Physics · Oct / Nov 2024 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 A student made measurements of a wooden metre rule. The width of the metre rule was a and the thickness of the metre rule was b, as shown. a b
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[2]
EITHER
Repeat at different places and calculate a mean Do not accept orientation
To reduce (the effect of) random error
MP2 dependent on MP1
Allow 1 mark for “Repeat and calculate a mean to reduce (the effect of)
random error”
OR
Check and correct for zero error
To eliminate systematic error
MP2 dependent on MP1
Allow 1 mark for “Check for zero error to eliminate systematic error”
(As D increases) value of (20)T will increase
4(b)(i)[3]
Uncertainty in (20)T remains constant
so the percentage uncertainty (in 20T) decreases
MP3 dependent on MP1 or MP2
4(b)(ii)[2]
16π2𝑀𝐷3
Substitution into 𝐸=
𝑎𝑏3𝑇2
E = 14.3 × 109 (Pa)
Accept 1.43 × 1010(Pa)
Example of calculation
16π2𝑀𝐷3
16π2× 0.4 kg × (0.8 m)3
𝑎𝑏3𝑇2 =
25.02 × 10−3 m × (6.17 × 10−3 m)3 × (0.62 s)2 = 1.43 × 1010 Pa
E =
4(b)(iii)[3]
EITHER
Uses percentage uncertainty in one of D a, b or T
Accept fractional
uncertainty
Uses 3 × %U in D or 3 × %U in b or 2 × %U in T
∆𝐷
∆𝑏
∆𝑇
Accept 3 ×
𝐷 or 3 ×
𝑏 or 2 ×
𝑇
Correct %U given to minimum 2 s.f.
Allow inclusion of U in m if 1g or 0.5g for uncertainty is used.
Example of calculation
%U in D =
0.001 m
0.800 m × 100 =
%U in a =
25.02 mm × 100 = 0.200%
0.05 mm
0.02 mm
%U in b =
6.17 mm × 100 = 0.324%
0.01 s
%U in T =
0.62 s × 100 = 1.61%
U in E = 3 × %U in D + %U in a + 3 × %U in b + 2× %U in T
= 3 × 0.125% + 0.200% + 3 × 0.324% + 2 × %
= 0.375% + 0.200% + 0.972% + 3.22% = 4.77%
OR
Use of uncertainties to calculate maximum or minimum E
Calculation of half range shown
Correct %U given to minimum 2 s.f.
e.c.f. (b)(ii)
Example of calculation
16π2𝑀𝐷3
16π2× 0.4 kg × (0.801 m)3
Max E =
𝑎𝑏3𝑇2 =
24.97 × 10−3 m × (6.15 × 10−3 m)3 × (0.61 s)2 = 1.502 × 1010
Pa
16π2𝑀𝐷3
16π2× 0.4 kg × (0.799 m)3
𝑎𝑏3𝑇2 =
25.07 × 10−3 m × (6.19 × 10−3 m)3 × (0.63 s)2 = 1.365 × 1010
Min E =
Pa
U in E =
1.502 − 1.365
× 1010 Pa = 0.0685 × 1010 Pa
2
0.0685 × 1010 Pa
%U in E =
1.43 × 1010 Pa × 100 = 4.79%
4(b)(iv)[2]
EITHER
Correct value of relevant limit shown
e.c.f. (b)(ii), (b)(iii)
Conclusion based on comparison of relevant limit and accepted value.
MP2 dependent MP1
Example of calculation
Lower limit of E = 14.3 × (1 − 0.048) = 13.6 (GPa)
The Young modulus of beech wood is less than the lower limit of E so the
metre rule is not made of beech wood
Show that values give lower limit 13.3 (GPa)
OR
Calculation of %D shown
e.c.f. (b)(ii), (b)(iii)
Conclusion based on comparison of %D and %U
MP2 dependent MP1
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

