Note AcademyNote Academy

Sociology · Oct / Nov 2020 · Paper 12 · Question 3

0495

As printed in the paper

The question as text

In all modern societies relative poverty still exists. Equal opportunities legislation is often used to argue that society is becoming more fair today, with individuals able to improve their income, wealth 3 and status. But poverty is difficult to measure accurately and sociologists disagree about the exact causes of social and economic inequality.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 3(a)[2]

    What is meant by the term ‘relative poverty’? One mark for partial definition, e.g. ‘not being able to buy things like good quality shoes’. Two marks for clear definition, e.g. ‘not able to afford what the majority in a society see as an acceptable lifestyle’ or ‘… being poor in relation to others in a society’.

  • 3(b)[4]

    Describe two ways status can be achieved. Possible answers:

    working hard and putting effort into something will often bring greater prestige, respect and status;
    work – gaining promotion and thus earning a higher status within an organisation, e.g. as supervisory or managerial role;
    education – gaining qualifications which can bring status in themselves, e.g. degree and higher degrees or as a route to higher status as part of a job;
    being a professional athlete requires dedication, effort and hard work and often brings high status if successful;
    becoming an accomplished criminal, e.g. within a gang engaging in highly deviant acts may bring higher status within the hierarchy;
    marriage can be a route to higher status, particularly in traditional societies;
    parenthood – the status of mother or father is achieved rather than ascribed at birth;
    any other reasonable response. One mark for each way identified (up to a maximum of two). One mark for each description (up to a maximum of two). 4 Achieved status = status that individuals acquire by their own merits, hard work and efforts.
  • 3(c)[6]

    Explain how traditional male roles have changed in modern industrial societies. Possible answers:

    gendered horizontal segregation is breaking down as more males now find work in traditionally female occupations such as nursing and more women enter formerly male only occupations such as engineering and construction;
    there is a ‘crisis of masculinity’ (Mac an Ghaill) following the decline in working class manual jobs wherein the working class male role of the provider is receding;
    the advent of the New Man means that men are now starting to share in domestic work with their partners or wives;
    some males are now taking on a more active role in parenthood;
    the traditional heroic and protective role of men is now questioned by feminists when they highlight the prevalence of rape and sexual abuse of women and children;
    men can now be seen as sex objects in a similar way to women in the media;
    the dominance of heterosexual white men is now being challenged in modern industrial societies by feminists and black and gay activism;
    expectations linked to male gender roles have changed, e.g. it’s now more acceptable for men to show their feelings, be focused on their appearance etc.;
    the value of men’s role in the family is being questioned as more women choose to bring up children on their own;
    the appearance of ‘Retributive’ man – where men today reassert traditional masculinity trying to turn the clock back to a time that has passed;
    any other reasonable response. Guidance Band 0 [0 marks] No creditworthy response. Band 1 [1–3 marks] Answers in this band will show only a limited awareness of the question. Responses may be short and un/underdeveloped. At the bottom of the band (1 mark), expect one weak point. Higher in the band (2–3 marks), candidates may offer more than one weak point, but there may be a tendency towards simplistic answers, engaging with sociological ideas without using sociological language. Band 2 [4–6 marks] Answers in this band will have clear and accurate explanation, showing good sociological knowledge and understanding. Sociological terms and concepts should be expected and explained. At the bottom of the band, the range of points covered may be narrow or lack detail. Higher in the band, answers will cover more than one point in a well-developed way or cover several points in less detail.
  • 3(d)[8]

    Explain why poverty is difficult to define. Possible answers:

    living standards are higher in modern industrial societies than in developing societies yet there are poor in both types of society, so it is difficult to reach a standard definition;
    it is difficult to define poverty as there are different types: absolute and relative;
    relative poverty takes the social context into account so an individual who is relatively poor in one society may not be relatively poor in another – this makes international definitions and comparisons difficult;
    there are different ways of defining the poverty level in society, e.g. less than 60% of median income is one measure, but why 60% – this seems arbitrary;
    some try to define poverty on the basis of the total cost of ‘necessities’ (e.g. Townsend’s study of poverty in the UK), but this may be problematic in terms of who classifies what items as ‘necessities’;
    defining poverty can be difficult because poverty can involve many factors such as education, health, housing etc., and so any attempts to define poverty will need to take these into account;
    Mack and Lansley’s Breadline Britain stipulated that individuals were in poverty if they lacked 3 or more items on a pre-defined list of items, but there is little justification of ‘3’ as the crucial number for poverty;
    where is the ‘poverty line’ set? Researchers and governments may differ in their views on this and thus there is no consensus;
    any other reasonable response. Guidance Band 0 [0 marks] No creditworthy response. Band 1 [1–3 marks] Answers in this band will show only a limited awareness of the question. A tendency to description is likely. Responses may be short and undeveloped and points stated without explanation. Sociological terms and concepts are unlikely to be used. At the bottom of the band (1 mark), expect one weak point. Higher in the band (2–3 marks), candidates may offer more than one weak point. Band 2 [4–6 marks] Answers in this band will show basic sociological knowledge and understanding. Responses may be underdeveloped and lacking in range. At the bottom of the band, candidates are unlikely to use sociological terms and concepts accurately. Higher in the band, candidates may be beginning to use sociological terms and concepts with greater accuracy. However, some aspects of the answer may only be partially developed/explained. Band 3 [7–8 marks] Answers in this band will show good sociological knowledge and understanding and will be well- developed and explained. Sociological terms and concepts will be used accurately overall. Answers will be well-focused on the question and there will be a range of points presented. At the top of the band explanations will be clear throughout.
  • 3(e)[15]

    To what extent have government measures failed to reduce social inequality? Arguments for:

    equal opportunities legislation has failed to reduce gender discrimination which remains a significant issue in the workplace via vertical and horizontal segregation;
    women are still subject to domestic violence and sexual violence disproportionately to men thus legislation and tougher sentences have only had minimal impact;
    the education system maintains social inequality despite government measures – so, for example, Marxists argue that social class divisions are reproduced via the hidden curriculum;
    government measures like the welfare state have not tackled social class inequality – right wing thinkers such as Charles Murray argue that the poor themselves, in the form of the underclass, are to blame for their poverty and low social status via the culture of poverty and the culture of dependency;
    despite legislation to tackle ethnic and racial discrimination it persists in many areas such as the workplace, housing and education as well as negative stereotyping in the media;
    equal opportunities legislation has failed to reduce ageism with both young and old suffering discrimination and unequal treatment in the workplace and in terms of their power and status in society;
    Marxists argue that the welfare state ultimately fails to reduce social inequality – it simply promotes the false consciousness that the system is less unjust than it really is, effectively ‘bribing’ the lower classes and making radical change less likely;
    government measures are likely to fail to reduce social inequality because, as functionalists like Davis and Moore argue, social inequality is inevitable in any complex modern society – roles need to be allocated and rewards assigned to these roles and some roles are more socially valued and attract more rewards;
    any other reasonable response. 15 Candidates may also discuss why other agencies (e.g. media) have been more successful than the government in reducing inequality. These could be credited depending on the context. Guidance Arguments against:
    legislation to tackle discrimination such as the Sex Discrimination Act and the Equality Act have made it harder for minorities and women to be openly discriminated against;
    measures such as the welfare state mean that society is now more meritocratic and individuals can achieve social mobility if they work hard;
    governments measure to redistribute wealth such as new tax laws and improved welfare benefits (such as the old age pension) have reduced poverty and narrowed the gap between rich and poor;
    the introduction of free education has improved the life chances of the poorest who can now achieve qualifications and access higher status jobs;
    gender discrimination legislation has improved the lives of women in many social areas such as in education and the workplace where women are now competing successfully with men;
    the introduction of free health care systems, such as the NHS, enable all social groups to access good quality care and thus improve their health and longevity;
    any other reasonable response. Band 0 [0 marks] No creditworthy response. Band 1 [1–4 marks] Answers in this band may be vague and largely based on common sense showing limited knowledge of the debate. Use of sociological terms or concepts is very unlikely. Responses may be short, undeveloped and one-sided. Lower in the band (1–2 marks), expect one or two weak points. Higher in the band (3–4 marks) candidates may offer more than two points and provide a weak definition of key terms in the question. Guidance Band 2 [5–8 marks] In this band candidates will show some basic knowledge of the debate. Alternatively, they may offer an answer which is list-like in nature, but there will be no real attempt to assess the issues raised by the question. There may be limited/some use of sociological terms or concepts. Responses may be underdeveloped and lack range. Answers may be simplistic and two-sided or only cover one side of the debate. Lower in the band, the response may be rather narrow in the points covered and there may be some development. Higher in the band, more points are likely to be covered with some development. Alternatively, a list-like answer with some development covering both sides of the argument may score up to 8 marks. A one-sided answer cannot score higher than 8 marks. Band 3 [9–12 marks] Answers in this band will show good sociological knowledge and understanding of the debate. Sociological terms and concepts will be used with greater accuracy and/or frequency. For the most part, answers will be well-developed, focused on the questions and there will be a range of points presented. There will be a two-sided response, but it may lack range on one side. At the bottom of the band, candidates may provide a narrower range of developed points. At the top of the band, expect a wider range of developed points and clear focus on the question. Band 4 [13–15 marks] Answers in this band will show excellent knowledge and understanding of the debate. There will be a strong grasp of the arguments as well as accurate and frequent use of sociological terms and concepts. Answers will be well-developed, clearly focused on the question and discuss a wide range of points. Responses will be two-sided and have a range of points on each side. At the bottom of the band (13 marks), the answer may lack a specific conclusion. Higher in the band, there will be a clear attempt to offer an assessment of the ‘To what extent?’ part of the question through a focused conclusion.

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.