantitative they can be easily analysed by putting the data into tables, charts, graphs etc.;
    any other reasonable answer. 10 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for full development of a point. for partial development of a point. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories/studies. for when a relevant example is given to support a point. for each correct evaluation point identified. for when an answer comes to a conclusion or judgement. Notes To credit a point relating to the idea that people will lie on a survey, it needs to be properly explained. To credit a point about surveys being quick the response must contrast with another method or give other supporting reasons. To score in level 3 (8–10 marks) expect to see at least four sociological points. This must be two points for and two points against (or more). If this is not the case the answer cannot score in level 3. Both sides of the debate should be well developed and engage conceptually/theoretically with the question. Guidance Possible arguments against:
    survey responses are low if done via self-completion questionnaire which may affect the representativeness of the sample;
    surveys are not always valid;

    their findings may not always be accurate or reflect reality – this may be because closed or structured questions are mainly used with no room for respondents to elaborate and give detail;

    if done via questionnaire the researcher cannot always be sure who answered the questions and this may invalidate the responses as the person may not be in the targeted sample;
    in questionnaires respondents often leave some questions unanswered, as there is no researcher present, and this means that data will be incomplete;
    if a survey is done via structured interview the interviewer effect may take place thus lowering the validity of the data;
    any other reasonable answer. Use Table A to mark answers to this question. To be awarded full marks (10 marks) an answer must have two good quality, well developed points for and against the view (DEVx2+DEVx2), a conclusion and consistent use of sociological concepts/theory (typically 6+ KU’s). To score marks lower in the level (8–9 marks) the quality of development may be a little uneven (e.g. DEVx3 + ^ though a conclusion is present) and/or concepts/theory may not be used consistently throughout. If there is no conclusion, but all four points are well developed and conceptual (DEV x4), a maximum of 8 marks may be credited. A level 2 answer (4–7 marks) is likely to lack the range and/or detail needed to score in level 3. Answers will contain both developed (DEV) and partially developed points (^). Some accurate sociological concepts/theory will be seen in this level. At the bottom of level 2 (4 marks) an answer would have a minimum of two partially developed points (^x2). To score at the higher end of the level (6–7 marks) there must be evidence of a debate. A one-sided answer, however good, can score a maximum of 5 marks. At the top of the level (7 marks) an answer would typically have 3 conceptual/theoretical points (DEVx3) possibly with one or more partially developed points (^), but no conclusion. A level 1 answer (1–3 marks) is likely to be short and/or largely common sense. It is unlikely to be a two-sided response and may be undeveloped and list-like. Alternatively, it might be a simple undeveloped point for and a simple undeveloped point against (this would typically score 2 marks). An answer that contains only one partially developed point (^), however many undeveloped points, can only score in this level.
  • 1(e)[12]

    Explain the research methods and evidence that you would choose to investigate why some children achieve better examination results than others. Give reasons for your choices. Your answer should include:

    two primary methods with relevant sampling
    one source of secondary evidence. Possible methods:
    interviews (any type)
    questionnaires
    surveys
    observation (all types)
    longitudinal studies
    other suitable method. Possible sampling points:
    the group to be studied
    the size of sample
    the type of sample
    the composition of the sample
    access to the sample
    other relevant sampling points. Possible sources of secondary evidence:
    statistics (e.g. exam results);
    previous sociological and other research on how different social classes, ethnicities and genders perform in/experience education;
    media materials e.g. social networking sites, magazine articles, blogs,
    forums, TV documentaries, newspaper articles etc. that discuss social class/ethnicity/gender and education;

    12 Key annotations used: for each correct point identified. for each incorrect point identified. for correct use of sociological concepts/theories. for correct justification or reasons given for the choice of research method, sample or evidence. for when a candidate makes reference to the context for their research plan. Question e is marked using the generic mark scheme levels in Table B. Answers are marked according to three criteria: methods and evidence, reasons for choices and application to context. Each criteria has four levels: excellent (4 marks), good (3 marks), some (2 marks) and limited (1 mark). Assessors should choose a mark for each criteria separately, then add the marks together to reach the final mark. Answers which show no knowledge and understanding and/or give no reasons for choices and/or show no application to context would of course be awarded 0 marks for the relevant criteria. CONT JUST Guidance

    personal documents/diaries/social network entries of students/teachers and others involved in education;
    other suitable evidence. Use Table B to mark answers to this question. Methods and evidence Application to context Reasons for choices To mark the answer you should decide the level for each of the three criteria (e.g. reasons for choices). Look for the ‘best fit’ of the answer in a level. Consider the levels above and/or below, if appropriate, to ensure you have selected the right one. In order to be placed in a level an answer needs to show evidence of most of the qualities described in that level.

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.