Biology · Oct / Nov 2024 · Paper 11 · Question 8
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
8 The photograph shows two avocados.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
8(a)[3]
An answer that includes three of the following points, with at least one
DO NOT PIECE TOGETHER if in two
similarity and one difference:
separate descriptions.
Similarities:
both contain carbon and hydrogen (and oxygen) (1)
ACCEPT hydrocarbon chain / COOH
group
both contain covalent bonds (only) (1)
DO NOT ACCEPT ester bonds
Differences:
unsaturated fatty acids contain carboncarbon double bonds
ACCEPT saturated fatty acids do not
but saturated fatty acids have only single carboncarbon
contain carboncarbon double bond
double bonds (1)
C = C and C C
DO NOT ACCEPT saturated fatty
acids have no double bonds
8(b)(i)[11]
The correct answer is A
B is incorrect because 41701 ÷ 68786 = 0.606242549355973, so ratio is 0.6 : 1
C is incorrect because 41701 ÷ 68786 = 0.606242549355973, so ratio is 0.6 : 1
D is incorrect because 41701 ÷ 68786 = 0.606242549355973, so ratio is 0.6 : 1
*8(b)(ii)
Animal products:
how much animal products / fats / cholesterol / LDL / HDL do you consume in a week?
because cholesterol increase risk of atheroma
high HDL : LDL reduces risk of CVD
has your consumption of fatty acids decreased?
because this could reduce the risk without any avocados being eaten
Other dietary factors:
how much {fibre / vegetables / fruit / cereal} do you consume each week?
because fibre reduces cholesterol levels
how much food containing antioxidants do you consume?
antioxidants reduce damage to endothelial cells
how much salt do you consume?
high salt intake is linked to high blood pressure
how much alcohol do you consume in a week?
alcohol affects liver function / increase blood pressure / affects the LDL:HDL ratio
is your calorie consumption greater than your energy usage?
obesity is a risk factor for CVD
Avocados:
do you eat avocados every week?
did you have adverse reactions to the avocado?
because study needed to ensure that they were being eaten on a weekly basis
because part of the benefit of eating avocados is to reduce saturated fatty acids in diet
the effects of the diet need to be compared to previously
how many avocadoes do you eat each week?
to see if the number of avocadoes affect the results
Nondietary questions:
do you smoke / how many cigarettes do you smoke / do you have high blood pressure?because smoking increases blood pressure / damages endothelial liningdo you have diabetes / family history / BMI / age?these increase the likelihood of CVDLevel 0
0
No awardable content
Level 1
12
Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge and
Questions suggested, relating to nondiet CVD risk
understanding to the given context with generalised comments made.
factors with some justification
Vague statements related to consequences are made with limited linkage
to a range of scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The
1 mark = 1 question suggested
discussion will contain basic information with some attempt made to link
2 marks = 1 question suggested which does not relate to
knowledge and understanding to the given context.
diet with justification
Level 2
34
Demonstrates adequate knowledge and understanding by selecting and
Questions suggested that relate to diet with justification
applying some relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are
discussed which are occasionally supported through linkage to a range of
3 marks = 1 question which relate to diet justified
scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion
4 marks = 2 questions which relate to diet justified
shows some linkages and lines of scientific reasoning with some
structure.
Level 3
56
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding by selecting
Questions appropriate to this investigation with
and applying relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are
justifications
discussed which supported throughout by sustained linkage to a range of
scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion
5 marks = 3 questions which relate to diet with
shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of scientific reasoning which is
justification justifications
clear and logically structured.
6 marks = 4 questions which relate to diet with
justifications
8(b)(iii)
An answer that includes at least one reason for it being valid and one
NB must state if the reason makes
reason for it not being valid for full marks to be awarded:
it valid or not
Valid because :
large sample size (1)
ACCEPT converse idea for invalid
IGNORE number of men and
represents both {men and women / a range of ages} (1)
women were different
ACCEPT longitudinal study
IGNORE healthy
ran for {a long period of time / 30 years} (1)
participants had no signs of CVD or stroke (1)
Invalid because :
no control group (1)
no indication that {lifestyles are similar / there were no (other)
ACCEPT named lifestyle
underlying diseases} (1)
lifestyles not controlled
other factors that increase
risk of CVD difficult to control
{diets / number of avocados} not controlled (1)
ACCEPT frequency of questionnaire
responses to questionnaire {are subjective / may not be
is low / questionnaire is every 4
truthful} (1)
years
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

