Biology · May / June 2025 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 Fitness programmes affect the time it takes a person to recover after exercise. The recovery rate is the time it takes for the breathing rate and tidal volume to return to their levels before exercise (resting rate). A student observed that the recovery rate varied between students. The diagram shows the apparatus used to investigate the recovery time of students after exercise. pen movable lid spirometer trace counterbalance container for carbon dioxide absorber mouthpiece oxygen inlet The student formed the following hypothesis: Students who have used a fitness programme have a shorter recovery time than those who have not used the programme.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[2]
A description that includes two of the following points:
ethical concern needs to get (informed) consent of
Accept students cannot be forced to participate
volunteer (1)
safety prevent infection of mouthpiece (1)
Accept check students do not have health
problem/are able to do the exercise
Accept change the carbon dioxide absorber
regularly
4(b)[9]
An answer that includes nine of the following points:
Ignore amount
one group with and one without a fitness programme (1)
Accept groups with different fitness programmes
and no programme
clear statement of the dependent variable e.g. the time
accept resting tidal volume or resting breathing rate
for the trace to return to the resting rate/ tidal volume (1)
not recovery time
detail of method/use of apparatus (1)
e.g. use of nose clip/calibrating/reading the
trace/get volunteers used to the apparatus/change
use of soda lime (in canister) (1)
soda lime
ignore volume/mass of soda lime
{sterilize/replace} mouthpiece for each student (1)
find the resting breathing rate/tidal volume/ (1)
e.g. exercise for one minute
use of standardised/same exercise (1)
measure the time to return to the resting rate/normal
accept resting tidal volume or resting breathing rate
breathing rate/recovery time (1)
accept description of finding resting rate
two variables that need to be controlled (1)
accept BM1/sex/height/mass/age/room
temperature/humidity/smokers/non smokers
and method of control of one variable (1)
e.g. temperature and AC
repeats to give mean values AND SD’s (1)
accept mean to do t test/to measure variability of
data
4(c)[3]
An answer that includes the following points:
table for raw data with headings and unit for time, with
Do not accept a calculated rate/recovery
means calculated from repeats (1)
rate heading in table (not raw data)
AND
But allow breathing rate
bar graph format with labelled axes (1)
accept description of mean calculated in
text or mean on one graph label
use of a t test(for difference) (with a bar graph showing only
accept inspect SD’s/ for overlap
two different fitness levels)
ignore error bars
OR
{line / scatter} graph format with labelled axes (1)
use of a correlation test (with a line graph showing more
Accept any named correlation test
than two different fitness levels)
4(d)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following points:
difficult to control all other aspects of volunteers’ life
e.g. genetic difference/ stress/ diet/respiratory
before the experiment (1)
disease/problem/previous level of
fitness/health
a stated difficulty with the apparatus (1)
e.g. leaking air/soda lime stops
working/difficult to read the trace/abnormal
breathing with spirometer
ignore temperature of the lab
(Total for question 4 = 16 marks)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

