Economics · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 22 · Question 1
0455
As printed in the paper
Show the answer and mark scheme
1(a)[1]
Calculate, in $, Air India’s loss in 2018. 0.7bn, 700m, 700 000 000. 1 7 × 10 to the power 8. 7 × 10ˆ8.
1(b)[2]
Identify two substitutes for air travel. Trains (1)
ships (1). 2 For ‘ships’ accept water travel.
1(c)[2]
Explain one characteristic that suggests that Air India was a monopoly in 1994. Share of the market was 100% (1)
only firm / share above 25% of the market / share above 40% / a complete/pure monopoly / no competition (1). Able to set price (1)
a price-maker (1).
1(d)[4]
Explain two reasons why a government may privatise an industry. Logical explanation which might include: Raise (tax) revenue (1)
which could be spent on e.g. education, healthcare / increase government spending (1). Increase efficiency / may perform better in the private sector / higher productivity (1)
introduce a profit motive / increase output/GDP / reduce costs of production (1). Increase competition (1)
lower price / increase quality / increase choice (1). Industry may be loss making / costly to run (1)
reduce need to use tax revenue to finance industry / tax revenue can be used for other purposes e.g. education / increase government spending / reduce national debt / tax rates might be cut (1). 4 One mark each for each of two reasons identified and one mark each for each of two explanations.
1(e)[4]
Analyse how India’s position on the current account of its balance of payments in 2017 compares with the other four countries. Coherent analysis which might include: Brazil, India and Kenya had a current account deficit (1)
while China and Russia had a current account surplus (1). India’s current account deficit is the largest in terms of $s (1)
but the second largest in % terms (1). China’s current account had a larger impact on its economy in terms of $s (1)
and Kenya’s in percentage terms (1). Russia’s current account surplus is larger than China’s in terms of % of GDP (1). China has the largest surplus in $s (1). 4 Up to 2 marks maximum for idea of size of current account balance without reference to deficit or surplus e.g. China has the largest current account balance and India the lowest. So maximum of 2 marks without reference to deficit/s or surplus/es. No marks for writing about a budget balance.
1(f)[5]
Analyse how a successful airline industry can promote economic growth. Coherent analysis which might include;
May increase number of tourists (1)
raise revenue from tourism / increase the size of the tourist industry (1)
may increase exports / imports / increase the ease of movement of people and goods into and out of the country (1). May attract more MNCs (1)
these will increase the country’s output/GDP (1)
introduce new technology / new methods of production (1). May lower costs of production (1)
raising firms’ profits (1)
providing the incentive/finance to expand (1)
increase the country’s output/GDP (1). May increase employment (1)
raise incomes (1)
increase total demand (1)
increase tax revenue (1)
more could be spent on e.g. education (1). May increase (geographical) mobility of labour (1)
making it easier for expanding firms to recruit workers (1).
1(g)[6]
Discuss whether the Indian government should increase the tax on airline fuel. Award up to 4 marks for why it should:
Raise revenue (1)can be used to finance e.g. education / training of pilots / increase government spending (1)
burden more likely to fall on the rich / may enable tax on basic necessities to be reduced (1).
May reduce market failure (1)air travel causes external costs / social cost exceeds social benefit (1)
air/noise pollution (1)
a tax may reduce air travel / lower demand for air travel (1)
by raising price (1)
encourage people to switch to other forms of transport (1). Award up to 4 marks for why it should not:
Will increase airlines’ costs / reduce airlines’ profits / cause a loss (1)airlines’ other costs are rising (1)
difficult for them to cover higher costs / raise prices (1)
due to elastic demand / price sensitive demand (1)
may go out of business (1)
may discourage investment (1)
causing unemployment (1).
May reduce tourism in the country (1)harming the current account position (1).
Airline fuel is already highly taxed (1)may be difficult to tax further (1).
Ait travel is safer than car travel in many countries (1)so injuries may increase if there is a switch between the two (1). 6 Apply this example to all questions with the command word DISCUSS (1g, 1h, 2d, 3d, 4d and 5d) Each point may be credited only once, on either side of an argument, but separate development as to how/why the outcome may differ is rewarded. Generic example mark Tax revenue may decrease … ... because of reason e.g. incomes may be lower. Tax revenue may increase because incomes may be higher i.e. reverse of a previous argument. Tax revenue may increase because of a different reason i.e. not the reverse of a previous argument e.g. government spending on subsidies may stimulate the economy more than spending on education.
1(h)[6]
Discuss whether more people will apply to be pilots for Indian airlines in the future. Award up to 4 marks for logical reasons why they might:
Introduction of new technology (1)will make the job easier (1)
Improved staff training (1)improve/increase skills (1)
improve motivation / satisfaction (1)
improve working conditions (1)airlines want to retain staff (1)
More routes are being flown / size of industry is increasing (1)demand for pilots may increase / more job opportunities (1)
may raise wages (1).
More fringe benefits may be provided (1)example (1).
Being a pilot is a highly regarded occupation in many countries (1). Award up to 4 marks for logical reasons why they might not:There may not be more people qualified to become pilots (1)education standards may fall / qualifications may be high (1).
Period of training may increase / cost of training may increase (1).Other jobs may offer higher wages / better working conditions / wages of pilots may fall (1)example of other jobs (1).
Advances in technology may reduce the need for pilots (1)may increase skills needed (1).
Increased tax on fuel may reduce the size of the airline industry (1)causing people to expect fewer job opportunities / unemployment of pilots (1).
Price of substitute forms of transport may reduce (1)lowering demand for pilots (1). 6 Note: some points may be given in reverse e.g. education standards may rise. Guidance
Job may require workers to be away from their families (1)people may want to stay close to home (1).
Working hours may be unsociable (1)people may want to spend more time with their families (1).
May be considered in some cases to be a risky job (1).
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

