Note AcademyNote Academy

Physics · Oct / Nov 2020 · Paper 41 · Question 13

YPH11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

13 In 1964 George Zweig proposed a model for matter. Zweig suggested that mesons and baryons are made from a set of fundamental particles he called aces. In this model each ace carried baryon number 1/3 and was fractionally charged. Baryons were a combination of three aces and mesons were a combination of two aces. Zweig said that the number of aces should match the number of leptons, so there would be four types of ace. Compare this model with the current standard model. (4)

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme

Maximum 4 marks

Similarities – Max 3 marks

Zweig model, baryon 3 aces and standard model baryon

3 quarks, so similar

1

Zweig model, meson 2 aces and standard model meson

1

2 quarks, so similar

Zweig model, number of aces same as lepton and

standard model quarks same as leptons, so similar

1

Zweig model, aces have fractional charge and standard

1

model quarks have fractional charge, so similar

Zweig model, aces are fundamental and standard model

1

quarks are fundamental, so similar

Zweig model, aces have baryon number 1/3 and

standard model quarks have baryon number 1/3, so

1

similar

Differences – Max 3 marks

Zweig model, meson 2 aces but standard model meson

1

quark antiquark, so different

Zweig model, 4 aces in total but standard model 6

1

quarks in total, so different

Zweig model, 4 leptons in total and standard model 6

1

leptons, so different

Zweif model, no antiaces but standard model has anti

1

quarks, so different

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.