Biology · Oct / Nov 2024 · Paper 61 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows pea seeds with growing roots. (Source: © Sangita Pal / Alamy Stock Photo) Mitosis occurs in growing roots. A scientist allowed pea seeds to start growing in different concentrations of oxygen. Pea seeds were grown in oxygen concentrations of 5% and 20%. After two days the root tips were removed. The tips were stained and observed under a microscope. The mitotic index for each root tip was determined.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)[1]
there is no (significant) difference between
Candidates will
the mitotic index at different oxygen
express this in
concentrations (after 2 days) (1)
different ways
3(b)[3]
An answer that includes the following:
suitable table format with
Allow mitotic index % or au
correct column headings and
units (1)
all data correctly entered (1)
not if units in table
means correctly calculated (1)
5.7 and 4.0
Do not allow 4
3(c)[3]
An answer that includes the
following:
mean mitotic index
bar graph with linear scale
allow % as unit for mitotic
starting at zero and axes
index
labelled, with units (1)
oxygen %
means plotted correctly (1)
ECF using the means from
3b
Allow tolerance of half a
range bars plotted correctly (1)
small square
3.6 to 4.4
5.1 to 6.2
3dii
An answer that includes the following
points:
(pea seeds grown) under 20%
oxygen have a larger mitotic
index than those grown under
5% oxygen (1)
the calculated value of t (11.33)
is more than the critical value
Allow any quoted t value and a
2.12 (1)
following correct statement for
MP2 and MP3
Allow 2.92 at 1%
significance
(therefore) reject the null
hypothesis, the difference in
the mitotic index at 5%
oxygen compared to 20%
Allow different concentrations
oxygen is significant (1)
of oxygen
3(d)(i)[2]
there is no (significant) difference between
Candidates will
the mitotic index at different oxygen
express this in
concentrations (after 2 days) (1)
different ways
An answer that includes the following:
suitable table format with
Allow mitotic index % or au
correct column headings and
units (1)
all data correctly entered (1)
not if units in table
means correctly calculated (1)
5.7 and 4.0
Do not allow 4
An answer that includes the
following:
mean mitotic index
bar graph with linear scale
allow % as unit for mitotic
starting at zero and axes
index
labelled, with units (1)
oxygen %
means plotted correctly (1)
ECF using the means from
3b
Allow tolerance of half a
range bars plotted correctly (1)
small square
3.6 to 4.4
5.1 to 6.2
3dii
An answer that includes the following
points:
(pea seeds grown) under 20%
oxygen have a larger mitotic
index than those grown under
5% oxygen (1)
the calculated value of t (11.33)
is more than the critical value
Allow any quoted t value and a
2.12 (1)
following correct statement for
MP2 and MP3
Allow 2.92 at 1%
significance
(therefore) reject the null
hypothesis, the difference in
the mitotic index at 5%
oxygen compared to 20%
Allow different concentrations
oxygen is significant (1)
of oxygen
An answer that includes two of the following
Ignore repeat the expt
points:
use different temperatures (1)
Allow within the 520%
use different oxygen concentrations
range or a wider range
Allow variety / cultivar /
use different times (1)
type
use different plant species (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(d)(ii)[3]
there is no (significant) difference between
Candidates will
the mitotic index at different oxygen
express this in
concentrations (after 2 days) (1)
different ways
An answer that includes the following:
suitable table format with
Allow mitotic index % or au
correct column headings and
units (1)
all data correctly entered (1)
not if units in table
means correctly calculated (1)
5.7 and 4.0
Do not allow 4
An answer that includes the
following:
mean mitotic index
bar graph with linear scale
allow % as unit for mitotic
starting at zero and axes
index
labelled, with units (1)
oxygen %
means plotted correctly (1)
ECF using the means from
3b
Allow tolerance of half a
range bars plotted correctly (1)
small square
3.6 to 4.4
5.1 to 6.2
3dii
An answer that includes the following
points:
(pea seeds grown) under 20%
oxygen have a larger mitotic
index than those grown under
5% oxygen (1)
the calculated value of t (11.33)
is more than the critical value
Allow any quoted t value and a
2.12 (1)
following correct statement for
MP2 and MP3
Allow 2.92 at 1%
significance
(therefore) reject the null
hypothesis, the difference in
the mitotic index at 5%
oxygen compared to 20%
Allow different concentrations
oxygen is significant (1)
of oxygen
An answer that includes two of the following
Ignore repeat the expt
points:
use different temperatures (1)
Allow within the 520%
use different oxygen concentrations
range or a wider range
Allow variety / cultivar /
use different times (1)
type
use different plant species (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
3(e)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following
Ignore repeat the expt
points:
use different temperatures (1)
Allow within the 520%
use different oxygen concentrations
range or a wider range
Allow variety / cultivar /
use different times (1)
type
use different plant species (1)
(Total for question 3 = 14 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

