Sociology · May / June 2023 · Paper 12 · Question 1
0495
As printed in the paper
The question as text
Source A 1 Zimbardo (1973) conducted an experiment on conformity to social roles. His aim was to investigate whether people would conform to the social roles of a prison guard or prisoner when they were placed in a pretend prison environment. Zimbardo had a sample of 21 male university students. The students volunteered in response to a newspaper advert. The students were then randomly selected to play the role of either a prisoner or a guard. Zimbardo wanted to make the experiment realistic so he turned part of a building into a pretend prison with cells. The students who played the role of prisoners were also arrested by real police, had their fingerprints taken and were given prison clothes to wear with chains around one ankle. The guards wore uniforms and carried handcuffs and a baton. Researchers told the guards to run the prison for two weeks without using physical violence. However, the guards became abusive when the prisoners began to complain. Five of the prisoners left the experiment early because they could not cope physically or mentally. For example, they were crying and experienced extreme anxiety. Zimbardo found that both the prisoners and guards soon identified with their social roles. He concluded that people quickly conform to social roles, even when the role goes against their moral beliefs. Source: https://www.simplypsychology.org/zimbardo.html
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
1(a)[2]
From Source A, identify two ways Zimbardo tried to make the experiment realistic. Acceptable responses:
he turned part of a building into a pretend prison with cells;the prisoners were arrested by real police;the prisoners were fingerprinted;the prisoners wore prison clothes and had a chain around one ankle;the guards carried batons;the guards wore uniforms and handcuffs. One mark for each way correctly identified from Source A (up to a maximum of two).1(b)[2]
Identify two types of questions used by sociologists when conducting research. Possible answers:
closed questions;open questions;pre-coded questions;scaled or Likert questions;multiple choice questions;any other reasonable response. One mark for each type of question correctly identified (up to maximum of two).1(c)[4]
Using information from Source A, describe two problems with the way the research was conducted. Possible answers:
the sample is unrepresentative – only 21 students took part and therefore the findings cannot be generalised;the sample were all male – this doesn’t take female behaviours into account and is therefore unrepresentative;the sample were all students – they may have known each other before the research OR this means the research is not representative of the behaviour of non-students;the sample were volunteers – often this type of sample attracts participants with strong views and hence data may be biased;ethical issues – some students playing the role of guard became abusive to others playing the role of prisoner thus causing potential harm;ethical issues some individuals left the study early because they could not cope mentally or physically and thus the researcher failed to properly safeguard them;cost – Zimbardo had to find funding for converting a building into realistic cells;the research was an experiment and interpretivists have concerns about the idea of using human beings as ‘guinea pigs’ for study;the prison was only ‘pretend’ – this means that participants behaviour may not have been entirely natural/authentic and hence validity may be negatively affected;some participants left the experiment early due to the mental and physical effects so Zimbardo’s findings may have been affected by the reduced sample size;any other reasonable answer. One mark for each point correctly identified from the source (up to a maximum of two). One mark for each point that is correctly developed (up to a maximum of two).1(d)[4]
Describe two limitations of using non-official statistics in sociological research. Possible answers:
non-official statistics may be biased to reflect the interests of the company /organisations that gather them – they may thus lack validity;they are quantitative data and interpretivists argue that they cannot answer the ‘why’ of social behaviour;any statistical account will represent a “snapshot” of social interaction as it was only when the statistics were compiled;non-official statistics may not be done on a large scale due to cost and hence they may lack representativesness;non-official statistics as secondary data may not always cohere with the aims of the researcher and thus their usefulness is limited;non-official statistics conducted on behalf of businesses, charities or political organisations may be biased to advance their cause negatively affecting accuracy;non-official statistics are secondary data – the researcher was not present when the initial research was done and so can never be sure it was done correctly;any other reasonable answer. One mark for each limitation correctly identified (up to a maximum of two). One mark for each limitation that is developed (up to a maximum of two).1(e)[8]
Describe two strengths and two limitations of a positivist approach to sociological research. Possible strengths:
positivism relies on quantitative data that is more reliable than qualitative research and hence other researchers can check results;positivists adopt a ‘scientific’ approach and aim to provide value-free objective information that is unbiased;positivists prefer quantitative data which can be turned into statistics and compared in terms of patterns and trends;positivists use quantitative data which can be turned into charts and graphs and easily analysed;positivists can test a hypothesis using evidence gathered;positivism is a macro approach which studies the big social forces in society, such as social class or socialisation, and how they fit into the bigger picture;positivists use large samples which are more likely to be representative and generalisable;any other reasonable answer. Possible limitations:the quantitative data positivists like lacks depth and detail and hence lacks validity;although positivism encourages researchers to disregard human emotion and values, this is an impossible ideal and all research is to some extent biased;positivists are not able to achieve verstehen as they do not believe in allowing subjectivity and empathy into the research process;positivists use quantitative data they cannot understand the reasons behind their data – the why or the meanings and motivations attached to social behaviour;positivists do not seek to achieve rapport with respondents and thus their data may lack validity;a positivist approach may be more likely to bring ethical issues e.g. some lab experiments and other experiments such as Zimbardo’s in Source A;sociology is not a science in which human behaviour is to be studied in a detached, objective manner – instead human motivations need to be uncovered to get an accurate picture;any other reasonable answer. One mark for each strength correctly identified (up to a maximum of two). One mark for each strength that is developed (up to a maximum of two). One mark for each limitation correctly identified (up to a maximum of two) One mark for each limitation that is developed (up to a maximum of two).1(f)[10]
Explain why feminists believe that society is based on conflict. Possible answers:
feminists argue that we live in a patriarchal society which is dominated by males e.g. males hold most of the important posts in society and make the key decisions and this is unfair;in the family males dominate women and children e.g. through the reality or threat of domestic violence and so conflict can be physical as well as emotional;in the workplace women face a glass ceiling created and maintained by men so women cannot access the top jobs and this creates conflict;a system of vertical segregation is in place in which women are expected to work in low paid, low status jobs often linked to stereotypical female role such as nursery workers or cleaners whereas male jobs are often higher paid and higher status – this inequality breeds social conflict;schools still allow boys to dominate in class and, in some cases, females are denied a proper education or channelled into ‘feminine subjects’ such as cooking and arts whilst boys are expected to do the ‘harder’ subjects such as physics and maths;at every stage women have had to fight for more rights – men have rarely given women equality proactively e.g. the legal conflict that resulted in women being given the vote;Marxist feminists believe that both class and gender work together to effectively oppress women and keep men in their power a conflict of interest runs through the social structure;any other reasonable response. Band 0 [0 marks] No creditworthy response. Band 1 [1–3 marks] Answers in this band will show only a limited awareness of the question. A tendency to description is likely. Responses may be short and undeveloped and points stated without explanation. Sociological terms and concepts are unlikely to be used. At the bottom of the band (1 mark), expect one weak point. Higher in the band (2–3 marks), candidates may offer more than one weak point. Band 2 [4–7 marks] Answers in this band will show basic sociological knowledge and understanding. Responses may be underdeveloped and lacking in range. At the bottom of the band, candidates are unlikely to use sociological terms and concepts accurately. Higher in the band, candidates may be beginning to use sociological terms and concepts with greater accuracy. However, some aspects of the answer may only be partially developed/explained. Band 3 [8–10 marks] Answers in this band will show good sociological knowledge and understanding and will be well-developed and explained. Sociological terms and concepts will be used accurately overall. Answers will be well-focused on the question and there will be a range of points presented. At the top of the band explanations will be clear throughout1(g)[15]
To what extent is secondary data useful for sociological researchers? Possible arguments for:
secondary data like diaries, historical documents etc. can offer great insight and may be a valid snapshot of social interactions;documents never intended for publication may be valid because the individual has no reason to be biased/lie;there is a lot of it – it is the richest vein of information available to researchers in many topic areas;some large data sets might not exist if not for the government collecting statistics;sometimes documents and official statistics might be the only means of researching the past;official statistics may be especially useful for making comparisons over time e.g. the U.K. Census for example goes back to 1851;on a practical level, many public documents and official statistics are freely available to the researcher saving both time and cost;any other reasonable answer. Possible arguments against:primary research is more valid as it allows the researcher to obtain original data that are current and highly specific to his or her needs;primary methods such as questionnaires or structured interviews may be better as they allow the researcher themselves to collect quantitative data from which patterns and trends may be seen;primary methods such as observations or unstructured interviews are better because they allow researchers to gather detailed qualitative data which is likely to be highly valid;a major disadvantage of secondary research is that the researcher may have difficulty obtaining information specific to his or her needs and hence it may not always be wholly relevant thus negatively affecting validity;some sources of secondary data such as diaries may be unrepresentative;secondary data sources such as personal documents may be biased and hence lack validity;official statistics may reflect the way things have been categorised rather than reality e.g. crime figures;official statistics may reflect the biases of those in power – limiting what you can find out;official statistics – the way things are measured may change over time, making historical comparisons difficult e.g. crime statistics, the definition of crime keeps changing;documents may lack authenticity– parts of the document might be missing because of age, and we might not even be able to verify who wrote the document, meaning we cannot check whether its biased or not;many documents do not survive because they are not stored, and others deteriorate with age and become unusable;some documents are deliberately withheld from researchers and the public gaze, and therefore do not become available e.g. secret documents;any other reasonable answer. Band 0 [0 marks] No creditworthy response. Band 1 [1–4 marks] Answers in this band may be vague and largely based on common sense showing limited knowledge of the debate. Use of sociological terms or concepts is very unlikely. Responses may be short, undeveloped and one- sided. Lower in the band (1–2 marks), expect one or two weak points. Higher in the band (3–4 marks) candidates may offer more than two points and provide a weak definition of key terms in the question. Band 2 [5–8 marks] In this band candidates will show some basic knowledge of the debate. Alternatively, they may offer an answer which is list-like in nature but there will be no real attempt to assess the issues raised by the question. There may be limited / some use of sociological terms or concepts. Responses may be underdeveloped and lack range. Answers may be simplistic and two-sided or only cover one side of the debate. Lower in the band, the response may be rather narrow in the points covered and there may be some development. Higher in the band, more points are likely to be covered with some development. Alternatively, a list-like answer with some development covering both sides of the argument may score up to 8 marks. A one-sided answer cannot score higher than 8 marks. Band 3 [9–12 marks] Answers in this band will show good sociological knowledge and understanding of the debate. Sociological terms and concepts will be used with greater accuracy and / or frequency. For the most part, answers will be well-developed, focused on the questions and there will be a range of points presented. There will be a two-sided response, but it may lack range on one side. At the bottom of the band, candidates may provide a narrower range of developed points. At the top of the band, expect a wider range of developed points and clear focus on the question. Band 4 [13–15 marks] Answers in this band will show excellent knowledge and understanding of the debate. There will be a strong grasp of the arguments as well as accurate and frequent use of sociological terms and concepts. Answers will be well- developed, clearly focused on the question and discuss a wide range of points. Responses will be two-sided and have a range of points on each side. At the bottom of the band (13 marks), the answer may lack a specific conclusion. Higher in the band, there will be a clear attempt to offer an assessment of the ‘To what extent?’ part of the question through a focused conclusion.
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

