Biology · May / June 2024 · Paper 41 · Question 2
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 Two students, student P and student Q, each cultured bacteria in a liquid medium for 20 hours. The culture conditions used by both students were identical. Every two hours, each student removed a sample of the culture to count the number of bacteria. Each student used a different method to count the number of bacteria in the samples. The graph shows the bacterial growth curve that each student drew using their results. 12 student P 10 8 Log10 number of bacteria 6 per cm3 4 student Q 2 0 0 4 8 12 16 20 Time / hours
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)(i)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
because we do not want {other bacteria in the culture /
ACCEPT microorganisms / pathogens
contamination of culture} (1)
ACCEPT to ensure only the test bacteria
as they could {give an overestimate of the number of bacteria
/ compete for nutrients
are used
/ produce toxins (to the bacteria being cultured)
competition for space
/ as they could be pathogens} (1)
OR
ACCEPT prevent infection / contamination
because we do not want to transfer the bacteria onto
of person
{ourselves / surroundings} (1)
as they may be {pathogenic / harmful} (1)
NB Prevent infection with pathogenic
bacteria = 2 marks
2(a)(ii)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
ACCEPT pathogens / microorganisms / spores
e.g.
technique described (1)
working by a bunsen burner / safety hood
technique explained (1)
+
to create an updraft / to move the
microorganisms in the air away / to prevent
bacteria falling into culture
IGNORE kill bacteria in the air
autoclaving {agar / culture fluid / equipment}
using sterile equipment
disinfecting work area
washing hands
+
to kill any bacteria present
reducing exposure of cultures to air / keep lid
on plates / close {doors / windows}
+
to reduce bacteria falling into cultures
2(b)[2]
3.2 (1)ACCEPT log 5.2 – log 2 = 3.2
ECF 0.3 / 0.34 / 0.345 = 1 mark
3 / 2.7 / 2.66 / 2.658 (1)Bald answer of {3 / 2.7 / 2.66 / 2.658} = 2 marks
Bald answer of 2.6578073089700996677 {incorrectly
rounded up to three decimal places max / correctly
rounded to more than three decimal places} = 1 mark
Bald answer of 3.2 = 1 mark
Bald answer of {0.3 / 0.34 / 0.345} = 1 mark
2(c)(i)[1]
63 / 63.1 (: 1)OR
0.02 / 0.016 (:1)
2(c)(ii)[2]
An answer that includes the following points:
NB both mark points but the wrong way
round for 1 mark
ACCEPT haemocytometer / Neubauer
(student P) {cell counts (not using an exclusion dye) / optical
methods / turbidity / absorption of light / colorimeter / counting
chamber
living and dead
chamber} as total cell counts (1)
IGNORE calorimeter
ACCEPT {haemocytometer / Neubauer
(student Q) {dilution plating / colony counting / counting chamber
chamber} using an exclusion dye
using an exclusion dye} as only living cells counted (1)
named exclusion dye e.g. eosin
/ trypan blue
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

