Chemistry · May / June 2024 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 This question is about the laboratory preparation of the ester methyl salicylate (oil of wintergreen). The equation for this reaction is shown. O O OH + CH3OH O CH3 + H2O OH OH salicylic acid methanol methyl salicylate water Procedure Step 1 20.0 g of salicylic acid and 100 cm3 of methanol are placed into a round‑bottomed flask. Step 2 15.0 cm3 of concentrated sulfuric acid is added slowly, whilst swirling the flask. Step 3 The mixture is heated gently under reflux for 45 minutes. Step 4 After cooling, the mixture is poured into a separating funnel and about 50 cm3 of iced water is added. The funnel is stoppered, shaken and allowed to settle. The aqueous layer is discarded. Step 5 The organic layer is returned to the separating funnel and washed with 50 cm3 of sodium carbonate solution. Step 6 The aqueous layer is discarded leaving the crude methyl salicylate. Step 7 The crude methyl salicylate is distilled and the fraction with the boiling temperature range 220–224°C is collected. Step 8 The pure methyl salicylate is transferred to a bottle and weighed.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[3]
Ignore early and incorrect rounding or truncating
moles of salicylic acid20.0/138.0 = 0.14493 (mol)
100 x 0.791 = 79.1 (g)
mass of methanol79.1/32.0 = 2.4719 (mol)
moles of methanoland
Allow just methanol is in excess if both mol have been
2.4719 (mol) > 0.14493 (mol)/ 2.32697 mol in excess
calculated
Alternative solution using masses instead of moles for M3
0.14493 (mol) × 32 = 4.64 (g) of methanol
and
Ignore SF except 1 SF
79.1(g) > 4.64(g) / the methanol is 74.46 g in excess
TE for wrong moles in M3 as long as methanol moles
are greater than salicylic acid moles
A ratio of 17:1 will score 3 marks
4(b)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
acts as a catalystAllow it catalyses the reaction
Ignore just speeds up the reaction
Ignore supplies hydrogen ions/acidifies the reaction
Ignore dehydrates
Ignore any reference as to how it acts as a catalyst
even if wrong.
Example of diagram
4(c)[3]
Heat
HEAT
roundbottomed / pearshaped flask containingAllow any indication of heat including an arrow or
water bath or electrical heater or Bunsen burner
mixture and heat
Ignore missing antibumping granules
Do not award conical flask or flask with no liquid
vertical condenser with water jacket and waterIgnore thermometer
flowing in the correct direction
Do not award if the condenser and flask are one
no gaps and open condenser and apparatuspiece of apparatus unless both are labelled
would work
Allow just M1 for distillation apparatus
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
4(d)[2]
add sodium carbonate (solution) to the separatingAllow add sodium carbonate (solution) to the
funnel (stopper it) and invert/shake/ swirl/agitate/mix
funnel and invert/shake/ swirl/agitate/mix
Allow add it to the separating funnel and
invert/shake/ swirl/ agitate/mix
Ignore any reference to layers
open the stopcock/tap to release the pressure/gas/Allow remove the stopper to release the
pressure/gas/carbon dioxide
carbon dioxide
Allow opening the funnel to release the
pressure/gas/carbon dioxide
Ignore subsequent steps
Example of calculation:
4(e)[3]
Ignore intermediate rounding and truncating
20.0/138.0 = 0.14493 (mol)
moles of salicylic acid (no mark as already awardedin (a))
152 (g mol−1)
Mr methyl salicylate152 x 0.14493 = 22.029 (g)
maximum mass of methyl salicylate14.1÷ 22.029 x 100 = 64.007
percentage yield calculationand
64 (%)/64.0 (%)
answer to 2 or 3 SF
Correct answer with some working scores 3
Common wrong answers
TE on wrong molar mass for M2 but only allow M3 if
percentage is less than 100%.
Using a Mr of 153 gives an answer of 63.587% and will score
2 if 23 SF
If no attempt has been made at calculating the Mr of
Using a Mr of 140 gives an answer of 69.492% and will score
methyl salicylate score 0.
2 if 23 SF
(Total for Question 4 = 12 marks)
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

