Note AcademyNote Academy

Global Perspectives · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 12 · Question 3

0457

As printed in the paper

The question as text

Study Source 4.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 3(a)[2]

    Main Annotations

    Candidates may identify one of the following from Source 4

    Your working environment sounds very strict.
    The managers think that by giving us responsibility in decision- making/encouraging us to work in teams is motivating…
    I work hard because I want to do a good job.
    I agree that working in teams makes work more interesting.
    My manager does not care what time I start and finish.
    This increases our productivity.
    My manager wants me to do a good job.

    Award 1 mark for correctly identifying an opinion from the list above. Award an additional 1 mark for a response that demonstrates a clear understanding of an opinion.

    Further guidance – note that the only acceptable answers are listed above. However, candidates may use their own words.

  • 3(b)(i)[1]

    Main Annotations

    A fact is a statement which is true or accurate and can be verified.

    The following examples of facts may be found in Ruben’s statement:

    If the company is not efficient, it will go out of business/we will all lose our jobs.
    Where I work there are lots of rules.
    Lots of rules keep us safe.
    We all know what to do.
    We have targets to meet.
    These are checked regularly.
    The managers supervise us a lot.
    I have heard about other companies.
    I work harder for the company.
    If I do not achieve my targets my managers are unhappy.
    I want to do a good job.
    There is lots of research showing that workers are more productive if …
    A research study from the United States found that people work harder if …
    Siya thinks that working in teams makes work more interesting. Award 1 mark for correctly identifying a fact from the list above.

    Further guidance – note that the only acceptable answers are listed above. However, candidates may use their own words.

  • 3(b)(ii)[2]

    Main Annotations

    Indicative content

    Examples of the points that could be made when explaining how well the fact supports the argument:

    Very good support as this fact is relevant to the argument and gives evidence of the benefits of supervising workers.
    Some support as the fact is relevant to the argument but it is only evidence from one place of work and may not apply in others.
    Limited support as the fact shows that Ruben’s managers think supervision is important but does not prove that it is necessary to make them work hard.

    Level 2 (2 marks) Good response

    Clear statement of how well the fact supports the argument AND a credible link between the fact and the argument is made.

    Level 1 (1 marks) Reasonable response

    Statement of how well the fact supports the argument OR a credible link between the fact and the argument is made.

    The response may lack clarity.

    Level 0 (0 marks)

    No creditworthy material.

  • 3(c)[15]

    Main Annotations

    Indicative content

    Candidates are expected to evaluate the arguments presented in Source 4 and compare their effectiveness. They should make a supported judgement with some explanation about which person has the most convincing argument.

    Candidates may support their judgement by considering:

    Strength of reasoning:

    logic
    structure
    balance
    claims

    Use of language:

    tone – emotive, exaggerated, precise
    clarity

    Evidence:

    range of information and depth
    relevance
    sufficiency – sample
    source – media; internet
    date – how recent
    different types of information – fact, opinion, value, anecdote
    testimony – from experience and expert

    Sources of bias

    local interest
    economic
    personal values
    experience

    Likely consequences of the ideas presented

    Acceptability of their values to others

    how likely other people are to agree with their perspective/view The following levels of response should be used to award marks:

    Level 5 (13–15 marks) Very good response

    Clear, credible and well supported points about which argument is more convincing. Coherent, structured evaluation of both arguments with clear comparison.

    The response usually contains three (or more) developed evaluative points, and may include some undeveloped points.

    Material from the sources is used as evidence to support the evaluation; clear reference to the evidence and/or arguments in the source e.g.

    quotation/summary of ideas.

    A clear judgement is reached.

    Level 4 (10–12 marks) Good response

    Clear, supported points about which argument is more convincing. Evaluation of both arguments, with comparison.

    The response usually contains two (or more) developed evaluative points and may include some undeveloped points. A wide range (four or more) of undeveloped but clearly appropriate points may be sufficient to enter this band at the lower level.

    Material from the sources is used as evidence to support the evaluation; some reference to the evidence and/or arguments in the source e.g.

    quotation/summary of ideas.

    A judgment is reached.

    Level 3 (7–9 marks) Reasonable response

    Reasonable points about which argument is more convincing. Some evaluation of both arguments, with an attempt at comparison or a very good evaluation of only one argument. Judgements and evaluative points are partially supported or asserted.

    The response usually contains one (or more) developed evaluative points, possibly with some undeveloped points; three (or more) undeveloped points may be sufficient to enter this band at the lower level.

    Some material from the sources may be used as evidence to support the evaluation. The response may occasionally lack some clarity and by difficult to follow.

    An attempt is made to give an overall judgement.

    Level 2 (4–6) Basic response

    Basic points about which argument is more convincing. There may be only one argument considered in any detail, with little attempt at comparison. Judgements and evaluative points are partially supported and lack clarity/relevance at times.

    The response usually contains two (or more) undeveloped points.

    A basic judgement may be reached.

    Level 1 (1–3 marks) Limited response

    Limited and unsupported points about which argument is more convincing. The response considers the arguments briefly and/or tangentially. There is little clarity. Answers at this level may repeat source material with little understanding or simply agree/disagree with the arguments presented. The response may not contain any clear evaluative points.

    Level 0 (0 marks)

    No relevant response or creditworthy material.

    Further Guidance

    Responses that give a very good evaluation of only one argument may achieve Level 3 but no higher.

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.