Note AcademyNote Academy

Mathematics · May / June 2025 · Paper 41 · Question 2

YMA01

As printed in the paper

The question as text

2. A spherical ball of ice with radius r cm is melting. The volume of the ball of ice, V cm 3, is decreasing at a constant rate, k cm 3 per second, where k is a constant. Given that V = 4 3 πr 3, show that the rate of decrease of the radius of the ball of ice with respect to time is inversely proportional to the square of the radius. (4)

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme

→

2

→

×

B1:

2

y

4 d

y x

o.e. For example, accept

2

y

2

2 d

y x

d

y

M1:

Attempts the product rule on 6xy

−

. Look for

±

α

x

±

β

y

d

x

Don’t be concerned by the signs here unless they state and use an incorrect product rule

d

y

d

y

A1:

Fully correct differentiation

4

y

−

6

x

−

6

y

=

14e

2

x

−

1

o.e. Allow unsimplified versions

d

x

d

x

4 d

y y

−

6 d

x y

−

6

y x

d

=

14e

2

x

−

1

d

x

4

yy

' 6

−

xy

' 6

−

y

=

14e x

2

−

1

You may see versions like

or

d

y

d

y

d

y

this will be A0 unless the d

=

−

−

−

2

x

−

1

=

acceptable. If they write

4

y

6

x

6

y

14e

0

d

x

d

x

d

x

subsequently disappears and is ignored.

1

M1:

Attempts to substitute in

x =

with their positive y value to find a value for the gradient of the tangent. It

2

is dependent upon having exactly two terms in d

y

x one each from the differentiation of

2y and 6xy . This

d

can be implied by a correct value for their d

y

x . Allow slips if they attempt to make d

y

x the subject before

d

d

1

d

y

6

y

+

14e

2

x

−

1

d

y

24

+

14

x =

=

→

=

=

substituting in

with their positive y value. FYI

2

d

x

4

y

−

6

x

d

x

16

−

3

Uses the value for their d

y

x with the point 1 ,

M1:

where a is their positive y coordinate to find the

2 a

d

equation of the tangent. If they have two positive y values, use of either one would be OK for this mark. It

must follow some attempt at differentiating the equation for C. If the form y

=

mx

+

c

is used the method

must proceed as far as c = …

A1:

38

x

−

13

y

+

33

=

0

(or any integer multiple of this). The order of the terms is not important

2

d

V

t = ±

k

d

4

d

V

=

π

→

=

π

V

r

3

4

r

2

3

d

r

d

r

±

k

=

λ

r

2

×

d

t

d

r

±

k

d

r

1

=

∝

✓ *

π

d

t

4

r

2

d

t

r

2

States or uses d

V

or d

V

t =

t = − (We don’t know if k is positive or negative).

B1:

k

k

d

d

Ignore any reference to units even if they are incorrect. E.g. d

V

t =

k

cm / sec

3

d

d

V

=

π

2

B1:

States or uses

4

r

o.e.

d

r

Uses a correct chain rule e.g. d

V

d

V

d

r

or equivalent with d

V

d

V

M1:

=

×

t = ±and

k

r = λ

r

2

d

t

d

r

d

t

d

d

A1*: Completes the proof by looking for the following three elements

d

r

±

k

achieves

= π

d

t

4

r

2

d

r

1

Offers a valid reason why

∝

d

t

r

2

gives a minimal conclusion

All previous marks must have been awarded

Examples of acceptable reasons and acceptable conclusions are;

d

r

k

c

E.g. I

= −

= −

, hence proven (Note that c cannot be k)

d

t

4

π

r

2

r

2

d

r

k

k

d

r

1

=

,as

∝

E.g. II

is a constant

π

2

π

2

d

t

4

r

4

d

t

r

d

r

k

= −π

Eg. III

as k and π are constants, it is true

d

t

4

r

2

d

r

k

k

1

k

1

E.g. IV

= −

= −

×

or

−

×

✓

d

t

4

π

r

2

4

π

r

2

π

2

4

r

Reason

E.g.V.

Conclusion

R

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.