Physics · May / June 2022 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 A student measured a metal nut of the type shown below.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)(i)[4]
Digital calipers have a smaller resolution
[Accept converse]
Calculation of percentage uncertainty using (half) resolution shown
%U for Vernier = 0.8% and %U digital = 0.08%
Hence the percentage uncertainty for digital calipers will be smaller
Example of calculation
%U in Vernier reading = 0.05 / 6.6 × 100 = 0.8 %
%U in digital reading = 0.005 / 6.58 × 100 = 0.08 %
4(a)(ii)[2]
Any PAIR from:
Repeat at different orientations and calculate a mean
Hence reduces (the effect of) random errors
Or
Check and correct for zero error
[Accept suitable method]
Hence eliminates systematic error
4(a)(iii)[3]
Mean d = 6.55 (mm)
Calculation using half range shown
[Accept furthest from mean]
Uncertainty in d = 0.03 (mm)
Example of calculation
Mean d = (6.57 + 6.58 + 6.54 + 6.52) / 4 = 26.21 / 4 = 6.55 (mm)
Uncertainty = (6.58 − 6.52) / 2 = 0.06 / 2 = 0.03 (mm)
Calculation of U in s 2 or d 2 using 2 × %U shown
Addition of U in s 2 and U in d 2 shown
U = 0.011 (cm2)
Example of calculation
%U in s 2= 2 × (0.02 / 16.83) × 100 = 2 × 0.12% = 0.24 %
U in s 2 = 1.6832 × 0.24 % = 6.80 × 10−3 cm2
%U in d 2= 2 × (0.04 / 8.55) × 100 = 2 × 0.47% = 0.94 %
U in d 2 = 0.8552 × 0.94 % = 6.87 × 10−3 cm2
U in A = (6.80 × 10−3 × √3) / 2 + (6.87 × 10−3 × π) / 4
= 5.89 × 10−3 + 5.40 × 10−3 = 0.011 cm2
Or
Use of correct absolute uncertainties for s and d
Use of maximum and minimum values to calculate limit of A shown
Correct value of maximum or minimum A
Subtraction to obtain uncertainty in A approximately 0.01 cm2
MP4 dependent on MP3
Example of calculation
minimum s 2 = (1.683 − 0.002)2 = 1.681 cm2
maximum d 2= (0.855 + 0.004)2 = 0.738 cm2
minimum A = √3 × 1.681/2 − π × 0.738/4 = 1.867 cm2
uncertainty in A = 1.88 − 1.867 = 0.013 cm2
4(b)[4]
Digital calipers have a smaller resolution
[Accept converse]
Calculation of percentage uncertainty using (half) resolution shown
%U for Vernier = 0.8% and %U digital = 0.08%
Hence the percentage uncertainty for digital calipers will be smaller
Example of calculation
%U in Vernier reading = 0.05 / 6.6 × 100 = 0.8 %
%U in digital reading = 0.005 / 6.58 × 100 = 0.08 %
Any PAIR from:
Repeat at different orientations and calculate a mean
Hence reduces (the effect of) random errors
Or
Check and correct for zero error
[Accept suitable method]
Hence eliminates systematic error
Mean d = 6.55 (mm)
Calculation using half range shown
[Accept furthest from mean]
Uncertainty in d = 0.03 (mm)
Example of calculation
Mean d = (6.57 + 6.58 + 6.54 + 6.52) / 4 = 26.21 / 4 = 6.55 (mm)
Uncertainty = (6.58 − 6.52) / 2 = 0.06 / 2 = 0.03 (mm)
Calculation of U in s 2 or d 2 using 2 × %U shown
Addition of U in s 2 and U in d 2 shown
U = 0.011 (cm2)
Example of calculation
%U in s 2= 2 × (0.02 / 16.83) × 100 = 2 × 0.12% = 0.24 %
U in s 2 = 1.6832 × 0.24 % = 6.80 × 10−3 cm2
%U in d 2= 2 × (0.04 / 8.55) × 100 = 2 × 0.47% = 0.94 %
U in d 2 = 0.8552 × 0.94 % = 6.87 × 10−3 cm2
U in A = (6.80 × 10−3 × √3) / 2 + (6.87 × 10−3 × π) / 4
= 5.89 × 10−3 + 5.40 × 10−3 = 0.011 cm2
Or
Use of correct absolute uncertainties for s and d
Use of maximum and minimum values to calculate limit of A shown
Correct value of maximum or minimum A
Subtraction to obtain uncertainty in A approximately 0.01 cm2
MP4 dependent on MP3
Example of calculation
minimum s 2 = (1.683 − 0.002)2 = 1.681 cm2
maximum d 2= (0.855 + 0.004)2 = 0.738 cm2
minimum A = √3 × 1.681/2 − π × 0.738/4 = 1.867 cm2
uncertainty in A = 1.88 − 1.867 = 0.013 cm2
Use of ρ = m / Ax
ρ = 6.91 g cm−3
[3 s.f. only]
[Accept 6.92 g cm−3]
Example of calculation
ρ = 10.3 / (1.88 × 0.792) = 10.3 / 1.49 = 6.91 g cm−3
Correct calculation of relevant limit using %U shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of limit and calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
Upper limit of ρ = 6.91 × (1 + 0.0188) = 7.04 g cm−3
As the upper limit is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is not
made from steel.
Or
Use of maximum or minimum values shown
Maximum ρ = 7.05 g cm−3
Or
Minimum ρ = 6.79 g cm3
Conclusion based on comparison of maximum or minimum ρ with
calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
Maximum ρ = (10.3 + 0.1) / ((0.792 − 0.003) × (1.88 − 0.01) = 7.05 g cm−3
As the maximum value is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is
not made from steel.
Or
Calculation of %U in ρ shown
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of %D and %U
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
%D = (7.85 − 6.91) / 7.85 × 100 = 12 %
As % D for lower value is greater than the %U then the hexagonal metal
nut is not made from steel.
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
4(c)(i)[2]
Use of ρ = m / Ax
ρ = 6.91 g cm−3
[3 s.f. only]
[Accept 6.92 g cm−3]
Example of calculation
ρ = 10.3 / (1.88 × 0.792) = 10.3 / 1.49 = 6.91 g cm−3
Correct calculation of relevant limit using %U shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of limit and calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
Upper limit of ρ = 6.91 × (1 + 0.0188) = 7.04 g cm−3
As the upper limit is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is not
made from steel.
Or
Use of maximum or minimum values shown
Maximum ρ = 7.05 g cm−3
Or
Minimum ρ = 6.79 g cm3
Conclusion based on comparison of maximum or minimum ρ with
calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
Maximum ρ = (10.3 + 0.1) / ((0.792 − 0.003) × (1.88 − 0.01) = 7.05 g cm−3
As the maximum value is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is
not made from steel.
Or
Calculation of %U in ρ shown
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of %D and %U
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
%D = (7.85 − 6.91) / 7.85 × 100 = 12 %
As % D for lower value is greater than the %U then the hexagonal metal
nut is not made from steel.
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
4(c)(ii)[3]
Digital calipers have a smaller resolution
[Accept converse]
Calculation of percentage uncertainty using (half) resolution shown
%U for Vernier = 0.8% and %U digital = 0.08%
Hence the percentage uncertainty for digital calipers will be smaller
Example of calculation
%U in Vernier reading = 0.05 / 6.6 × 100 = 0.8 %
%U in digital reading = 0.005 / 6.58 × 100 = 0.08 %
Any PAIR from:
Repeat at different orientations and calculate a mean
Hence reduces (the effect of) random errors
Or
Check and correct for zero error
[Accept suitable method]
Hence eliminates systematic error
Mean d = 6.55 (mm)
Calculation using half range shown
[Accept furthest from mean]
Uncertainty in d = 0.03 (mm)
Example of calculation
Mean d = (6.57 + 6.58 + 6.54 + 6.52) / 4 = 26.21 / 4 = 6.55 (mm)
Uncertainty = (6.58 − 6.52) / 2 = 0.06 / 2 = 0.03 (mm)
Calculation of U in s 2 or d 2 using 2 × %U shown
Addition of U in s 2 and U in d 2 shown
U = 0.011 (cm2)
Example of calculation
%U in s 2= 2 × (0.02 / 16.83) × 100 = 2 × 0.12% = 0.24 %
U in s 2 = 1.6832 × 0.24 % = 6.80 × 10−3 cm2
%U in d 2= 2 × (0.04 / 8.55) × 100 = 2 × 0.47% = 0.94 %
U in d 2 = 0.8552 × 0.94 % = 6.87 × 10−3 cm2
U in A = (6.80 × 10−3 × √3) / 2 + (6.87 × 10−3 × π) / 4
= 5.89 × 10−3 + 5.40 × 10−3 = 0.011 cm2
Or
Use of correct absolute uncertainties for s and d
Use of maximum and minimum values to calculate limit of A shown
Correct value of maximum or minimum A
Subtraction to obtain uncertainty in A approximately 0.01 cm2
MP4 dependent on MP3
Example of calculation
minimum s 2 = (1.683 − 0.002)2 = 1.681 cm2
maximum d 2= (0.855 + 0.004)2 = 0.738 cm2
minimum A = √3 × 1.681/2 − π × 0.738/4 = 1.867 cm2
uncertainty in A = 1.88 − 1.867 = 0.013 cm2
Use of ρ = m / Ax
ρ = 6.91 g cm−3
[3 s.f. only]
[Accept 6.92 g cm−3]
Example of calculation
ρ = 10.3 / (1.88 × 0.792) = 10.3 / 1.49 = 6.91 g cm−3
Correct calculation of relevant limit using %U shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of limit and calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
Upper limit of ρ = 6.91 × (1 + 0.0188) = 7.04 g cm−3
As the upper limit is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is not
made from steel.
Or
Use of maximum or minimum values shown
Maximum ρ = 7.05 g cm−3
Or
Minimum ρ = 6.79 g cm3
Conclusion based on comparison of maximum or minimum ρ with
calculated ρ
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
Maximum ρ = (10.3 + 0.1) / ((0.792 − 0.003) × (1.88 − 0.01) = 7.05 g cm−3
As the maximum value is lower than 7.85 g cm−3 the hexagonal metal nut is
not made from steel.
Or
Calculation of %U in ρ shown
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown
[e.c.f. (c)(i)]
Conclusion based on comparison of %D and %U
[MP3 dependent MP2]
Example of calculation
%U in ρ = (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (0.01 / 1.88) × 100 + (0.03 / 7.92) × 100
= 0.97 % + 0.53 % + 0.38 % = 1.88 %
%D = (7.85 − 6.91) / 7.85 × 100 = 12 %
As % D for lower value is greater than the %U then the hexagonal metal
nut is not made from steel.
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

