Note AcademyNote Academy

Economics · Oct / Nov 2024 · Paper 21 · Question 4

0455

As printed in the paper

The question as text

The World Trade Organization (WTO) estimates that India has the largest levels of trade protection of any major economy. The highest tariffs are imposed on products from the primary sector. For example, in 2018 India imposed a tariff of approximately 90% on imports of coffee to protect its coffee farmers. However, the markets for coffee substitutes and complements do not have such levels of government intervention.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 4(a)[2]

    Identify two methods of trade protection apart from a tariff. Two from non-tariff barriers:

    import quotas
    subsidies
    embargoes / bans
    licences
    product standards / regulations 2 Accept any relevant methods.
  • 4(b)[4]

    Explain how the price of coffee substitutes and complements can affect the demand for coffee. Logical explanation which might include: Relationship between price and demand of substitutes is positive (1)

    when price of coffee substitutes increases, demand for coffee increases, or vice versa (1)

    because as price of coffee substitutes increases, coffee is relatively cheaper (1)

    demand for the substitute will decrease, and the demand for coffee will increase (1)

    e.g. coffee and tea (1). Relationship between price and demand of complements is negative (1)

    when price of coffee complements increases, demand for coffee falls or vice versa (1)

    because as price for coffee complements increases, the demand for the complement will fall, and therefore the demand for coffee will decrease (1)

    e.g. coffee and sugar (1). 4 Maximum of 3 marks if only substitutes or complements are explained. Mark

  • 4(c)[6]

    Analyse the possible reasons why a government may want to intervene in a market. Coherent analysis which might include: Government may want to intervene in a market due to market failure / when the market mechanism leads to inefficient allocation of resources (1)

    Reasons for intervention:

    to provide public goods (1)

    not provided by the market (1)

    due to non-rivalry / non-excludability (1)

    creating the free rider problem / no profit-incentive for private producers (1)

    to provide merit goods (1)

    under-consumed and under- produced by the market (1)

    external benefits which are ignored by the market (1)

    e.g. vaccinations (1)

    to reduce provision of demerit goods (1)

    over-consumed and over-produced by the market (1)

    external costs are ignored by the market (1)

    e.g. pollution (1)

    to reduce monopoly power (1)

    that creates high prices (1)

    while reducing consumer choices (1)

    and reducing quality (1)

    to reduce factor immobility (1)

    factors of production unable to move around to its best possible use (1)

    e.g. labour immobility where workers cannot move around (1)

    and therefore are unemployed (1)

    to protect consumers of essential items (1)

    by setting a maximum price (1)

    keeping the price below the market price (1)

    to protect low paid workers (1)

    by setting a minimum wage (1)

    keeping the wage above the market wage (1)

    to give subsidies / impose tariffs (1)

    e.g. protect infant industries (1)

    so that they can grow in the long- term / protect employment (1). 6 Maximum of three marks for identification of reasons Mark

  • 4(d)[8]

    Discuss whether or not high tariffs can reduce unemployment. In assessing each answer, use the table opposite. Why it might:

    high tariffs lead to increase price of imports reducing the demand for imports
    high tariffs make consumers choose domestic products instead which increases demand for domestic workers
    high tariffs provide government with extra revenue which could be used to subsidise domestic firms / domestic employment
    high tariffs can be a major source of tax revenue. Some of this could be spent on e.g. education and training which will increase workers’ skills and mobility, and so reduce unemployment. Why it might not:
    high tariffs lead to retaliation which leads to decrease in demand for exports and therefore decrease demand for domestic workers
    high tariffs still not enough to offset lower cost of imports
    domestic production may not be able to increase due to full employment / lack of natural resources
    higher prices of imported raw materials could increase costs of production, so reducing profits and lowering output
    domestic prices may rise as domestic firms become complacent as they are protected. Level Description A reasoned discussion which accurately examines both sides of the economic argument, making use of economic information and clear and logical analysis to evaluate economic issues and situations. One side of the argument may have more depth than the other, but overall both sides of the argument are considered and developed. There is thoughtful evaluation of economic concepts, terminology, information and / or data appropriate to the question. The discussion may also point out the possible uncertainties of alternative decisions and outcomes. 6–8 Mark Guidance A reasoned discussion which makes use of economic information and clear analysis to evaluate economic issues and situations. The answer may lack some depth and development may be one-sided. There is relevant use of economic concepts, terminology, information and data appropriate to the question. 3–5 There is a simple attempt at using economic definitions and terminology. Some reference may be made to economic theory, with occasional understanding. 1–2 A mark of zero should be awarded for no creditable content. Mark

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.