Chemistry · Oct / Nov 2020 · Paper 51 · Question 24
YCH11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
24 This question is about transition metals and their compounds.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
24(a)(i)[2]
Examples of equation:
[Fe(H2O)6]3+ + 3NH3 → Fe(OH)3 + 3H2O + 3NH4+
correct formula of iron(III) hydroxide (1)
or
rest of equation correct, conditional on correct
[Fe(H2O)6]3+ + 3NH3 → Fe(OH)3(H2O)3 + 3NH4+
precipitate (1)
Allow Fe(H2O)3(OH)3
Ignore state symbols, even if incorrect
Ignore square brackets around iron(III) hydroxide formulae
24(a)(ii)[1]
ligand exchange / ligand substitution
Allow ligand replacement
/ ligand displacement
Do not award ligand change / change in coordination
number / redox / deprotonation in addition to correct
24(a)(iii)[2]
Example of diagram:
Allow NH2− Fe on left of structure
6 bonds between N in diamines and Fe (1)
Conditional on 6 NFe bonds
rest of diagram correct (1)
Allow C2H for CH2, H2N for NH2 etc
Allow displayed / skeletal formulae for ligands
Ignore bond lengths and bond angles
Ignore missing brackets and charge / 3+ on Fe
Ignore lone pairs on N / arrows added to bonds
unless pointing towards the nitrogen atoms
Do not award two nitrogens from the molecule
bonded at 180o to Fe ion
24(b)(i)[2]
Example of table:
any 2 colours (1)
Oxidation state of
Colour of aqueous
vanadium
solution
third colour (1)
+3
green
+4
blue
+5
yellow or colourless
Ignore any further description of colour e.g. pale
yellow
Do not award combined colours e.g. blue/green
24(b)(ii)[1]
Allow the oxidation number of vanadium remains the
it is not a redox reaction because the oxidation number of
same if one oxidation number given – this may be
shown by the equation
vanadium is (+)5 in both species
Ignore ‘there are no electrons in the equation’
Ignore just ‘the oxidation number of vanadium does
not change’
Do not award reference to any atom oxidised or
reduced
Do not award vanadium oxidation number is (+)5 in
both species so it is a redox reaction
24(b)(iii)[5]
An answer that makes reference to the following points:
Examples of equations:
Allow multiples
Ignore state symbols even if incorrect
Ignore uncancelled H+ / H2O
Penalise uncancelled electrons once only
NO3− + 2H+ + V2+ → NO2 + H2O + V3+
equation for oxidation of V2+ to V3+ (1)
Allow Cu2+ + V2+ → Cu+ + V3+
Allow ½Br2 + V2+ → Br− + V3+
Eocell = (+)1.06 (V)
Eocell for oxidation of V2+ to V3+ (1)
TE on Cu2+ / Br2 chosen as oxidising agent
With Cu2+ Eocell = (+)0.41(0) (V)
With Br2 Eocell = (+)1.35 (V)
equation for oxidation of V3+ to VO2+ (1)
NO3− + V3+ → NO2 + VO2+
Allow ½Br2 + V3+ + H2O → Br− + VO2+ + 2H+
Eocell = (+)0.46 (V)
Eocell for oxidation of V3+ to VO2+ (1)
With Br2 Eocell = (+)0.75 (V)
VO2+ is not oxidised to VO2+ / any further as Eocell is −0.2 (V) /
Allow this shown in an equation
negative (1)
24(c)[6]
This question assesses the student’s ability to show a coherent
Guidance on how the mark scheme should be
and logically structured answer with linkages and fully sustained
applied.
reasoning.
The mark for indicative content should be added to
Marks are awarded for indicative content and for how the answer
the mark for lines of reasoning. For example, a
is structured and shows lines of reasoning.
response with five indicative marking points that is
partially structured with some linkages and lines of
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for
reasoning scores 4 marks (3 marks for indicative
indicative content.
content and 1 mark for partial structure and some
Number of indicative
Number of marks awarded
linkages and lines of reasoning).
marking points seen in
for indicative marking points
If there were no linkages between the points, then
6
4
the same indicative marking points would yield an
overall score of 3 marks (3 marks for indicative
54
3
32
2
content and no marks for linkages).
1
1
0
0
In general it would be expected that 5 or 6
indicative points would get 2 reasoning marks, and
The following table shows how the marks should be awarded for
3 or 4 indicative points would get 1 mark for
structure and lines of reasoning
reasoning, and 0, 1 or 2 indicative points would
score zero marks for reasoning.
Number of marks awarded
for structure of answer and
sustained lines of reasoning
Answer shows a coherent logical
2
structure with linkages and fully
sustained lines of reasoning
demonstrated throughout
Answer is partially structured
1
with some linkages and lines of
reasoning
Answer has no linkages between
0
points and is unstructured
If there is any incorrect chemistry, deduct mark(s)
Comment: Look for the indicative marking points first, then
from the reasoning. If no reasoning mark(s)
consider the mark for the structure of the answer and sustained
awarded do not deduct mark(s).
line of reasoning.
e.g. iron catalysing formation of ammonia from
nitrogen and hydrogen but naming it the Contact
Process / incorrect formula e.g. for persulfate ions
Allow correct formulae for names
Do not award examples that are not transition
metals, ions or compounds
Indicative content
Allow this shown on a MaxwellBoltzmann
IP1 Comparison Activation energy
both catalysts increase the rate of reaction by providing an
distribution / reaction profile diagram
alternative route / mechanism with a lower activation energy
Allow (physical) state for phase
IP2 Phase
a heterogeneous catalyst is in a different phase from the
Allow heterogeneous catalysts are easy to separate
reactants and a homogeneous catalyst is in the same phase as
from the reaction mixture / reactants / products
and homogeneous catalysts are difficult to
the reactants / all solutions / gases
separate from the reaction mixture / reactants /
products
IP3 Example of heterogeneous
example of a heterogeneous catalyst and reaction it catalyses
e.g. iron and Haber Process, nickel and hydrogenation of
alkenes, platinum in a catalytic converter / with CO and NO
IP4 Example of homogeneous
example of a homogeneous catalyst and reaction it catalyses
e.g. iron(II) / iron(III) ions and reaction between iodide ions
and persulfate ions
Allow e.g. reactant molecules bind to active sites
IP5 Mechanism of heterogeneous
for adsorbed /
reactant molecules are adsorbed onto the catalyst surface,
particles react for bonds weakened /
the bonds are weakened, reaction takes place then the
product molecules leave for desorbed
product molecules are desorbed
Allow vanadium(V) oxide reduced to vanadium(IV)
and oxidised back to vanadium(V) for the Contact
Process
Allow this shown in equations, even if unbalanced
IP6 Mechanism of homogeneous
Allow donate / receive electrons for oxidised /
the transition metal ion is oxidised / reduced to a different
reduced
oxidation state then changes back to the original oxidation
state
(Total for Question 24 = 19 marks)
Total for Section B = 50 marks
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

