Biology · May / June 2024 · Paper 31 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows jujube fruits. (Source: © Aneeta Benwan-edam/Alamy Stock Photo) Jujube fruits are edible and are native to China. Jujube fruits do not store well. An investigation compared the effect of covering the fruit with an edible coating. One coating was made from chitosan, a polysaccharide obtained from the outer skeleton of shellfish. Another coating was made from cinnamon oil. Samples from stored fruit were tested for vitamin C content and antimicrobial activity.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[2]
percentage decrease of fruit coated with chitosan calculated
34.69387755, or any correct rounding
(34.6938776, 34.693878, 34.69388,
34.6939, 34.694, 34.69, 34.7) for the
calculation
ACCEPT 35 for one mark only
difference calculated correctly and given to given to 2
e.g. 43.75 – 34.69 = 9.06
significant figures (1)
= 9.1 to 2 sig figs
Incorrect rounding at any
intermediate stage can only have 1
mark.
3(a)(ii)[4]
An answer that includes the
following points:
Aaxes correct (x time, yVit Conc,) (1)
Lboth axes labelled withsuitable title and units (x,
Time / days, y, Vitamin C
content of fruits coated
with cinnamon oil / a.u.
points plotted correctly onlinear scale (1)
appropriate line of best fit3(a)(iii)[3]
A description that includes the following points:
repeat {for all 3 groups / experiment} (1)
IGNORE formula
(calculate) mean and standard deviation (1)
ACCEPT SD
ACCEPT find
ACCEPT range bars
plot (mean and) {standard deviation / error bars} (on a
ACCEPT present in a table described
graph) (1)
e.g. with SD column
3(a)(iv)[3]
A description that includes three of the following points:
describe method to standardise coating method (1)
e.g. dip in it for standard time / do as
done in original investigation / same
concentrations as in original
investigation
repeat the investigation under the same conditions as
ACCEPT e.g. temperature, length of
time, 60 days, size of fruit, type of
before (1)
fruit
use of DCPIP (1)
IGNORE colour change
description of titration (1)
e.g. titrate dropwise / using burette /
pipette
3(b)(i)[2]
A description that includes the following points:
take readings at the (bottom of the) meniscus (1)
ACCEPT reverse argument
hold the pipette at eye level when taking the readings (1)
ACCEPT avoid parallax error
ACCEPT perpendicular
3(b)(ii)[1]
1 × 105 / 1.0 × 105
ACCEPT 1.105
1.0 .105
3(b)(iii)[2]
An explanation that includes two of the following points:
ACCEPT harmful, disease causing for pathogenic
IGNORE irritant, allergy
IGNORE to kill microbes
{aseptic technique / description of aseptic technique} toACCEPT infection
avoid contamination of {cultures with other bacteria /
ourselves with bacteria (which could be pathogenic)} (1)
ACCEPT taped vertically
{leave the lid loose / only partially seal lid} (of Petri dishonto base) so that {conditions are aerobic / anaerobic
bacteria (which could be pathogenic) do not grow} (1)
ACCEPT forming pathogenic
growing bacteria at temperatures {slightly below 37°C /no higher than 35°C / body temperature} to decrease
growth of pathogenic bacteria (1)
3(b)(iv)[3]
An answer that includes the following points:
different types of agar used as bacteria and fungi haveACCEPT food
different nutritional requirements (1)
higher temperature for bacteria because the {enzymes /ACCEPT reverse argument
ACCEPT enzyme / metabolism optima different
metabolism} of bacteria have a higher optimum
(temperature than the enzymes of fungi) (1)
ACCEPT reverse argument
fungi cultured for longer as they have a slower {growth /reproductive} rate (than bacteria) (1)
ACCEPT growth rates different
ACCEPT fungi take more time to grow
3(b)(v)[4]
An answer that includes the following points:
uses {a range / more than one species} (ofmicroorganism) / bacteria and fungi} so conclusion is
(more) representative
uses only four microbes so conclusion is notrepresentative (1)
no {data given for uncoated fruit / control} so do notknow if either coating has an (antimicrobial) effect (1)
ACCEPT the differences are small so cannot
no {error bars / SDs / repeats} so cannot judge if thejudge if the differences are statistically
{differences are statistically significant / there is no
significant
measure of variability (1)
measures diameter, direct area measure would be betterbecause zone not always circular (1)
no indication of concentration of coating substance so maynot be {representative / optimal} (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

