Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 51 · Question 19
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
19 This question is about benzene, C6H6 , a colourless liquid first isolated in 1825, and some related compounds. Three C6H6 structures proposed in the 1860s are shown. Kekulé structure Dewar structure Ladenburg structure The delocalised model for the structure of benzene has been accepted since the 1930s following the study of its X‑ray diffraction pattern and the understanding of electron delocalisation in bonding theory. The Dewar and Ladenburg structures have since been isolated as stable compounds but there is no compound with the Kekulé structure. benzene
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
19(a)[2]
suitable test: bromine water/Br2(aq) (1)Allow bromine / Br2((l)) / Br2 in organic solvent
Do not award Br/Br−
Accept potassium manganate((VII))/KMnO4 and acidified/
named acid/H+
Do not award hydrogenation
Do not award combustion
result of test: decolourises (from orange) withAllow does not decolourise with benzene
Dewar structure (and no change with benzene) (1)
Allow brown/orange/yellow for colour of bromine water
Allow red/brown/orange for colour of bromine
Allow pink/purple for colour of potassium manganate((VII))
Ignore colour fades for decolourises
Ignore reference to addition/substitution
Do not award any reference to decolourisation/reaction with
benzene
19(b)[2]
Ignore any reference to IR and/or 13C NMR
similarity: (both compounds have) one (NMR) peak (1)Allow (both compounds have) one proton environment
Ignore just same number of peaks
Ignore references to relative peak area/integration/splitting
Do not award any other number of peaks
difference: expected chemical shift values (1)chemical shift for benzene within range of 6.4 to 8.4 ppm
(actual value is 7.3 ppm)
and
chemical shift for Ladenburg structure within range of
0 to 2.3 ppm (actual value is 2.3 ppm)
Allow any range or value within the above ranges
Ignore just benzene would have a higher chemical shift than
Ladenburg structure or reverse argument
Do not award additional incorrect chemical shifts
19(c)[2]
An explanation that makes reference to the following
Ignore any reference to:
points:
C−H bonds
bond strength/bond angle
delocalised electrons
Dewar/Ladenburg structures
showed that all C−C bonds are the same length inAllow showed benzene is a regular hexagon
benzene (1)
Allow showed benzene contains only one type of
carboncarbon bond
Allow benzene bond lengths are in between C=C and C−C
Ignore just benzene has no C=C bonds
Do not award benzene bond lengths are longer than C−C/
shorter than C=C
in Kekulé structure the C=C bonds would beAllow Kekulé structure would have shown two different
shorter than the C−C bonds (or reverse argument) (1)
lengths/types of carboncarbon bond
Allow Kekulé structure would have alternating carboncarbon
bond lengths
Ignore just Kekulé has C=C bonds
Do not award C−C bonds would be shorter than the C=C bonds
If no other mark awarded, just bond lengths equal in benzene
but different in Kekulé scores (1)
19(d)(i)[2]
A diagram showing:
Example of diagram:
correct relative stabilities (1)two or three numerical differences in enthalpywith appropriate arrows (1)
Allow names for structures
If three values and arrows are given they must all be correct to
score M2
Allow slight imprecision in start and end of arrows in M2
Ignore any xaxis label
Do not award double headed arrows in M2
Do not award incorrect sign in M2
19(d)(ii)[1]
An answer that makes reference to the following:
pi bonds are weaker/more reactive/require lessIgnore just Dewar structure has pi/double bonds/is unsaturated
energy to break (than sigma bonds)
Ignore just Dewar structure has weaker bonds
Do not award C=C/double bonds weaker/require less energy to
break (than C−C/single bonds)
or
fewer bonds must break to convert the
Accept reverse argument
Dewar structure to benzene
Allow any specified numbers to indicate fewer bonds must break
Ignore fewer new bonds must form
Ignore Dewar structure is more similar to benzene
Ignore carbon atoms already in a ring/hexagon
Ignore any reference to intermolecular forces
Do not award (higher) ring strain in Ladenburg
Do not award smaller difference in enthalpy
Do not award Ladenburg structure more stable
19(e)[2]
An explanation that makes reference to the following
Allow double bond for C=C throughout
points:
Ehexa1,4diene
twice the hydrogenation enthalpy (of hex3ene)Accept −118 × 2 (=−236) as two C=C bonds
as two (isolated) C=C bonds (1)
Allow twice the hydrogenation enthalpy as no delocalisation of
pibond(s)
Ehexa1,3diene
less exothermic/more stable (by 22 kJ mol−1 thanAccept less negative
Ehexa1,4diene
Allow more positive
and
as some delocalisation of pibond(s) (1)
Allow some delocalisation of double bond(s)
Allow double bonds/porbitals are conjugated
Allow double bonds/porbitals are close enough to overlap
Ignore just C=C are close
Ignore just delocalisation of electrons
Ignore electron density more spread out
Ignore resonance stabilised
19(f)(i)[2]
Example of correct skeletal formulae:
skeletal formula of any one isomer (1)skeletal formulae of second and third isomers (1)(1,2isomer) (1,3isomer) (1,4isomer)
Allow Kekulé benzene ring
Allow structural/displayed CH3 and CH3CO groups
If no other mark awarded, 1,2, 1,3 and 1,4isomers with
incorrect side chain/cyclohexane ring scores (1)
19(f)(ii)[2]
(identification of X as) 1,4isomer (1)Allow any form of identification, including (f)(i) annotation
Allow just ‘1,4’ or ‘para’
(7 peaks consistent with) 7 carbon environments (1)M2 dependent on a structure containing 7 carbon
environments
Accept 1,2isomer and/or 1,3isomer have 9 carbon
environments/would have 9 peaks
Allow (4 arene peaks consistent with) 4 arene carbon
environments
Allow 1,2isomer and/or 1,3isomer have 6 arene carbon
environments/would have 6 arene peaks
19(f)(iii)[4]
A mechanism including:
Example of mechanism:
Allow Kekulé benzene ring
curly arrow from on or within circleto C+ of CH3CO+ (1)
structure of intermediate ion (1)‘Horseshoe’ facing tetrahedral carbon and covering at least three
carbons with some part of positive sign within ‘horseshoe’
Allow methyl at 1,2 or 1,3positions
Ignore missing methyl substituent
Do not award dotted/dashed C−H/C−C bonds unless 3D structure
curly arrow from C−H bond to within ringand
Allow 1,2 or 1,3product from corresponding intermediate
correct product (1)
Do not award missing methyl substituent
balanced equation for regeneration of catalyst (1)AlCl4− + H+ AlCl3 + HCl
(Total for Question 19 = 19 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

