Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 41 · Question 16
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
16 Compound X is used by mammals as an alternative energy source to sugars. X is a compound of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen only.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
16(a)(i)[1]
otherwise the mass of water from the combustion cannot
Allow any indication that the measurement of water is affected
be measured
Allow indication that the values of H and O obtained will be
affected
Ignore just reference to ‘the products’
Do not award (presence of water) affects the reaction of O2 with X
Do not award water reacts with X
Do not award water dissolves CO2
16(a)(ii)[5]
Example of calculation
moles of CO2and H2O (1)
mol CO2 = 4.31 ÷ 44 = 0.097955
mol H2O = 1.32 ÷ 18 = 0.073333
mass of C = 0.097955 x 12 = 1.1755 g
masses of C and H (1)
mass of H = 0.073333 x 2 = 0.1467 g
mass of O = 2.50 − (1.1755 + 0.1467)
mass of O (1)
= 1.1778 g
C
H
O
0.0980 x 1
0.0733 x 2
1.178/16
moles of C, H and O (1)
mol
= 0.0980
= 0.147
= 0.0736
ratio
1.33
2
1
integers
4
6
3
ratio (1.33:2:1), ( integer ratio) and empirical formula
C4H6O3
No TE if oxygen mass not calculated
In M1 and M2 mol CO2 and mass of carbon scores (1)
mol H2O and mass of hydrogen scores (1)
Example of inductive calculation
Allow inductive calculation
C4H6O3 + 4O2 → 4CO2 + 3H2O
balanced equation (1)
Formula mass (4x12 + 6 + 3 x 16) = 102 (g)
Formula mass (C4H6O3) (1)
CO2 = 4 x 44 = 176 (g) and H2O = 3 x 18 = 54 (g)
Product masses from equation (1)
2.5 x 176 ÷ 102 = 2.5 (g)
Mass of CO2 from 2.5 g of X (1)
2.5 x 54 ÷ 102 = 1.32 (g)
Mass of H2O from 2.5 g of X (1)
Correct answer with any correct method scores (5)
Correct answer with no working scores (0)
TE at each stage
Ignore SF except 1 SF
16(b)(i)[6]
An answer that makes reference to the following
two structures (2)
A
B
Allow displayed or structural formulae or any combination of
skeletal, displayed and structural
Penalise incorrect horizontal –OH connectivity once
Ignore names even if incorrect
13C spectrum shows four different (types of) carbon atom
Accept X has four carbon environments
Allow 13C spectrum shows X has four types of carbon atom
(so molecular formula same as empirical formula) (1)
Ignore just ‘X has four carbon atoms’
Ignore just ‘X is a ketone’ / C=O present
reaction with Brady’s reagent indicates a carbonyl
compound (1)
Do not award ‘acyl’
no reaction with Tollens’ reagent indicates a ketone (group)
/ not an aldehyde (1)
reaction with NaHCO3 (forming CO2) indicates
Accept COOH (group)
(carboxylic) acid (1)
16(b)(ii)[3]
An answer that makes reference to the following
reagents for iodoform test (1)
iodine / I2
and
sodium hydroxide /NaOH / potassium hydroxide KOH
Accept NaI / KI and NaOCl
Allow iodine and OH− / alkali
Ignore ‘iodoform test’
result for methyl ketone (1)
(pale) yellow precipitate
Allow
yellow solid / ppt /ppte /antiseptic smell
No change / precipitate
result for ethyl ketone (1)
Allow
no reaction / (pale) yellow precipitate does not form
M2 and M3 dependent on M1 or a near miss or just
‘iodoform test’
If result not linked to structure max (2)
e.g NaOH and I2 give yellow ppt (positive) and no reaction
(negative) scores (2)
If no reagent or an incorrect reagent given then both
observation marks correct scores (1)
Do not award use of physical methods
16(c)[5]
An answer that makes reference to the following
structure of X (1)
Answers may refer to the diagram
Allow number of peaks shows number of proton
(three) peaks indicate three proton environments (1)
environments
Allow if the protons in each environment are
clearly labelled e.g. each set circled
Ignore just ‘peak areas are 3:2:1’
peak heights / areas indicate environments contain 3, 2 and 1 protons (1)
all singlets / no splitting so no adjacent proton environments (1)
peak at δ about 11.1 is COOH
identification of proton environments from chemical shifts (1)
peak at δ about1.9 is CH3CO
peak at δ about 2.5 is OCCH2COOH
Allow ‘alkane proton’ / HCC
Allow both 1.9 and 2.5 identified as HCC=O
Do not award reference to the functional group
rather than the proton
M2, M3 and M5 may be awarded without
referring to the structure
M2 and M3 are standalone
(Total for Question 16 = 20 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

