Physics · May / June 2021 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YPH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 A student measured some dimensions of a thick, circular lens. The diagram shows approximate values of these dimensions. x Diagram not to scale x ≈ 2 mm t t ≈ 1 cm d d ≈ 5 cm side view plan view
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)(i)[1]
[Accept clear reference to range of micrometer as 25 mm]
There may be a systematic error
4(a)(ii)[2]
Or
there may be zero error (on the Vernier calipers)
(Therefore) the values may not be close to the true value
Or
(therefore) there may be a constant value added to the
measurements
4(b)[2]
Mean x = 2.12 (mm)
Uncertainty of 0.02 (mm) from calculation of half range
[Accept furthest from the mean]
Example of calculation
mean x = (2.11+2.10+2.13+2.14+2.11) mm/5 = 2.118 = 2.12
mm
Uncertainty = (2.14−2.10) mm/2 = 0.02 mm
4(c)(i)[2]
𝑑2+(𝑡−𝑥)2
Use of n = 1 +
8𝑓(𝑡−𝑥)
Correct value of n to 2 or 3 s.f.
[e.c.f (b)]
Example of calculation
𝑑2+(𝑡−𝑥)2
5.102+(0.830−0.212)2
26.01+0.6182
n = 1 +
8𝑓(𝑡−𝑥) = 1 +
8×9.8×(0.830−0.212) = 1 +
48.45
= 1.54
4(c)(ii)[2]
Addition of U in t and U in x shown
Conversion to %U to minimum 2 s.f.
[e.c.f (b)]
Example of calculation
U = 0.01 + 0.02 = 0.03
%U = 0.03 / (8.30 − 2.12) × 100% = 0.49 %
4(c)(iii)[4]
Use of 2× %U in d or 2× %U (t−x) shown
[e.c.f (b)]
Calculation of U in d 2 or U in (t−x)2 shown
Addition of U in d 2 and U in (t−x)2 shown
[do not penalise
Correct value of U to minimum 3 s.f.
if square root of final value is taken]
Example of calculation
%U in d 2 = 2 × (0.01/5.1 × 100) = 0.392%
U in d 2 = 5.12 × 0.392/100 = 0.102
%U in (t − x)2 = 2 × 0.49 = 0.98%
U in (t − x)2 = 0.6182 × 0.98/100 = 0.004
U = 0.102 + 0.004 = 0.106
Correct calculation of %U in n shown
[e.c.f. (c)(ii) and
4(c)(iv)[3]
(iii)]
Calculation of relevant limit shown
[e.c.f (c)(i)]
Valid conclusion based on comparison of calculated values
[MP3 dependent on MP2]
Example of calculation
%U = (0.106/26.4 × 100) + 0.485 + (0.3/9.8 × 100) = 0.402 +
0.485 + 3.06
= 3.95%
Upper limit = 1.54 × 1.04 = 1.60
Lower limit = 1.54 × 0.96 = 1.48
The lens is most likely to be made of crown glass as it is the
only value to fall within the range
Or
Correct calculation of %U in n shown
[e.c.f. (c)(ii) and
(iii)]
Correct calculation of relevant %D shown [e.c.f (c)(i)]
Valid conclusion based on comparison of calculated values
[MP3 dependent on MP2]
Example of calculation
%U = (0.106/26.4 × 100) + 0.485 + (0.3/9.8 × 100) = 0.402 +
0.485 + 3.06
= 3.95%
Crown glass %D = (1.54−1.52)/1.52 × 100 = 1.32 %
Flint glass %D = (1.66−1.54)/1.66 × 100 = 7.23 %
The lens is most likely to be made of crown glass as the %D
is less than the %U whereas %D is larger than %U for flint
glass.
Total mark for Question 4 = 16
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

