Physics · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 An L-shaped steel rod was held horizontally in a stand clamped by its shorter end as shown. metre rule steel rod Diagram not to scale stand p q bench The end of the steel rod was at a height p above the bench. A student attached a mass m to the end of the steel rod causing it to bend towards the bench. The end of the steel rod was then at a height q above the bench.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)(i)[2]
Any TWO from:
Ensure the metre rule is vertical using a set square
Accept alternative
valid methods
Ensure the end of the rod is close to the metre rule
Or use a set square to read off the values
Take readings perpendicular to the scale (to avoid parallax)
4(a)(ii)[2]
The uncertainty of a single reading is half the resolution of the metre rule,
(which is 0.5 mm)
As the two readings are subtracted, the uncertainties are added
4(b)(i)[2]
Micrometer screw gauge (with a resolution of 0.01mm) (Accept digital
caliper)
As this would produce an uncertainty of 0.25% which is small
4(b)(ii)[2]
One PAIR from:
Repeat at different orientations and calculate a mean
To reduce the effect of random errors
Check (and correct) for zero error
To eliminate systematic error
4(b)(iii)[2]
Mean value of d = 2.35 (mm)
Calculation from half range shown to give uncertainty of 0.02 (mm)
Example of calculation
Mean d = (2.35 + 2.37 + 2.34 + 2.34 + 2.33) mm / 5 = 11.74 mm / 5
= 2.348 mm = 2.35 mm
Uncertainty = (2.37 − 2.33) mm /2 = 0.04 mm/2 = 0.02 mm
4(c)[2]
Use of G = (32mglx2) / (π yd 4) shown
Correct value of G given to 2 or 3 s.f.
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Bald answer scores 0
Accept value of 1.5 × 1011 (N m−2) if d = 2 mm used
Example of calculation
G
= 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81 N kg−1 × 0.589 m × (0.103 m)2
3.14159 × 0.026 m × (2.35 × 10−3 m)4
= 0.196 N m3 / 2.49 × 10−12 m5
= 7.87 × 1010 (N m−2)
= 7.9 × 1010 (N m−2)
Calculation of correct value of %U in G
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Correct value of relevant limits from %U
e.c.f. (c)
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant limits with data
Example of calculation
%U
= (0.1 / 58.9) × 100 + 2 × (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (1 / 26) × 100
+ 4 × (0.02 / 2.35) × 100
= 0.17% + 2 × 0.97% + 3.85% + 4 × 0.85%
= 0.17% + 1.94% + 3.85% + 3.40%
= 9.36% = 9.4%
Upper limit = 78.7 × 109 N m2 × (1+0.094) = 86.1 × 109 N m2
Lower limit = 78.7 × 109 N m2 × (1 − 0.094) = 71.3 × 109 N m2
As both values fall within this range, the student cannot determine which type of
steel the rod is made from.
Or
Use of uncertainties to calculate maximum or minimum shown
Calculation of correct value of upper limit
Calculation of correct value of lower limit
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant limit with data
Example of calculation
Upper limit G = 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81Nkg−1 × (0.589+0.001)m × ((0.103+0.001)m)2
3.14159 × (0.026−0.01) m × ((2.35−0.02) × 10−3 m)4
= 0.200 N m3 / 2.31 × 10−12 m5
= 8.68 × 1010 (N m−2)
Lower limit G = 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81Nkg−1 × (0.589−0.001)m × ((0.103−0.001)m)2
3.14159 × (0.026+0.01) m × ((2.35+0.02) × 10−3 m)4
= 0.192 N m3 / 2.68 × 10−12 m5
= 7.16 × 1010 (N m−2)
As both values fall within this range, the student cannot determine which type of
steel the rod is made from.
Or
Use of 2× %U in x Or 4× %U in d shown
Calculation of correct value of %U in G
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown
e.c.f. (c)
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant %D with %U
Example of calculation
%U
= (0.1 / 58.9) × 100 + 2 × (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (1 / 26) × 100
+ 4 × (0.02 / 2.35) × 100
= 0.17% + 1.94% + 3.85% + 3.40%
= 9.36% = 9.4%
%D for structural steel = (78.7 − 79.3)/79.3 × 100 = 0.76 %
%D for carbon steel = (78.7 − 77)/77 × 100 = 2.3%
As % D for both structural and carbon steel are less than the %U, the student
cannot determine which type of steel the rod is made from.
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
4(d)[4]
Any TWO from:
Ensure the metre rule is vertical using a set square
Accept alternative
valid methods
Ensure the end of the rod is close to the metre rule
Or use a set square to read off the values
Take readings perpendicular to the scale (to avoid parallax)
The uncertainty of a single reading is half the resolution of the metre rule,
(which is 0.5 mm)
As the two readings are subtracted, the uncertainties are added
Micrometer screw gauge (with a resolution of 0.01mm) (Accept digital
caliper)
As this would produce an uncertainty of 0.25% which is small
One PAIR from:
Repeat at different orientations and calculate a mean
To reduce the effect of random errors
Check (and correct) for zero error
To eliminate systematic error
Mean value of d = 2.35 (mm)
Calculation from half range shown to give uncertainty of 0.02 (mm)
Example of calculation
Mean d = (2.35 + 2.37 + 2.34 + 2.34 + 2.33) mm / 5 = 11.74 mm / 5
= 2.348 mm = 2.35 mm
Uncertainty = (2.37 − 2.33) mm /2 = 0.04 mm/2 = 0.02 mm
Use of G = (32mglx2) / (π yd 4) shown
Correct value of G given to 2 or 3 s.f.
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Bald answer scores 0
Accept value of 1.5 × 1011 (N m−2) if d = 2 mm used
Example of calculation
G
= 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81 N kg−1 × 0.589 m × (0.103 m)2
3.14159 × 0.026 m × (2.35 × 10−3 m)4
= 0.196 N m3 / 2.49 × 10−12 m5
= 7.87 × 1010 (N m−2)
= 7.9 × 1010 (N m−2)
Calculation of correct value of %U in G
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Correct value of relevant limits from %U
e.c.f. (c)
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant limits with data
Example of calculation
%U
= (0.1 / 58.9) × 100 + 2 × (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (1 / 26) × 100
+ 4 × (0.02 / 2.35) × 100
= 0.17% + 2 × 0.97% + 3.85% + 4 × 0.85%
= 0.17% + 1.94% + 3.85% + 3.40%
= 9.36% = 9.4%
Upper limit = 78.7 × 109 N m2 × (1+0.094) = 86.1 × 109 N m2
Lower limit = 78.7 × 109 N m2 × (1 − 0.094) = 71.3 × 109 N m2
As both values fall within this range, the student cannot determine which type of
steel the rod is made from.
Or
Use of uncertainties to calculate maximum or minimum shown
Calculation of correct value of upper limit
Calculation of correct value of lower limit
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant limit with data
Example of calculation
Upper limit G = 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81Nkg−1 × (0.589+0.001)m × ((0.103+0.001)m)2
3.14159 × (0.026−0.01) m × ((2.35−0.02) × 10−3 m)4
= 0.200 N m3 / 2.31 × 10−12 m5
= 8.68 × 1010 (N m−2)
Lower limit G = 32 × 0.1kg × 9.81Nkg−1 × (0.589−0.001)m × ((0.103−0.001)m)2
3.14159 × (0.026+0.01) m × ((2.35+0.02) × 10−3 m)4
= 0.192 N m3 / 2.68 × 10−12 m5
= 7.16 × 1010 (N m−2)
As both values fall within this range, the student cannot determine which type of
steel the rod is made from.
Or
Use of 2× %U in x Or 4× %U in d shown
Calculation of correct value of %U in G
e.c.f. (b)(iii)
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown
e.c.f. (c)
Valid conclusion based on comparison of relevant %D with %U
Example of calculation
%U
= (0.1 / 58.9) × 100 + 2 × (0.1 / 10.3) × 100 + (1 / 26) × 100
+ 4 × (0.02 / 2.35) × 100
= 0.17% + 1.94% + 3.85% + 3.40%
= 9.36% = 9.4%
%D for structural steel = (78.7 − 79.3)/79.3 × 100 = 0.76 %
%D for carbon steel = (78.7 − 77)/77 × 100 = 2.3%
As % D for both structural and carbon steel are less than the %U, the student
cannot determine which type of steel the rod is made from.
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

