Chemistry · May / June 2023 · Paper 41 · Question 17
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
17 A Born–Haber cycle for calcium chloride is shown. Ca2+(g) + 2Cl(g) 2 × +122 kJ mol–1 Ca2+(g) + Cl2(g) 2 × –349 kJ mol–1 Ca2+(g) + 2Cl–(g) +1145 kJ mol–1 Ca+(g) + Cl2(g) +590 kJ mol–1 –2258 kJ mol–1 Ca(g) + Cl2(g) +178 kJ mol–1 Ca(s) + Cl2(g) CaCl2(s)
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
17(a)[1]
Do not award ‒178 (kJ mol‒1)
(+)178 (kJ mol‒1)Ignore units even if incorrect
17(b)[2]
Example of calculation:
equation or workingsΔfH = Σ(all other terms)
ΔfH = 178 + 590 + 1145 + (2 × 122) + (2 × ‒349) + (‒2258)
answer to 3SF with negative sign‒799 (kJ mol‒1)
Correct answer scores (2)
TE on incorrectly transferred values e.g. ‒394
Penalise omission of ×2 once only (–572 scores 1 mark)
TE on one incorrect sign
No TE on incorrect expression
Penalise M2 for incorrect units
+799 scores 1 mark
17(c)[4]
An explanation that makes reference to the following points:
Allow reverse arguments
calcium chloride is almost completely ionicAccept CaCl2 is 100% ionic
Allow LE is calculated assuming a pure ionic
structure
Allow shows more covalent character
calcium iodide has partially covalent characterAllow CaCl2 has less covalent character than CaI2
Ignore polar
Do not award M2 for CaI2 is covalent
Do not award M2 for Intermolecular forces
Accept iodide has a lower charge density
iodide (ion) is larger (than chloride (ion))Allow iodine ion
Ignore iodine is larger
Do not award molecules, Cl2 or I2 loses M3
Accept more (easily) distorted
(so) more (easily) polarisedAllow (more) polarisable
Do not award CaI2 is more polarised
If no comparison for M3 and M4 allow 1 mark, e.g.,
“iodide is large and is polarised”
Penalise iodine/chlorine or incorrect ions once only.
17(d)(i)[2]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
An example of a completed cycle:
two labelled arrows in the correct directionformulae including state symbolsAccept two arrows on righthand side
Allow ΔlattH/ ΔHlatt
Allow ΔhydH alone on righthand arrow
Allow ΔHhyd
Allow numerical values rather than the symbols
Allow missing 2 for the ΔhydH Cl–
Allow left arrow going down if labelled as lattice
dissociation energy or –LE
17(d)(ii)[2]
Example of a calculation:
calculation‒(‒2258) ‒ 1579 ‒ (2 × 378)
enthalpy change of solution= ‒77 (kJ mol‒1)
No TE on an incorrect cycle, but (+)77 scores 1 mark
Allow TE on transcription errors from M1, and award
M2
Allow ×2 omitted, answer = (+)301 (kJ mol‒1) scores (1)
(Total for Question 17 = 11 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

