Biology · May / June 2024 · Paper 61 · Question 4
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
4 When seeds germinate, starch is broken down and used as a respiratory substrate to provide energy for growth. Respiration rate can be measured using a simple respirometer. A student knew that mung beans germinate very quickly and wanted to compare the respiration rate in germinating mung beans with the rate in germinating peas. They formed the following hypothesis: Germinating mung bean seeds will have a faster respiration rate than germinating pea seeds. Plan an investigation to find evidence to support or reject this hypothesis.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
4(a)[3]
A description that includes three of the following:
find a suitable pretreatment for seeds (1)
Accept soaking time / number of times to
rinse seeds /other valid example
Accept temperature / light
find suitable conditions for
wavelength/daylength
{germination/growth/respiration} of seeds (1)
find a suitable time for seeds to (start)
{germination/growth/respiring} (1)
Accept time to produce a measurable
find a suitable timescale to measure distance moved by
change of gas
bubble (1)
find a suitable {number / mass} of seeds to
obtain a measurable rate/quantity of gas
4(b)[8]
An answer that includes eight of the following:
clear statement of the dependent variable
Accept
distance moved by bubble (in respirometer) in given time /
volume of oxygen/gas used in given time
suitable method for preparing seeds (1)
Accept soaking / rinsing / surface sterilisation etc
use of a carbon dioxide absorber (1)
E.g soda lime /KOH/NaOH
Not sodium hydrogen carbonate
seeds left to equilibrate/acclimatise (before
data collection) (1)
Accept distance moved by bubble in given time / volume
description of data collection in a given time
of gas collected in syringe
calculation of rate described (1)
E.g distance / volume divided by time
identify one abiotic variable to be controlled
and description of how it is controlled (1)
Accept: temperature / wavelength of light
Ignore pH
one biotic variable identified (1)
Accept age of seeds / mass of seeds / variety of seeds
use both types of seed in the investigation
4(c)[3]
A description including the following
Accept distance moved by bubble (in given time)
raw data table with headings and units, with
Accept additional columns eg volume of oxygen
means calculated from repeats (1)
used / rate of respiration
Accept description of calculating mean
Do not accept units in the body of the table
suitable graph with labelled axes (1)
Accept distance moved by bubble / volume of
oxygen used / rate of respiration
use of an appropriate statistical test (1)
MP2 and 3 usually a bar graph and a stats test
for difference
OR a line graph of time intervals
4(d)[3]
An answer that includes three of the following:
if mung beans germinate more quickly than peas the
highest respiration rate may be at different times after
soaking (1)
It is hard to control {age/viability}of seeds (1)
Accept older seeds may have a lower
{germination rate / respiration rate}
Accept if some seeds do not germinate this will
affect the result / reduce the respiration rate
Seed may change from aerobic to anaerobic
respiration (1)
errors in { reading position of bubble on
scale/measuring volume of gas} (1)
germinating seeds produce heat so hard to control
Accept changing temperature will affect
temperature (which affects rate of respiration) (1)
position of bubble on scale
(Total for question 4 = 17 marks)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

