Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 51 · Question 20
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
20 This question is about benzene and some of its compounds.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
20(a)(i)[10]
See examples of mechanism on next page
FeBr3 + Br2 → Br+ + FeBr − /
equation for the formation of the electrophile4
Br−Br + FeBr3 → Brδ+−Brδ− FeBr3
Allow this shown as part of the first step
e.g.
Allow partial charges on Brδ+−Brδ−
curly arrow within the circle/hexagon toDo not award curly arrow starting on or outside the hexagon
anywhere towards or on Br+
Do not award missing +/δ+ on electrophile
Do not award curly arrow to a lone pair of electrons on Br+
intermediate structure including charge withDo not award dotted bonds to H and Br unless they are part of
horseshoe covering at least 3 carbon atoms
a 3D structure
and
facing the tetrahedral carbon atom
and
some part of the positive charge must be within
the horseshoe
curly arrow from C−H bond to anywhere in theIgnore missing H+ / involvement of FeBr − in removal of H+
hexagon, reforming the delocalised structure
4
Ignore reformation of the catalyst even if incorrect
Examples of mechanism
Or
20(a)(ii)*
This question assesses a student’s ability to show a coherent and logically
Guidance on how the mark scheme should be applied:
structured answer with linkages and fullysustained reasoning.
The mark for indicative content should be added to the mark for lines of
reasoning. For example, an answer with five indicative marking points
Marks are awarded for indicative content and for how the answer is
that is partially structured with some linkages and lines of reasoning
structured and shows lines of reasoning.
scores 4 marks (3 marks for indicative content and 1 mark for partial
structure and some linkages and lines of reasoning).
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for indicative
If there are no linkages between points, the same five indicative
content.
marking points would yield an overall score of 3 marks (3 marks for
indicative content and no marks for linkages).
Number of indicative marking
Number of marks awarded for
points seen in answer
indicative marking points
In general it would be expected that 5 or 6 indicative points would get 2
reasoning marks, and 3 or 4 indicative points would get 1 mark for
6
4
reasoning, and 0, 1 or 2 indicative points would score zero marks for
5–4
3
reasoning.
3–2
2
1
1
General points to note
0
0
If there is any incorrect chemistry, deduct mark(s) from the reasoning.
If no reasoning mark(s) awarded do not deduct mark(s).
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for structure
and lines of reasoning.
Number of marks
awarded for structure of
answer and sustained
line of reasoning
Answer shows a coherent and logical
2
structure with linkages and fully sustained
Accept structures for names throughout
lines of reasoning demonstrated throughout.
Answer is partially structured with some
1
If name and formula given both must be correct
linkages and lines of reasoning.
Answer has no linkages between points and
0
Deduct a reasoning mark if there is no comparison given for
is unstructured.
IP1 to IP3
Do not penalise unbalanced / incomplete equations
Comment:
Deduct (mark) from reasoning if any products given are
Look for the indicative marking points first, then consider the mark for
incorrect
structure of answer and sustained line of reasoning
Indicative content
IP1 – SimilarityAll three need to be mentioned for this IP – evidence for
All are attacked by / react with electrophiles
phenol reacting with an electrophile may be seen in IP6
IP2 – Types of reactionAccept benzene forms monobromo product /
Cyclohexene undergoes addition reactions but benzene
bromobenzene, cyclohexene forms dibromo product / 1,2
dibromocyclohexane and phenol forms tribromo product /
and/or phenol undergo substitution reactions
2, 4, 6tribromophenol
Allow HBr is produced with benzene and phenol but
cyclohexene only forms one product
IP3 – ConditionsAllow react under normal laboratory conditions / room
Cyclohexene and/or phenol react with (aqueous) bromine /
temperature and pressure
without a catalyst and benzene needs
(a FriedelCrafts catalyst / iron / iron(III) bromide)
Allow reference to AlBr3/AlCl3
This IP can be awarded if benzene equation has catalyst and
other equation(s) do not
Ignore references to specific temperatures
IP4 – BenzeneAllow delocalised (π) electron ring in benzene is (very)
Benzene has delocalised electrons and is (kinetically) stable
stable
so the reaction has a high activation energy
Allow delocalisation of electrons in π bonds which
decreases the electron density (of the ring) and makes it less
susceptible to electrophilic attack
IP5 – CyclohexeneCyclohexene has localised electron density in one π bond
If neither IP4 or IP5 awarded then allow (1) for benzene has
(which increases the electron density and makes it more
delocalised electrons but cyclohexene does not
susceptible to electrophilic attack)
IP6 – PhenolAllow the lone pair (of electrons) on the oxygen/OH in
Phenol has a lone pair of electrons on the oxygen which is
phenol
delocalised (within the ring)
and increases the electron density of the (benzene)
and
ring/overlaps with the delocalised ring
makes it more susceptible to electrophilic attack
20(b)[7]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Allow displayed / structural / skeletal formulae or any
combination of these
Ignore any references to heat/ incorrect inorganic products
(M1) reagent for step 1 magnesium and (dry) etherExamples of structures of intermediates:
(reacting with bromobenzene)
(M2) first intermediate – phenyl magnesium bromideAllow (1) for M3 for the acid hydrolysis of benzonitrile
(M3) reagent for step 2 – phenyl magnesium bromidewith carbon dioxide / CO2 and
(followed by hydrolysis with) dilute acid / H+
or
methanal and dilute acid / H+ then oxidation
(M4) second intermediate – benzoic acid(M5) reagent for step 3 – phosphorus(V) chloride /Allow thionyl chloride/SOCl2
PCl5
(M6) third intermediate – benzoyl chloride(M7) reagent for step 4 – ammonia / NH3 added to anDo not award dilute ammonia or ammonia added to
acyl chloride
benzoic acid
M4 to M7 from scheme above can be awarded from
benzoic acid however produced
20(c)(i)[1]
Accept skeletal/displayed/structural formulae or
combination thereof provided it is correct
repeat unitExample of repeat unit:
Accept switching of monomer positions, e.g.
Allow amide link to be drawn as CONH/ – NH – CO –
Allow ‘cis’ orientation of amide link
Ignore bond lengths and bond angles
Ignore brackets around repeat unit and n
Ignore byproducts such as HCl
Do not award additional incomplete repeat units
Do not award hydrogen drawn with two single bonds,
e.g. – N – H – CO
Do not award missing continuation/extension bonds
20(c)(ii)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following point:
Reference to breaking of covalent bonds scores (0)
Ignore references to (permanent) dipole forces
because there is hydrogen bonding (and LondonAllow ‘it’ for the polyamide since it is the subject of
forces between the chains) in a polyamide
the question, so “it has hydrogen bonding” scores M1
Do not award if hydrogen bonding to water stated
Do not award if hydrogen bonding shown by CH2
Do not award if ionic bonding or ions referred to
(and this is) stronger than the London forces betweenAccept dispersion forces / attractions between
the chains in polyalkenes (so more energy is needed
temporary and induced dipoles for London forces
Allow van der Waals’ forces for London forces
to separate the polyamide molecules)
or
the London forces between the chains in polyalkenes
Allow London forces in polyalkenes are easier to
overcome (than hydrogen bonding)
are weaker (than hydrogen bonding so more energy is
needed to separate the polyamide molecules)
Note that M2 is awarded for a comparison of the
weakness of London forces to the strength of hydrogen
bonding. Hence M2 is dependent on M1 or nearmiss
(Total for Question 20 = 20 marks)
(Total for Section B = 51 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

