Note AcademyNote Academy

Islamiyat · May / June 2026 · Paper 11 · Question 5

0493

As printed in the paper

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 5(a)[10]

    Give an account of the lives of Abu Talib and Abu Sufyan during the life of the Prophet (pbuh).

    Use the AO1 Levels of Response.

    Candidates should include some of the following points. All other relevant points must be credited. Abu Talib: Abu Talib was the leader of one of the clans of Quraysh and became the guardian of the Prophet (pbuh) after the death of the Prophet’s grandfather. He loved the Prophet (pbuh) like his own son, often preferring Muhammad (pbuh) over his own children. When in financial difficulty, Abu Talib’s son ʿAli went to live with the Prophet (pbuh).

    Abu Talib took the Prophet (pbuh) on trade journeys with him, and on one particular journey the monk, Bahira, told Abu Talib that his nephew would be the final prophet. Abu Talib quickly sold his goods and returned to Makka to protect Muhammad (pbuh), knowing that if he was discovered as the final prophet, he would face danger. The Prophet (pbuh) collected arrows and gave them to his uncle during Harb al Fajar. Abu Talib also approved Khadija’s marriage proposal and is claimed to have delivered the marriage sermon.

    Abu Talib not did become Muslim when the Prophet (pbuh) openly announced Islam, but he did promise to protect the Prophet (pbuh). It was his protection that prevented the Prophet (pbuh) from being persecuted more severely. When there was a boycott on the Prophet (pbuh) and his family, Abu Talib faced the difficulties of the boycott with the Prophet (pbuh) in the Valley of Abi Talib (Shib i Abi Talib). His support for the Prophet (pbuh) was invaluable. Abu Talib died shortly after the boycott, and the Prophet (pbuh) was very saddened by his death.

    Abu Sufyan: he was a prominent and powerful figure among the Quraysh, from the Bani Umayya, and a staunch opponent of the Prophet (pbuh) and the Muslims. It was his caravan returning from Syria that was the basis for the Battle of Badr, where despite reaching Makka safely the Quraysh still decided to fight. After the loss at Badr, revenge was sought and Abu Sufyan led the Quraysh army to Uhud. His wife Hind also went seeking revenge for the death of her father at Badr. At Uhud, when the Prophet (pbuh) retreated to the mountain, Abu Sufyan called out to the Muslims asking if the Prophet (pbuh) was still alive, then saying ‘this is retaliation for Badr.’ He vowed to fight again and the next time they met was at the Battle of the Trench. He testified to the Prophet’s honesty when he met with the Byzantine emperor even though he was not Muslim.

    After the Quraysh broke the Treaty of

    Hudaybiyya, Abu Sufyan went to Madina to attempt to restore the treaty, but without success. He tried to meet with the Prophet (pbuh), but he wasn’t successful, and he was even rebuked by his daughter Ramla/Umm Habiba, who was the wife of the Prophet (pbuh). He subsequently converted to Islam at the time of the Conquest of Makka, and the Prophet (pbuh) honoured him by making his house a safe place, despite his fierce opposition for many years.

    He died aged 90 in Madina.

  • 5(b)[4]

    What lessons can Muslims learn from the lives of Abu Talib and Abu Sufyan about relationships with non-Muslims?

    Use the AO2 Levels of Response.

    Candidates can give other examples, and all relevant answers should be credited.

    The lives of Abu Talib and Abu Sufyan can teach Muslims that a person does not have to be Muslim for them to be able to have a kind and loving relationship with them, especially if they are family members such as the Prophet’s relationship with Abu Talib.

    It can help Muslims understand that even when non-Muslims are not kind to you, you can have patience with them as the Prophet (pbuh) was patient with Abu Sufyan even though he showed animosity towards the Muslims. It also shows that anyone can become Muslim in the future so you should not give up hope of them changing their ways even if they are against you.

    Another lesson could be that, like Umm Habiba, Muslims should put their faith in God before their relationships.

    Also, it is important to honour family members whether they are Muslim or non-Muslim, when they are not oppressing or opposing you. The Prophet’s relationship with Abu Talib was so deep that the year of his passing, was called the year of grief, as the Prophet (pbuh) was deeply saddened by Abu Talib’s (and Khadija’s) loss.

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.