Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2024 · Paper 41 · Question 8

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

8 The Bajau people are nomadic people who free‑dive in the waters around the Philippines, Malaysia and Indonesia. They have been travelling around these waters on house boats for over 1 000 years. They can free‑dive to depths of 70 m for as long as 13 minutes, spending 60% of their working time underwater. The photograph shows a Bajau free‑diving, without breathing equipment. (Source: © Marko Reimann/Alamy Stock Photo) Scientists measured the size of the spleens of the Bajau people and a related group of people called Saluan. The Saluan people live on the mainland of Indonesia and do not free‑dive. The genomes of the two groups of people were analysed.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 8(a)[4]

    An explanation that includes four of the following points:

    (because a large spleen) can {store / release} {more / a lot of} {red

    DO NOT ACCEPT {store / release}

    blood cells / oxygen} (1)

    of blood

    oxygen {dissociates from the haemoglobin / diffuses out of the red

    blood cells} (1)

    (delivering / providing) oxygen (to the cells) for aerobic respiration (1)

    ACCEPT muscles can contract for

    allowing the seals to stay {underwater / dive} longer (1)

    longer

    e.g. prevent buildup of lactic acid

    credit an advantage of this (1)

    seals can escape predators

    seals can find food

  • 8(b)(i)[1]

    The only correct answer is B

    A is incorrect because the mean is the sum of all values divided by the number of values

    C is incorrect because mode is the most common value

    D is incorrect because standard deviation is a measure of variance

  • 8(b)(ii)[2]

    A description that includes two of the following points:

    ACCEPT converse

    {median / middle} size of spleens of Saluan people is smaller (than

    the Bajau people) (1)

    ACCEPT some Saluan have larger

    (some) Bajau people have larger spleens than any of the Saluan

    spleens than the Bajua

    people (1)

    there is a greater {range / spread / variation} in the sizes of

    spleens in the Bajau people than the Saluan people (1)

    *8(c)

    Aspect 1 : how spleens became enlarged

    mutation may have occurred

    in gene coding for {spleen size / ability to store more red blood cells}

    spleen size maybe polygenic / multiallelic

    so wide range of spleen sizes

    selection pressure for larger spleens

    {increased chance of survival / more food / more oxygen in body} acted as a selection pressure

    Aspect 2 : advantages of large spleens

    large spleens allowed the Bajau people to dive for longer

    as more oxygen was supplied to their cells

    when they were holding their breath

    enabling them to spend more time hunting under water / not returning surface

    and therefore catching more food

    increasing their chances of survival

    Aspect 3 : how the allele frequency increased

    natural selection

    those who survived were more likely to reproduce

    passing the alleles onto their offspring

    offspring more likely to survive

    repeated over many generations

    increasing the frequency of the allele in the population

    Aspect 4 : interactions with divers and nondivers / lack of interactions with Saluan people

    Bajau people did not reproduce with Saluan people

    because the Bajau people lived in house boats / Saluan people lived on the main land

    therefore the alleles not introduced into this population of people

    or if it was it became diluted

    diving and nondiving Bajau people reproduced together

    therefore the allele for large spleens was present in both divers and nondivers

    Level 0

    0

    No awardable content

    Level 1

    12

    An explanation may be attempted but with limited interpretation or

    Simple comments / explanation

    analysis of the scientific information and with a focus on mainly just one

    piece of scientific information. The explanation will contain basic

    1 mark = simple explanation of one aspect

    information, with some attempt made to link knowledge and

    understanding to the given context.

    2 marks = simple explanation of two aspects

    Level 2

    34

    An explanation will be given, with occasional evidence of analysis,

    Some extended explanation

    interpretation and/or evaluation of both pieces of scientific information.

    The explanation shows some linkages and lines of scientific reasoning,

    3 marks = extended explanation of one aspect

    with some structure.

    4 marks = at least two aspects covered which includes

    extended explanation of one of the aspects

    Level 3

    56

    An explanation is made that is supported throughout by sustained

    Extended explanation clearly linked to size of spleen

    application of relevant evidence of analysis, interpretation and/or

    evaluation of both pieces of scientific information. The explanation

    5 marks = extended explanation of two aspects

    shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of scientific reasoning, which

    is clear and logically structured.

    6 marks = coherent extended explanation of three aspects

    Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828

    with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom

  • 8(c)[6]

    An explanation that includes four of the following points:

    (because a large spleen) can {store / release} {more / a lot of} {red

    DO NOT ACCEPT {store / release}

    blood cells / oxygen} (1)

    of blood

    oxygen {dissociates from the haemoglobin / diffuses out of the red

    blood cells} (1)

    (delivering / providing) oxygen (to the cells) for aerobic respiration (1)

    ACCEPT muscles can contract for

    allowing the seals to stay {underwater / dive} longer (1)

    longer

    e.g. prevent buildup of lactic acid

    credit an advantage of this (1)

    seals can escape predators

    seals can find food

    The only correct answer is B

    A is incorrect because the mean is the sum of all values divided by the number of values

    C is incorrect because mode is the most common value

    D is incorrect because standard deviation is a measure of variance

    A description that includes two of the following points:

    ACCEPT converse

    {median / middle} size of spleens of Saluan people is smaller (than

    the Bajau people) (1)

    ACCEPT some Saluan have larger

    (some) Bajau people have larger spleens than any of the Saluan

    spleens than the Bajua

    people (1)

    there is a greater {range / spread / variation} in the sizes of

    spleens in the Bajau people than the Saluan people (1)

    *8(c)

    Aspect 1 : how spleens became enlarged

    mutation may have occurred

    in gene coding for {spleen size / ability to store more red blood cells}

    spleen size maybe polygenic / multiallelic

    so wide range of spleen sizes

    selection pressure for larger spleens

    {increased chance of survival / more food / more oxygen in body} acted as a selection pressure

    Aspect 2 : advantages of large spleens

    large spleens allowed the Bajau people to dive for longer

    as more oxygen was supplied to their cells

    when they were holding their breath

    enabling them to spend more time hunting under water / not returning surface

    and therefore catching more food

    increasing their chances of survival

    Aspect 3 : how the allele frequency increased

    natural selection

    those who survived were more likely to reproduce

    passing the alleles onto their offspring

    offspring more likely to survive

    repeated over many generations

    increasing the frequency of the allele in the population

    Aspect 4 : interactions with divers and nondivers / lack of interactions with Saluan people

    Bajau people did not reproduce with Saluan people

    because the Bajau people lived in house boats / Saluan people lived on the main land

    therefore the alleles not introduced into this population of people

    or if it was it became diluted

    diving and nondiving Bajau people reproduced together

    therefore the allele for large spleens was present in both divers and nondivers

    Level 0

    0

    No awardable content

    Level 1

    12

    An explanation may be attempted but with limited interpretation or

    Simple comments / explanation

    analysis of the scientific information and with a focus on mainly just one

    piece of scientific information. The explanation will contain basic

    1 mark = simple explanation of one aspect

    information, with some attempt made to link knowledge and

    understanding to the given context.

    2 marks = simple explanation of two aspects

    Level 2

    34

    An explanation will be given, with occasional evidence of analysis,

    Some extended explanation

    interpretation and/or evaluation of both pieces of scientific information.

    The explanation shows some linkages and lines of scientific reasoning,

    3 marks = extended explanation of one aspect

    with some structure.

    4 marks = at least two aspects covered which includes

    extended explanation of one of the aspects

    Level 3

    56

    An explanation is made that is supported throughout by sustained

    Extended explanation clearly linked to size of spleen

    application of relevant evidence of analysis, interpretation and/or

    evaluation of both pieces of scientific information. The explanation

    5 marks = extended explanation of two aspects

    shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of scientific reasoning, which

    is clear and logically structured.

    6 marks = coherent extended explanation of three aspects

    Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828

    with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.