Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2025 · Paper 51 · Question 8

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

8 The scientific document you have studied is adapted from the articles Risk of heart failure may increase with age due to Y chromosome loss and Essence of man: Y size doesn’t matter in the New Scientist. Use the information from the scientific document and your own knowledge to answer the following questions.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 8(a)(i)[1]

    A calculation showing the following steps:

    NO ECF

    correct measurement of the lengths of X and Y

    X = 94 mm Y = 39 mm accept in

    chromosome (1)

    cm

    (accept +/1mm)

    ratio calculated and given in the correct format (1)

    (94÷39) = 2.4 : 1

    ACCEPT 2.5 : 1 2.3 :1

    correct answer gains full marks

    An answer that includes two of the following points:

    (loss of Y chromosome) means loss of genes /

    ACCEPT genes still present on X

    because (most)women can’t lose a Y chromosome/

    chromosome in women

    women do not have Y chromosome (1)

    ACCEPT Y chromosome genes have a

    negative effect on the heart that are

    not present in women who lack the

    {genes / Y chromosome}

    IGNORE loss of Y chromosome

    unqualified as in stem of question

    ACCEPT reduced immune function /

    (loss of Y chromosome) genes) cause { changes/

    malfunction of phagocytes / causes

    mutations} {in cells / macrophages / named organ}

    (increased) inflammation / causes

    (increased)

    {atherosclerosis

    atheromas}

    ACCEPT Y chromosome contains

    genes

    that

    may

    prevent

    inflammation / fibrosis

    which leads to {scarring to heart / damage to heart

    ACCEPT cardiac muscle for heart

    / cancer / Alzheimer’s disease }(1)

    A description that includes the following points:

    using {gRNA / RNA sequences} complementary to

    IGNORE nucleic acids unqualified

    (specific)

    {gene

    /

    DNA

    sequence}

    (on

    Y

    ACCEPT gRNA guides {Cas(9) /

    chromosome) (1)

    endonuclease enzyme}

    ACCEPT gRNA {stimulates /

    activating} Cas9 / enzyme

    which enables {Cas(9) / endonuclease enzyme} to

    ACCEPT use of restriction enzymes

    {cut / delete} {gene(s) / section of DNA / at specific

    / RE ( in correct context)

    sequence } (1)

    IGNORE enzymes unqualified

    REJECT plasmid

    ACCEPT Cas9 cut the Y chromosome

    A description that includes the following points:

    use a (screening) questionnaire (1)

    e.g. lifestyle factor questionnaire

    using a named physiological measurement/ or

    techniques (1)

    e.g ECG /heart rate/ cardiac output/

    using a second named physiological measurement /

    or technique (1)

    blood pressure / (blood) cholesterol

    level / BMI / angiogram / ultrasound

    of heart / PET / MRI / stress test /

    specific blood markers e.g.CRP /

    blood test to detect numbers of cells

    without Y chromosome / {genetic /

    blood} screening to identify cells

    without Y chromosome

    ACCEPT compare with people{ with

    comparison with national data / perform named

    statistical test on data (1)

    Y chromosome / loss less than 40%

    of Y chromosome}

    IGNORE

    compare

    with

    healthy

    people

    An explanation that includes two of the following points:

    (antibody) binds to {ISM / ISM receptor/ growth

    ACCEPT opsonisation / agglutination

    factor / the molecule} (1)

    ACCEPT blocks ISM receptor on

    cells

    causing inhibition of {enzyme / signalling pathway}

    ACCEPT prevents {growth factor /

    ISM} binding to target cells /

    causes phagocytosis of {growth

    factor / ISM}

    {inhibiting / prevents stimulation of} inflammatory

    response (1)

    preventing ISM from binding to

    other cells and causing

    inflammation = mp2 &3

    An explanation that includes two of the following points:

    temperature acts as a stimulus (1)

    ACCEPT reference to epigenetic

    changes /named epigenetic

    changes

    causing the activation of genes for {steroid /

    ACCEPT affects activity of an

    protein /enzyme / sex hormones}(1)

    enzyme ( aromatase) / allow

    enzymes work faster / allow

    description of increase/ decrease

    enzyme activity

    IGNORE denaturing of enzyme

    which bind to {membrane / nuclear} receptors (1)

    ACCEPT

    which

    converts{

    testosterone

    /

    androgen}

    to

    oestrogen / change {T/O} balance

    ACCEPT production of oestrogen

    initiating sexual {differentiation / development /

    IGNORE determine the sex of an

    growth / development of (sex) organs / genitalia}

    animal as this is the wording from

    the question stem

    87 (%) (1)

    An explanation that includes the following points:

    X chromosome {inactivation / silencing} in

    ACCEPT All the genes on the X

    one of the female XX sex chromosomes (1)

    chromosome

    named example of epigenetic modification

    ACCEPT DNA methylation / DNA

    demethylation / histone

    modification / histone acetylation /

    demethylation of repressor gene

    Non coding RNA {coating / wrapping

    round}

    one

    of

    the

    sex

    XX

    chromosomes and deactivates it /

    forms stable Barr body

    For mps 1 and 2

    An explanation that includes three of the following points:

    bone marrow contains stem cells that differentiate

    ACCEPT gives rise to for

    into immune cells (1)

    differentiate

    some men lose their Y chromosomes in their bone

    marrow (cells)(1)

    ACCEPT less immune cells / fewer

    resulting in an impaired immune system (1)

    named immune cell / reduced

    release of cytokines / disrupted

    function of named immune cell

    ACCEPT less {destruction / killing}

    therefore no destruction of the cancer cells (1)

    of {mutated / cancer} cells

    Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828

    with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom

  • 8(a)(ii)[2]

    A calculation showing the following steps:

    NO ECF

    correct measurement of the lengths of X and Y

    X = 94 mm Y = 39 mm accept in

    chromosome (1)

    cm

    (accept +/1mm)

    ratio calculated and given in the correct format (1)

    (94÷39) = 2.4 : 1

    ACCEPT 2.5 : 1 2.3 :1

    correct answer gains full marks

  • 8(b)[2]

    An answer that includes two of the following points:

    (loss of Y chromosome) means loss of genes /

    ACCEPT genes still present on X

    because (most)women can’t lose a Y chromosome/

    chromosome in women

    women do not have Y chromosome (1)

    ACCEPT Y chromosome genes have a

    negative effect on the heart that are

    not present in women who lack the

    {genes / Y chromosome}

    IGNORE loss of Y chromosome

    unqualified as in stem of question

    ACCEPT reduced immune function /

    (loss of Y chromosome) genes) cause { changes/

    malfunction of phagocytes / causes

    mutations} {in cells / macrophages / named organ}

    (increased) inflammation / causes

    (increased)

    {atherosclerosis

    atheromas}

    ACCEPT Y chromosome contains

    genes

    that

    may

    prevent

    inflammation / fibrosis

    which leads to {scarring to heart / damage to heart

    ACCEPT cardiac muscle for heart

    / cancer / Alzheimer’s disease }(1)

  • 8(c)[2]

    A description that includes the following points:

    using {gRNA / RNA sequences} complementary to

    IGNORE nucleic acids unqualified

    (specific)

    {gene

    /

    DNA

    sequence}

    (on

    Y

    ACCEPT gRNA guides {Cas(9) /

    chromosome) (1)

    endonuclease enzyme}

    ACCEPT gRNA {stimulates /

    activating} Cas9 / enzyme

    which enables {Cas(9) / endonuclease enzyme} to

    ACCEPT use of restriction enzymes

    {cut / delete} {gene(s) / section of DNA / at specific

    / RE ( in correct context)

    sequence } (1)

    IGNORE enzymes unqualified

    REJECT plasmid

    ACCEPT Cas9 cut the Y chromosome

  • 8(d)[3]

    A description that includes the following points:

    use a (screening) questionnaire (1)

    e.g. lifestyle factor questionnaire

    using a named physiological measurement/ or

    techniques (1)

    e.g ECG /heart rate/ cardiac output/

    using a second named physiological measurement /

    or technique (1)

    blood pressure / (blood) cholesterol

    level / BMI / angiogram / ultrasound

    of heart / PET / MRI / stress test /

    specific blood markers e.g.CRP /

    blood test to detect numbers of cells

    without Y chromosome / {genetic /

    blood} screening to identify cells

    without Y chromosome

    ACCEPT compare with people{ with

    comparison with national data / perform named

    statistical test on data (1)

    Y chromosome / loss less than 40%

    of Y chromosome}

    IGNORE

    compare

    with

    healthy

    people

  • 8(e)[2]

    An explanation that includes two of the following points:

    (antibody) binds to {ISM / ISM receptor/ growth

    ACCEPT opsonisation / agglutination

    factor / the molecule} (1)

    ACCEPT blocks ISM receptor on

    cells

    causing inhibition of {enzyme / signalling pathway}

    ACCEPT prevents {growth factor /

    ISM} binding to target cells /

    causes phagocytosis of {growth

    factor / ISM}

    {inhibiting / prevents stimulation of} inflammatory

    response (1)

    preventing ISM from binding to

    other cells and causing

    inflammation = mp2 &3

  • 8(f)[2]

    An explanation that includes two of the following points:

    temperature acts as a stimulus (1)

    ACCEPT reference to epigenetic

    changes /named epigenetic

    changes

    causing the activation of genes for {steroid /

    ACCEPT affects activity of an

    protein /enzyme / sex hormones}(1)

    enzyme ( aromatase) / allow

    enzymes work faster / allow

    description of increase/ decrease

    enzyme activity

    IGNORE denaturing of enzyme

    which bind to {membrane / nuclear} receptors (1)

    ACCEPT

    which

    converts{

    testosterone

    /

    androgen}

    to

    oestrogen / change {T/O} balance

    ACCEPT production of oestrogen

    initiating sexual {differentiation / development /

    IGNORE determine the sex of an

    growth / development of (sex) organs / genitalia}

    animal as this is the wording from

    the question stem

  • 8(g)[1]

    87 (%) (1)

  • 8(h)[2]

    An explanation that includes the following points:

    X chromosome {inactivation / silencing} in

    ACCEPT All the genes on the X

    one of the female XX sex chromosomes (1)

    chromosome

    named example of epigenetic modification

    ACCEPT DNA methylation / DNA

    demethylation / histone

    modification / histone acetylation /

    demethylation of repressor gene

    Non coding RNA {coating / wrapping

    round}

    one

    of

    the

    sex

    XX

    chromosomes and deactivates it /

    forms stable Barr body

    For mps 1 and 2

  • 8(i)[3]

    An explanation that includes three of the following points:

    bone marrow contains stem cells that differentiate

    ACCEPT gives rise to for

    into immune cells (1)

    differentiate

    some men lose their Y chromosomes in their bone

    marrow (cells)(1)

    ACCEPT less immune cells / fewer

    resulting in an impaired immune system (1)

    named immune cell / reduced

    release of cytokines / disrupted

    function of named immune cell

    ACCEPT less {destruction / killing}

    therefore no destruction of the cancer cells (1)

    of {mutated / cancer} cells

    Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828

    with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.