Chemistry · May / June 2021 · Paper 51 · Question 18
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
18 This question is about manganese compounds. Some data are given below. Electrode reaction EO / V − + e− ⇌ MnO4 2− 1 MnO4 +0.56 2− + 2H2O + 2e− ⇌ MnO2 + 4OH− 2 MnO4 +0.59 Fe3+ + e− ⇌ Fe2+ 3 +0.77 MnO2 + 4H+ + 2e− ⇌ Mn2+ + 2H2O 4 +1.23 − + 8H+ + 5e− ⇌ Mn2+ + 4H2O 5 MnO4 +1.51 − + 4H+ + 3e− ⇌ MnO2 + 2H2O 6 MnO4 +1.70 2− + 4H+ + 2e− ⇌ MnO2 + 2H2O 7 MnO4 +2.26
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
18(a)(i)[2]
selection of the correct halfequations from the table (1)[7] MnO42− + 4H++ 2e−⇌MnO2 + 2H2O
3MnO42− + 4H+⇌ 2MnO4− + MnO2 + 2H2O
writing the balanced equation (1)Allow
[1] MnO4− + e−⇌MnO42−and
[5] MnO4− + 8H++ 5e−⇌Mn2+ + 4H2O
which gives
5MnO42− + 8H+⇌ 4MnO4− + Mn2+ + 4H2O
Accept e for e− in half equations
Correct equation scores (2) marks
Unbalanced equation with all species correct
scores (1)
Use of alkaline halfequation to give
3MnO42− + 2H2O ⇌ 2MnO4− + MnO2 + 4OH−
scores (1) mark
Ignore state symbols even if incorrect
18(a)(ii)[2]
selection of appropriate values and insertion in the correct equation (1)Eocell = 2.26 − 0.56
completion of calculation= (+)1.70 (V) and (positive so
and
reaction is) feasible
evaluation of the feasibility of the reaction (1)
Accept (if second equation given)
Eocell = 1.51 − 0.56
= (+)0.95 (V) and (positive so
reaction is) feasible
TE on alkaline disproportionation
Eocell = 0.59 − 0.56 = (+)0.03 (V) and
(positive so reaction is) feasible scores (2)
TE on equations used the wrong way
round −1.70 / −0.95(V) and not feasible
scores (1)
Just (+)1.70 (V) / (+)0.95 (V) scores (1)
Do not award a nondisproportionation
reaction
For M1 and M2Either
18(a)(iii)[4]
2MnO4− + MnO2 + 4OH−⇌3MnO42− + 2H2O
equation for the reaction (1)Allow → for ⇌
Or Eocell = 0.56 − 0.59
Eocell = −0.03 (V)
calculation of negative Eocell for the equation (1)Or
Reverse reaction and Eocell = (+)0.03 (V) (1)
Equations 1 and 2
clear identification of the appropriate halfequations from the table (1)use of anticlockwise rule or similar to show that required reaction isDesired reaction moves ‘clockwise’ so not
not favoured (1)
(thermodynamically) feasible
Allow calculation of Eocell as above
For M3 and M4
(−)0.03 (V) /Eocellis a (very) small
statement that the standard electrode potential values are close (1)Or
equilibrium has significant concentrations of
the reactants and products
Allow if Eocell = (+)0.03 (V) in M2
Standalone mark
Allow by increasing alkali concentration
reaction may be shifted in the required direction using concentratedNo TE on incorrect system
alkali (1)
Ignore
just ‘by changing concentrations’
references to rate and temperature
Ignore state symbols even if incorrect
18(b)(i)[1]
colourlessAllow pale green for colourless
and
Do not award just ‘green’ for the start colour
to pale pink
Accept pink
Do not award purple / magenta
Ignore ‘clear’
Ignore ‘permanent’
Example of calculation
18(b)(ii)[5]
calculation of moles of manganate(VII) in 27.35 cm3 (1)27.35 x 0.0195 x 10−3
= 5.33325 x 10−4/ 0.000533325 (mol)
use of 1:5 ratio to calculate mol Fe2+ in 25.0 cm3 (1)5 x 5.33325 x 10−4
= 2.666625 x 10−3 /0.002666625 (mol)
scaling to 250.0 cm3to give mol Fe2+ in 250.0 cm3 (1)10 x 2.666625 x 10−3
= 2.666625 x 10−2/ 0.02666625mol)
conversion of mol to g of iron (1)2.666625 x 10−2 x 55.8 = 1.48798 (g)
calculation of percentage of iron in the wire and gives the final value to3 SF (1)
100 x 1.48798/1.53 = 97.25338
= 97.3%
If Ar (Fe) = 56 is used mass = 1.49331 (g)
% iron = 97.6%
Allow 100 x 1.49/1.53 =97.4%
Correct answer to 3 SF and some working
scores (5)
TE at each stage
Ignore premature rounding if final answer
correct otherwise allow rounding to at least
3SF
18(b)(iii) An explanation that makes reference to the following
Reference to halfequations 6 & 7 in the
brown suspension formed is manganese(IV) oxide / MnO2 (1)table
Allow
manganese(IV) oxide / MnO2formed (in
alkaline conditions)
Mn(VII) to Mn(II) provides 5 electrons per MnO4− but Mn(VII) toAccept explanation in terms of oxidation
numbers
Mn(IV) only provides 3 electrons
Standalone mark
so more MnO4− is needed / titre is greater (1)If no other mark is scored, allow one mark
for the titration is no longer quantitative as
another reaction is (also) taking place.
100 x 0.005 x 2
18(b)(iii)[3]
selection of the correct halfequations from the table (1)[7] MnO42− + 4H++ 2e−⇌MnO2 + 2H2O
3MnO42− + 4H+⇌ 2MnO4− + MnO2 + 2H2O
writing the balanced equation (1)Allow
[1] MnO4− + e−⇌MnO42−and
[5] MnO4− + 8H++ 5e−⇌Mn2+ + 4H2O
which gives
5MnO42− + 8H+⇌ 4MnO4− + Mn2+ + 4H2O
Accept e for e− in half equations
Correct equation scores (2) marks
Unbalanced equation with all species correct
scores (1)
Use of alkaline halfequation to give
3MnO42− + 2H2O ⇌ 2MnO4− + MnO2 + 4OH−
scores (1) mark
Ignore state symbols even if incorrect
selection of appropriate values and insertion in the correct equation (1)Eocell = 2.26 − 0.56
completion of calculation= (+)1.70 (V) and (positive so
and
reaction is) feasible
evaluation of the feasibility of the reaction (1)
Accept (if second equation given)
Eocell = 1.51 − 0.56
= (+)0.95 (V) and (positive so
reaction is) feasible
TE on alkaline disproportionation
Eocell = 0.59 − 0.56 = (+)0.03 (V) and
(positive so reaction is) feasible scores (2)
TE on equations used the wrong way
round −1.70 / −0.95(V) and not feasible
scores (1)
Just (+)1.70 (V) / (+)0.95 (V) scores (1)
Do not award a nondisproportionation
reaction
For M1 and M2Either
2MnO4− + MnO2 + 4OH−⇌3MnO42− + 2H2O
equation for the reaction (1)Allow → for ⇌
Or Eocell = 0.56 − 0.59
Eocell = −0.03 (V)
calculation of negative Eocell for the equation (1)Or
Reverse reaction and Eocell = (+)0.03 (V) (1)
Equations 1 and 2
clear identification of the appropriate halfequations from the table (1)use of anticlockwise rule or similar to show that required reaction isDesired reaction moves ‘clockwise’ so not
not favoured (1)
(thermodynamically) feasible
Allow calculation of Eocell as above
For M3 and M4
(−)0.03 (V) /Eocellis a (very) small
statement that the standard electrode potential values are close (1)Or
equilibrium has significant concentrations of
the reactants and products
Allow if Eocell = (+)0.03 (V) in M2
Standalone mark
Allow by increasing alkali concentration
reaction may be shifted in the required direction using concentratedNo TE on incorrect system
alkali (1)
Ignore
just ‘by changing concentrations’
references to rate and temperature
Ignore state symbols even if incorrect
colourlessAllow pale green for colourless
and
Do not award just ‘green’ for the start colour
to pale pink
Accept pink
Do not award purple / magenta
Ignore ‘clear’
Ignore ‘permanent’
Example of calculation
calculation of moles of manganate(VII) in 27.35 cm3 (1)27.35 x 0.0195 x 10−3
= 5.33325 x 10−4/ 0.000533325 (mol)
use of 1:5 ratio to calculate mol Fe2+ in 25.0 cm3 (1)5 x 5.33325 x 10−4
= 2.666625 x 10−3 /0.002666625 (mol)
scaling to 250.0 cm3to give mol Fe2+ in 250.0 cm3 (1)10 x 2.666625 x 10−3
= 2.666625 x 10−2/ 0.02666625mol)
conversion of mol to g of iron (1)2.666625 x 10−2 x 55.8 = 1.48798 (g)
calculation of percentage of iron in the wire and gives the final value to3 SF (1)
100 x 1.48798/1.53 = 97.25338
= 97.3%
If Ar (Fe) = 56 is used mass = 1.49331 (g)
% iron = 97.6%
Allow 100 x 1.49/1.53 =97.4%
Correct answer to 3 SF and some working
scores (5)
TE at each stage
Ignore premature rounding if final answer
correct otherwise allow rounding to at least
3SF
18(b)(iii) An explanation that makes reference to the following
Reference to halfequations 6 & 7 in the
brown suspension formed is manganese(IV) oxide / MnO2 (1)table
Allow
manganese(IV) oxide / MnO2formed (in
alkaline conditions)
Mn(VII) to Mn(II) provides 5 electrons per MnO4− but Mn(VII) toAccept explanation in terms of oxidation
numbers
Mn(IV) only provides 3 electrons
Standalone mark
so more MnO4− is needed / titre is greater (1)If no other mark is scored, allow one mark
for the titration is no longer quantitative as
another reaction is (also) taking place.
100 x 0.005 x 2
1.53
(Balance:
= 0.65)
100 x 0.05 x 2
27.35
All three percentages correct scores (2)
burette:= 0.37(%)
100 x 0.06
25
Any two percentages correct scores (1)
pipette:= 0.24(%)
IGNORE SF
100 x 0.3
250
volumetric flask:= 0.12(%)
(Total = 1.38) (2)
An explanation that makes reference to
total percentage uncertainty is (approximately) 1.38% (1)TE on 18(c)(i)
Allow 1.4% / 2 SF
because the total percentage uncertainty is much bigger than 0.863, theAccept % correction of rounding 95.863 to
answer should be to no more than 2 / 3 SF(1)
95.9 = 100 x 0.037 ÷ 95.863 = 0.039 %
and negligible compared with 1,38%
Ignore ‘data given to 3SF’
(Total for Question 18 = 21 marks)
Allow amino
Amine18(c)(i)[2]
1.53
(Balance:
= 0.65)
100 x 0.05 x 2
27.35
All three percentages correct scores (2)
burette:= 0.37(%)
100 x 0.06
25
Any two percentages correct scores (1)
pipette:= 0.24(%)
IGNORE SF
100 x 0.3
250
volumetric flask:= 0.12(%)
(Total = 1.38) (2)
An explanation that makes reference to
18(c)(ii)[2]
total percentage uncertainty is (approximately) 1.38% (1)TE on 18(c)(i)
Allow 1.4% / 2 SF
because the total percentage uncertainty is much bigger than 0.863, theAccept % correction of rounding 95.863 to
answer should be to no more than 2 / 3 SF(1)
95.9 = 100 x 0.037 ÷ 95.863 = 0.039 %
and negligible compared with 1,38%
Ignore ‘data given to 3SF’
(Total for Question 18 = 21 marks)
Allow amino
Amine
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

